Hanson: Why Don’t These Guys Grow Up?

The music business is always looking for the next big thing, be it a new singer, group or style of music. The trend now is toward youthful performers, such as Grammy Award-winning country singer LeAnn Rimes (14) and the alternative rock band Silverchair (ranging in age from 15 to 17). Then there’s the Nirvana-wannabe band Radish, whose 15-year-old lead singer/songwriter recently signed a $2 million contract with Mercury Records.
The newest, uh, kids on this teeny-bopper block are Hanson, a trio composed of brothers Isaac (guitar), Zac (drums), and Taylor (keyboards) Hanson. They’re blonde and pretty and, at first glance, appear to be a group of pre-pubescent girls.
Cute Band Alert
Hanson’s youthful “grunge lite” appearance makes for a good marketing gimmick-after all, teenage girls make up a large record-buying demographic. The cute-boy-band market has been tapped before (The Monkees and Menudo were literally made for it), generally resulting in big money for the music industry and a lot of mediocre music for record buyers.
Which brings us to Hanson’s debut album, Middle of Nowhere. The first single, “MMMbop,” is about relationships. In it, lead singer Taylor Hanson advises listeners to “Hold on to the ones who really care” because “In an mmmbop they’re not there.” The rest of the lyrics are equally cheesy. As for the music-the single was produced by the Dust Brothers, who also worked on Beck’s Odelay, which may explain the rather lame-sounding record scratching tricks heard throughout the song.
Catchy Tunes, Cheesy Lyrics
The first cut on the album, “Thinking of You” showcases Taylor’s high, cracking, adolescent voice, which makes it sound as if he were on the verge of puberty while the album was being recorded. The song itself is of the predictable pop/rock variety, with multi-tracked vocals and a catchy chorus that’s easy to sing along with (“Ride the wings of an eagle/Glide along with the wind/No matter how high/I’ll be thinking of you the whole time”).
The song “Where’s the Love?” also has a radio friendly chorus: “Where’s the love?/It’s not enough/It makes the world go round and round.” The addition of funky classic-rock style guitar playing that sounds a bit like some of Bon Jovi’s more uptempo stuff makes it mildly interesting.
“Speechless,” which is about a two-timing girlfriend, made me chuckle with lines like, “I see what you’re doin’ behind my back all the time/I get suspicious when you call me someone else’s name/You think I don’t notice that nothing’s the same?” These lyrics are humorous when you remember that it’s a 13-year-old singing them.
The album also includes some token ballads (like “Yearbook,” a slow and sappy song about a lost friend) and, of course, a breakup song (“Lucy”). After all, every pop/rock album hoping to go platinum must have these essential (and utterly unoriginal) elements, right?
Professional Help
Overall, the album has a polished, highly produced sound. The Hanson brothers are credited with much of the songwriting, but eight of the album’s 12 tracks were co-written by professional “song doctors.” I recognized one of them, Desmond Child. He wrote hits for several ’80s rock and metal bands, including Alice Cooper and KISS.
And, even though the brothers are credited with playing some of the guitar, keyboard, and drum parts, 22 additional musicians also perform on the album. Unfortunately, the album’s liner notes fail to mention which tracks they appear on. Listening, I often wondered whether it was actually the Hansons who played some of the more professional sounding instrumental sections. Hmmm…
It is always going to be an event when a group this young releases an album. Heck, at age 11, when I could have been cutting my first record, what was I doing? Wasting my time watching TV and playing air guitar. So I acknowledge Middle of Nowhere as an impressive attempt for such young kids. Unfortunately, all it does is recycle the same old bubblegum pop cliches. Like their predecessors New Kids on the Block, Hanson does the “cute boy band” thing very well, but that isn’t saying much.
Live a Little, First
In my opinion, 20 should be the minimum age for releasing an album. Unless you’re singing on the Barney soundtrack or possess true musical genius of the Mozart variety, you should wait until you have gained some experience in this complicated thing called life before thinking you can write songs about it. I’m sorry, but I’m sick and tired of hearing baby singer-songwriters moan about how hard life is when they haven’t even had time to experience many of its difficulties.
If you enjoy catchy tunes with radio-friendly melodies, then Hanson may just fit the bill. But if you are like me and prefer music that is a little more original and has a little more depth, then look elsewhere. Time will tell if Hanson is more than another passing trend; in my opinion, they have a long way to go before they stake a lasting claim in popular music.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.