Rent Control: Fight Now or Pay Later

Most teenagers dream of graduating high school, getting a job, moving out of their parents’ house and into a place of their own.
But if the current rent laws are not renewed by June 15 of this year, as the governor and many other city and state officials would like, that may be harder than ever to do.
Currently, there are 1.2 million apartments in New York City that are either rent controlled or rent stabilized. These laws were set up to protect tenants from greedy landlords during a big housing shortage after World War II. They set limits on the amount of rent landlords can legally charge for a given apartment and prevent them from kicking someone out when his or her lease is up.
The state senate must vote on whether or not to preserve these protections before June 15, otherwise they will expire and landlords will be free to do pretty much whatever they want.
The Way It Works Now
Rent control is the older of the two laws, and applies to people in older buildings who have been living there continuously since 1971, mostly senior citizens. Under rent control your rent is fixed and can only be raised if the landlord makes a special petition to the New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal (DHCR).
Rent stabilization covers buildings built between 1947 and 1974, that have six or more apartments. Under stabilization, tenants are automatically offered the choice of a new one- or two-year lease when their current lease expires. The DHCR limits how much landlords can raise the rent on these new leases-usually it can’t be more than around 4 or 6 percent. With rent stabilization, if any of the tenant’s rights are violated, the DHCR can even lower her rent.
Other rights that are up for grabs right now are succession rights and the Senior Citizen Rent Increase Exemption. Succession rights say that if the parents die or move out, the apartment automatically goes to the children-as long as they’re over 18 and have been living there constantly for a number of years (usually two). The senior citizen’s exemption prevents elderly people on a fixed income from having their rents raised. Even State Senate Majority Leader Joseph L. Bruno, who is very much for doing away with these laws, said that he would consider leaving this particular regulation in place.
It’s Not a Free Market
Some politicians such as Bruno, and Governor George E. Pataki think that rent regulations are hindering the development of new housing in New York City, and doing away with these laws would solve that problem. They say that the reason more investors don’t want to invest their money in building housing is because it’s not a free market. As long as there are millions of apartments out there with artificially low rents, they believe, even landlords who aren’t covered by the rent laws can’t charge as much as they might otherwise be able to. In a December press release Senator Bruno said the rent regulations were “the single, greatest impediment to creating new housing opportunities for New Yorkers.”
Republican state and city officials feel that if the regulations are done away with, developers will invest in building and renovating more housing and that the rents wouldn’t necessarily skyrocket.
Forcing People Out Of Their Homes
But others believe that ending rent regulations would mean that landlords will charge tenants unbelievably high “market rates,” prices only the richest people could afford. This could result in working and lower class tenants losing their apartments and even winding up on the street. “This is losing your right to stay in your apartment,” said Bill Rowen, a coordinator of the campaign to save the rent laws for the Metropolitan Council on Housing.
Rowen said that ending the rent regulations would lead to a dramatic increase in the homeless population and that many people will also leave the city for neighboring states like New Jersey, where the cost of living is cheaper. If any of these things were to happen, it could have a very negative effect on the city’s economy.
Why Young People Should Care
A lot of people probably think that this issue won’t affect them because they don’t pay rent. Well, let me tell you, it will. If you get money from your parents, they’ll probably have less of it to give you (unless they’re landlords). If you move out it could be almost impossible to find an apartment you can afford. And who knows what else?
Even when they know an issue is important to them, young people often don’t fight because they don’t think anyone is listening. That’s not necessarily true. Politicians play to the people that vote. It’s a well-known fact that not a lot of 18- to 30-year-olds vote, so obviously politicians aren’t going to waste their time on young people. What they’re looking for is job security.
It’s just like if you want a good grade; you’re not going to do really good work for teachers you don’t even have. That would be a waste of your time because they have no power over you. And that’s what the politicians think. They think we don’t have power, but we do, and we have to start using it.
Get Involved!
Even if you’re too young to vote, that doesn’t mean you’re helpless. There are other things you can do. Fight for what you want: petition, write letters, go to rallies. And for anyone who says that rallies don’t make a difference-they do. When the people you’re trying to send a message to can look out of their office windows, and physically see just how much opposition they might be facing, it makes them see just how insecure their jobs might be.
People who do not want to see their right to affordable housing taken away only have until June 15 to do something about it. For more information contact your state senator or:
Governor George Pataki, Executive Chamber, Albany, NY 12224 212-681-4580
Senate Majority Leader Joseph Bruno, 270 Broadway, N.Y., NY 10007 212-417-5550
Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver, 270 Broadway, Rm. 1807, New York, NY 10007 212-312-1420
To get involved, contact the Metropolitan Council on Housing, 102 Fulton St., Rm. 302, New York, NY 10038 or call 212-693-1553
And most importantly, if you’re over 18, vote! You have to let the government know that they can’t just take away your rights without a fight.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.