I get tired of watching these 20-something love stories that all seem to have been written by Jerry Seinfeld and directed by Ben Stiller. All the young characters are stupid and naive. They don’t know what they’re looking for in a relationship, but the sex is great because that’s what sells tickets. Even John Hughes’s teen romances (The Breakfast Club, Sixteen Candles, Pretty in Pink) were better than most of the movies out now.
Don’t get me wrong, it’s not like I hate romantic movies; if I see one that’s not mocking my intelligence, I can really get into it. Carried Away, for example, is a refreshing love story with actors who keep it real by depicting true-to-life situations that can happen to an average Joe. Even though the characters it portrays are much older than I am, I could relate to them.
Seduced By a Teenager
The story revolves around Jonathan (Dennis Hopper), a 47-year-old man who lives on a farm, milks the cow every morning, takes care of his sick mother and teaches high school. He’s been in love with Rosalee (Amy Irving), who teaches grade school kids in the classroom across the hall from his, since he was 18. Everything in his life is routine, including their relationship. Bourbon and scotch are the only exciting things in his life.
Then he meets his new student, 17-year-old Catherine Wheeler (Amy Locane). Jonathan is smitten by her soft-spoken voice and slim figure. When her rich dad wants to rent his stable so that Catherine can keep her horse there, Jonathan agrees. It isn’t long before Catherine seduces the older man who is losing half of his hair and will be collecting social security in 20 years.
His True Love
After that, Jonathan’s almost living a double life. Catherine makes him feel young and that he can do anything, but their relationship is only sexual. Rosalee, on the other hand, is the love of his life and his best friend. She speaks to the mature side of him and also brings out his sense of humor.
I felt a lot of sympathy for Jonathan. I’ll admit that he is a weak little pervert because he can’t control his hormones when a 17-year-old gives him the eye. On the other hand, this young girl who every boy in class likes is attracted to him and that must make him feel desirable. You can say he’s wrong for having an affair with one of his students, but for me, the worst part is that he cheats on Rosalee.
Complex Characters
The good thing about Carried Away is that the characters are three-dimensional. For example, in one scene, Rosalee’s in a bar with Jonathan, playing dice with the bartender to see who should pay for the drinks. When she wins, she says, “Well, son of a b-ch, I guess the drinks are on you.”
I was surprised to see this mild-mannered school teacher drinking and cursing. She turns out to be tough and funny and quirky. You wonder why Jonathan is bored with her. But she can also be emotional. When she finds out about Jonathan’s affair, she cries, “I can’t believe you did this to me. I dedicated my whole entire life to you!”
As for Jonathan, he shows his sensitive side when he plays piano with his sick mom but he can also be angry and sarcastic. There’s a scene where the school board denies him a new job in a city high school because he never went to college, even though he’s been teaching for years. They’re giving him a hard time and he blurts out that they’re “a-holes.”
The characters are complex, which makes you take them seriously and get emotionally involved in their lives. I really cared about what was happening to them. Watching the scene where Jonathan at first declines to sleep with Catherine but then turns back to accept her offer, I gasped.
It’s About Change
Although I like both Jonathan and Rosalee a lot, I have very mixed feelings about the character of Catherine. She’s messed up because she comes from a bad home which is sad but common (and she is rich too so boo-hoo). She also showed herself to be intellectual at times with her philosophy of “letting your true talents show” which helps Jonathan get out of his boring daily routine. And, in the end, Jonathan’s affair with her also helps him get closer to Rosalee.
But it isn’t a serious love triangle. Catherine is constantly seducing Jonathan to get her way; their relationship is like a power trip for her, which annoyed me. I felt sorry for her and at the same time I couldn’t care less if she moved back where she came from.
I can’t tell you what a relief it was to catch a movie that didn’t bore or frustrate me. Finally, a movie that dealt with a real taboo love problem-the age difference. I especially liked how it showed that Jonathan’s involvement with Catherine isn’t just about physical attraction, it’s about his need to escape from his boring life to something exciting.
Carried Away is about change-change in yourself, change in the way you love another person. And it shows that change can be for the better, even when the circumstances are harsh. A good movie like this comes out very rarely, just like a meteor. You’re lucky if you see one in your lifetime.
“Carried Away”: An Escape from the Routine
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.