“Before and After”: A Teen on Trial

The suspense-thriller Before and After is so gripping that I’m willing to see this movie a second time.
This powerful drama is about 16-year-old Jacob (Edward Furlong), a boy who is on trial for the brutal murder of his girlfriend.
Jacob’s girlfriend is found dead at the side of the road, and since Jacob was the last person to see her alive, the police consider him a suspect. But Jacob’s parents, Carolyn and Ben (portrayed by Meryl Streep and Liam Neeson), and his sister Judith (Julia Weldon) don’t believe for one minute that Jacob killed her and they are willing to protect him at all costs.
A stream of townspeople would beg to differ; they are convinced of Jacob’s guilt. The plot is original in my opinion because I have never seen a story where a boy is accused of killing someone and the whole town wants him to suffer in the slammer. The protests make the family depressed, distraught and scared. And the movie shows how this case, and deciding what to do about it, puts a strain on the family.
Lawyer-Client Conflict
After Jacob is arrested, Carolyn and Ben hire a high-class lawyer named Panos Demeris, brilliantly played by Alfred Molina. I liked this character a lot. He is extremely frank and to the point with Jacob’s parents, and that makes the movie more entertaining. Because he is so blunt, Demeris is able to get Carolyn and Ben angry at him, which gives a boost of excitement to the mostly low-key mood of the film.
In one scene, Demeris sits down to discuss the case with them over a sandwich, then has the audacity to flash a picture of the bloody and mutilated victim while munching on his hero. This not only offends Jacob’s parents, it ticks them off as well. And they give him a piece of their minds. But Demeris is very nonchalante in response to their anger. He is only interested in getting his client off.
Did He DoIit?
He tells Carolyn and Ben something like “the system is not about compassion. If you don’t like me now, you’re not gonna like me when I have to defend your son. And you definitely won’t like the prosecution.”
Most movies that I’ve seen don’t show any conflict between lawyers and their clients. This was one of the most interesting things about the movie. Without it, Before and After probably would have seemed ordinary to me.
I didn’t find the ending to be such a surprise, but Before and After did have a pretty suspenseful storyline. As I watched, I was asking myself, “Did Jacob do it? If not him, then who?”
The movie had one weakness. I was under the impression that the story would be told with narration because at the beginning, the introduction is told by Jacob’s sister in a voice-over. This narration stops and then doesn’t continue until after Jacob’s trial at the end of the film. But if I were writing the film, I probably would have included more narration to show more about what Judith thinks about the whole situation. (She seems to know a lot more about Jacob and his girlfriend than Ben and Carolyn do.)
Still, despite the one weakness, I really liked Before And After and I think that anyone who likes suspense should go see this movie.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.