“From Dusk Till Dawn”: One Big Waste

If Hollywood were ever to make a list of commandments, the first would definitely have to be: all the talent in the world can not make a bad story into a good movie.
Such is the case with Robert Rodriguez’s newest picture, From Dusk Till Dawn, where you have an excellent director and an extremely talented group of actors (most of whom actually deliver pretty good performances) but you also have a lousy story line.
At the start, From Dusk Till Dawn appears to have all the makings of another Rodriguez hit. In the tradition of his first two movies, El Mariachi and Desperado, it has the quirky characters, the action, the humor, some more action, and a suave hero (who in this case starts out as a villain, I think).
Some Jokes and Some Murders
The villain/hero, Seth Gecko, is played by Facts of Life and E.R. star George Clooney. He and his brother Richard (Quentin Tarantino), a deranged sex-offender, rob a Texas bank and then set out for Mexico with the Texas Rangers, the FBI, and practically every other Southwestern crime-fighting force on their tails.
Up to this part I’m OK. While in Texas, Clooney and Tarantino kill a few people and crack a couple of jokes. There are some real good scenes, the most memorable being the one where a local boasts about how the brothers Gecko are holding a 9-0 lead in murders over the law enforcement agencies that are chasing them.
Then the brothers meet Jacob Fuller (Harvey Keitel), a former priest on his way to Mexico with his two kids Kate (Juliette Lewis) and Scott (Ernest Liu) in an attempt to regain his faith. The Gecko brothers kidnap the family, hoping to use them as fronts to get into Mexico.
Crossing the Border
As soon as the Fullers arrive on the scene, you can see the movie start to run out of gas. Keitel and Lewis, who are both exceptional actors as a rule, add nothing to this movie. As a matter of fact they hurt it, because they play their characters in a totally emotionless way. They’re so calm when the Geckos kidnap and threaten to kill them that they make the entire situation seem like some type of game.
When the characters finally arrive in Mexico, Rodriguez dips into his bag of Mexican stereotypes, and the screen becomes engulfed with tequila-drinking, knife-wielding bar patrons in search of a good time. Not only that, but what at first seems to be a harmless strip joint turns into a den of vampires.
Attack of the Vampire Strippers
The whole second half of the movie is horrendous as it quickly changes from a serious action film to a “t&a” grade B horror movie. As the Titty Twister Band plays its hard rock version of mariachi music, bare-chested waitresses stroll across the screen serving drinks to a barful of truckers and bikers, many of whom seem to be American, not Mexican (must be a by-product of the NAFTA agreement). As for the movie’s climax, just call it Attack of the Vampire Strippers.
Although you don’t get completely lost watching this movie, the change of genres is pretty confusing. Not to mention pointless.
A Lousy Screenplay
The explanation for why this movie is so bad is simple-a lousy screenplay. Why was it produced? Either Rodriguez is intent on proving that his direction can salvage even the worst scripts, or Quentin Tarantino, who wrote the screenplay, is trying to prove that his name is so big that anything he does will become a hit. If this is the best script he’s capable of these days, he should concentrate on acting and directing and leave the writing to the pros.
If you have $8 to waste, by all means go and see this. If not, go see Heat or Casino and find out how real professionals make movies.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.