Guy Likes, Guy Gripes, Stupid Quizzes: Teen Mags Need a Makeover

Kissing: Are You Doing It Right?
Back off! How to Stop A Boyfriend Snatcher
Long Hair: Do You Have the Guts to Cut?
The shelves of newsstands are filled with magazines for teenage girls. On the covers are pictures of girls who never look like anyone you know and the titles of stories about fashion and beauty.
I started to read Teen when I was 12 or 13. I had stacks of them. I thought what was in them was what my life would be like as a teenager. If I wanted information on college, health, sex, or jobs it would all be there. But the only thing I learned was how to shave my legs.
YM, Teen, Sassy, Seventeen…The names are different but the contents are always the same: page after page of thin, White girls groping boys.
“Hit on Him,” “Guy Search,” and “Boy Magnet Beauty,” articles from YM and Sassy last summer, tell you how to get boys, how to dump boys, and how to look good for them. You get the impression that the editors think that a girl’s world wouldn’t exist without a boyfriend.
Boys, Boys, Boys
The March ’95 issue of Seventeen had an article about “Guy Likes and Guy Gripes.” In the July ’95 issue of Teen, guys mouthed off about kissing and how they want girls to look. But in all the magazines I looked at for this article I didn’t see a single article where they asked girls what they look for in a guy or a relationship. The closest they came was a quiz in the March 1995 issue of Seventeen: “Are You Obsessed with Him?”
Teen magazines are full of these little quizzes: “Do You Need a Mood Makeover?” (Sassy, September ’95) and “Are You a Drama Queen?” (YM June-July ’94) to name a couple more examples. In the “mood makeover” quiz you pick two answers from 16 choices and they tell you what your mood is. In the “drama queen” quiz there are 10 multiple choice questions. If you score over 24 points you qualify as a drama queen. Who cares?
As for the photographs, I know lots of girls-heavy girls, short girls, girls whose skin isn’t perfect-who don’t look anything like the ones in these magazines. Why don’t we ever see photos of girls who look like them?
In the back they have ads for the perfect powder puff, modeling schools, clothing clubs and a telephone number to talk to the stars. I don’t want to send some personal message to celebrities. At $2.98 per minute, they can just guess what I think about them.
Serious Stories?
I occasionally do see articles about important topics such as teen motherhood, but there are usually only one or two per issue. And even when they do try to focus on something important they tend to trivialize it.
The February 1995 issue of Seventeen, for example, had an article entitled “Sobriety High” about a high school for teenagers who have addictions to drugs and alcohol. It described girls putting makeup on and picking through 400 pounds of clothes piled on their floor to get ready for school. The reporter described a coffee shop popular with students where waiters wear “lederhosen and green felt hats.” I don’t know much about fashion, but I do know that what waiters wear has nothing to do with teen alcoholism.
The main problem with the article was that there wasn’t any emotion in it. “The school doesn’t have enough money for a janitor, so the students pitch in to keep it clean,” it says. If it had been an article about boys who surf they might have cared more about getting the details.
Clueless Editors
No matter how good or bad they are, these articles are almost always the shortest ones in the magazine. The May 1994 issue of Teen had a one page article about sexually transmitted diseases and, a few pages later, a three page story called “Coolest Coastal Hangouts.” Do the editors think that where to go body surfing is more important than a girl’s health?
After reading the issue, I now know which beaches are paradise and very little about the symptoms of AIDS, what kind of cancers it causes, and how to prevent infections. Instead of telling you how to get an HIV test, they offer readers quizzes about being drama queens, boy-obsessed, and moody.
I still look at teen magazines from time to time, however, just for fun. But in my four or five years reading them, I’ve learned that the editors don’t have a clue about the real lives of girls or anything else I care about.

SIDEBAR: What Girls Want Reported
Crystal Whittaker, 13, of I.S. 195, has been reading YM, Teen and YSB for only a year but is already getting tired. “They’re full of garbage,” she said. “I read this story about Keanu Reeves. He runs around [the house] in his underwear.” Crystal says if it were up to her the magazines would be more “realistic…I would have real facts about sex, peer pressure, drugs, HIV, STD’s.” Dawn Garcia, 20, of Nassau Community College, agreed. She’s read Seventeen “once or twice” and wasn’t impressed. “They focus more on your hair, makeup, your weight,” she said. “They should focus more on education-college, not just high school.” What bothers Helene Sola, 18, of City College, who also reads Seventeen from time to time, are how thin most of the models are. “I wouldn’t glorify skinny people; skinny people suck,” she said, although she swore she was only kidding. Helene and her friends laugh at some of the outfits they wear. “We kid around,” she said. “We say, ‘[I] can’t wear that. My boobs are too big.’ ” She added that if it were her magazine, “I would go to the Salvation Army and show how you can get clothes for five bucks, not expensive outfits.” Another thing she doesn’t like are the “stupid” little quizzes. “They’re [too] general,” she said. “You can’t tell anything from them.” Ruby Thomas, 18, of George Washington University, has been reading YM and Seventeen for five or six years. In general, she says they seem “believable,” but the one thing she thinks is “real dumb” is the “girlfriend/boyfriend crap” in every single issue. “They think everyone has a boyfriend,” Ruby said.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.