Murphy Brown, Roseanne: I Find My Role Models On TV

During this Women’s History Month, we celebrate those gutsy women who have overcome obstacles and prejudices faced by females in society and, in the process, set examples for the rest of us. We celebrate…those intrepid women of TV.
Yes, TV. Though you may not realize it, the women of TV have evolved right along with their counterparts in American society. In the 1950s when the average woman was deemed fit to be nothing more than a dear, loving housewife and perfect mother, TV moms like June Cleaver on Leave it to Beaver were in.
However, over time, the ladies of TV-land have changed into what are now the brassy and bold women of the ’90s. We have Murphy Brown and Roseanne. Amanda on Melrose Place. Erica Kane on All My Children, Elaine on Seinfeld, and the sisters on the show Sisters.
Instead of getting weepy whenever something bad happens to them, these women get even. Instead of settling for a life depending on others, they stand up for themselves and pursue their dreams, no matter what it takes. These women have replaced getting satisfaction solely from pleasing others with steely determination to please themselves.
Of course change happens slowly, and there are still women on TV who unfortunately maintain a passive presence. But they’re no longer perfect moms. Now we have bimbos: Kelly and Peg Bundy, the big-haired mother-daughter pair on Married with Children, and the baby-faced, baby-brained female lifeguards of Baywatch.
Nevertheless when I turn on the set these days, I can usually find a role model. One of my personal favorites has alway been Murphy Brown, a tough, get-the-story-no-matter-what-it-takes reporter for the fictional news show For Your Information (FYI).
My Kind of Reporter
In her infamous interviews Murphy’s done things most of us (men and women) only dream about doing-like tearing apart congressmen and making executives of huge companies cry and faint. She’s even gotten into fist fights with other reporters during Presidential press conferences, just for the sake of getting the scoop first!
In the past on such shows, it was the male reporters we saw in the thick of things while the women did cheesy stories on Barbie conventions. Murphy lashes back against this stereotype and uses her brain, not her body, to outdo many of the males in her field. She may be a little raw and tough at times, but let’s face it, being a successful woman in a competitive field such as journalism requires a special edge.
Murphy serves as a role model even in the world of her show. Her fellow reporter, Corky Sherwood, started out as a sickeningly naive former Miss America, covering ground-breaking stories on cheese and cows. Over time, however, she’s evolved into a savvy reporter, covering prime stories with a ruthless vengeance-thanks to Murphy’s influence.
Not Your Meek Little Housewife
Roseanne Connor of Roseanne shatters yet another stereotype: the meek little housewife. With a wise-cracking sense of humor and cynical realism, she redefines the role. As a mother, she chooses to tackle her children’s problems head on, instead of pretending they’re just not there.
When she finds out her daughter Becky has gotten drunk, Roseanne doesn’t lecture her. Instead, she pretends that drinking is OK and by playing along, she shows that alcohol really makes you a nobody, not a somebody.
And when Becky tells her she is going to become sexually active, Roseanne doesn’t start spouting the virtues of abstinence. She escorts Becky directly to the gynecologist to get birth control pills, but also advises her to wait a little while before taking the big plunge.
And Roseanne has never been just a housewife. She’s always had to work to help support her family. Her jobs have included factory worker and waitress. These days she owns and runs a diner with her sister Jackie, while at the same time caring for her family AND preparing for a new baby. Is she hardworking or what?
Unfortunately, a Few She-Monsters
There are still a lot of conflicting messages in TV-land, though. Women who have power are often portrayed as ruthless and bitchy, although many possess convictions and an intense desire to achieve their goals that all women can identify with.
Amanda Woodward on Melrose Place is renowned for her backstabbing, seductive, manipulative ways. With her business smarts and determination, Amanda has snagged a top executive position at L.A.’s prestigious D&D advertising agency, plus she’s the landlord of the building on Melrose Place where she and the other characters live.
Of course I’m not sure I would want to be her best friend. I mean, Amanda has vindictively seduced the boyfriends and husbands of many women. She has threatened and insulted any female who even remotely intrudes on “her turf,” meaning both her latest boyfriend and her powerful position at D&D.
In fact, Amanda’s the perfect example of how any woman who possesses even a minute amount of power in TV-land is portrayed as a disgusting she-monster, even though a woman can be kind and gentle and still effectively use her power. As much as I love Murphy Brown, she, too, can be really abrasive, although her character has been softened somewhat over the years.
Can You Be Strong and Sensitive?
Then there’s Erica Kane of the daytime soap opera, All My Children, who has gone from child bride to career woman. Along the way, Erica has gotten married 11, yes e-l-e-v-e-n, times. Her smorgasbord of husbands has included a dashing All-American hunk, a rich, sneaky millionaire and her present husband, a handsome, filthy rich Hungarian count who owns a sprawling estate.
But don’t think that Erica depends on her husbands for money. A successful model, she at one point ran her own makeup company, Enchantment, until it was ruthlessly taken over by her assistant, Alec.
Erica does have her negative points: she jumps from one man to the next and manipulates each one in the way that suits her best. Over the years, however, she’s changed from an annoyingly giggly, husband-dependent girl to a shrewd businesswoman who’s making it as a 40-something model and who realizes that all she needs from a man is his love, not his money.
Many, if not most, of these TV characters are exactly what today’s real life females want to be: strong, intelligent, determined women. I just have one suggestion for them: calm down. While it’s great for women to show their strength by being more tough and rugged, there is nothing wrong with still being sensitive and caring at the same time.
Being a strong woman doesn’t have to mean denying who you are, it just means making sure everybody else knows that you’re also a force to be reckoned with. Now let’s just tell that to the (mostly male) TV producers!

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.