Attention all music fans! Be on the look out for a “comeback” of sorts. I ain’t talking about washed up rock stars, old school rappers or tired old R&B singers who hack their psychic friends on television. Matter of fact, it isn’t even a person. I’m talking about records, otherwise known as vinyl.
This comeback was officially declared when Pearl Jam’s most recent album Vitalogy made it to #36 on the Billboard charts based on vinyl sales alone. So now vinyl, which has spent the last few years as a zombie (half dead/half alive) has become the thing of the moment.
Some of the reasons cited for vinyl’s resurgence are that records last longer than tapes and CDs, that it makes a great collectible, and that the cover art is better because the artist has more room to draw. But if I was you I wouldn’t get carried away with this “rebirth of the record” because, like all trends, it won’t last.
First off, using Pearl Jam as evidence for how vinyl is being reborn is a very bad idea. Pearl Jam fans are a legion of fanatics that will buy anything Pearl Jam makes. If Pearl Jam made an album of nursery rhymes it would go platinum on fan sales alone (many of the fans who bought Vitalogy on vinyl ALSO bought the CD and the tape). What other group besides Pearl Jam has cracked the Billboard charts on vinyl sales alone?
Who Buys Albums for Cover Art?
Also, vinyl isn’t as hot as it is made to look. Some of the reasons used to explain its superiority over CDs and tapes are superficial and sentimental. For instance, while it is true that vinyl art usually looks better than the art on CDs and tapes, this is not always the case. Nirvana’s In Utero album has an excellent piece of art that wasn’t done in the vinyl format.
Besides, art is not the reason why people buy albums. An album could have stickman art on the cover and be phat while the one with an Andy Warhol cover might be nothing but garbage. The real reason why people buy albums is because of the music, which brings me to my third point.
Walkman, Discman. . . Vinylman?
The reason why vinyl was put on its deathbed in the first place was because people wanted more portable, clearer music. They could either have developed the “Vinylman” which when carried on your back would give you portable sound (not to mention spinal problems) or go the Walkman and Discman route. Guess which was chosen?
Vinyl collectors forget that the reason why tapes and CDs started kicking vinyl’s butt is that they are far more versatile than vinyl. You can copy music onto tapes off the radio (can’t do that with vinyl). You can select what songs you want to listen to on CDs by pushing a button, while with vinyl you run the risk of getting a scratch every time you move the needle to the song you want. And CDs hold more music than vinyl (which explains the bonus songs you often get) and also sound clearer (though some vinyl fans say they sound sterile).
Another superficial complaint of vinyl fans is that CDs cost much more than vinyl and that you’re charged much more for a CD than it costs to make. I’m sorry to break it to you sweethearts but all music mediums have an incredible markup over what they cost to make (it’s about the same thing as buying M&Ms at Carnegie Hall).
What this all breaks down to is that, for most people, buying vinyl in these days and times just isn’t worth it. Many stereo companies don’t make record players anymore so, unless you already have one, buying vinyl seems self-defeating. And even if you have a phonograph you would need Indiana Jones to help you search for a store that still sells record albums.
Fanatics and Geezers
CDs and tapes may have their faults and those of us who have ever had to untangle tapes or gotten fingerprints on CDs know this. But, with proper care, CDs and tapes are still a much better deal than records.
I expect this vinyl craze to end in a couple of weeks or months (maybe even before this article goes to press!). Of course, vinyl still will have its uses. It makes a much better Frisbee than a CD and many DJs out there need vinyl for their trade (unless you know one that spins CDs). Serious collectors and geezers will probably stick to vinyl even when this “rebirth” is over. But for us average music listeners vinyl is as dead as Elvis (although some people will insist that he’s still alive too).
Vinyl Is History
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.