A Rap Fan Experiments: Making Room for Nirvana

While I was growing up, the only music anyone ever listened to in my house was rap and r&b. I shunned rock. It was alien to me.
That started to change about three years ago, when I was 16. I was watching TV and Nirvana’s video “Smells Like Teen Spirit” came on. I remember the thunderous guitar riffs and bass lines. I remember the lead singer’s voice which reminded me of a banshee’s wail. I didn’t understand a word he was saying but I didn’t give a damn. “I like a rock song,” I said to myself. These words are not usually uttered by a hardcore rap fanatic.
I didn’t tell anyone in the house that I was starting to like rock. I would have felt like I was turning my back on an old friend. Think about when you were younger and you had one best friend in the world. Then you got older and made more friends and didn’t have as much time for your best friend. That’s how crossing over musically made me feel. How could I betray my best friend? How could I leave rap?
Headbanger Vmit Nise?
Meanwhile, I was hearing more mention in the media about Nirvana and their style of music. It seemed like this sound was getting big and part of me wanted to be involved with it. But another part of me felt that there wasn’t room in my musical taste for headbanger vomit noise. How could I be devoted to rap and grunge at the same time?
I started to get my answer while watching Video Music Box’s Alternative Thursdays one day. They played rap that was different from your run of the mill LL Cool J or EPMD. You know, guys like Me Phi Me and P.M. Dawn, whose raps didn’t always rhyme and whose videos included weird imagery like puppets onstage or synchronized swimming.
Nirvana’s “Come As You Are” came on. I was shocked. I didn’t remember the Box playing rock before. And I liked it. The bass line was enchanting and lead singer Kurt Cobain’s voice was hypnotizing. There are some songs where you can press the stop button without a care, but others you have to hear all the way through. This was one of the others. I couldn’t stop listening.
Gradually I came to a realization. If Video Music Box could make room for both rock and rap, so could I. My musical taste had room the size of a warehouse; I had just never bothered to fill it.
Was I Betraying Rap?
So I admitted it to myself. I loved Nirvana. If I heard one of their songs on the radio, it got my complete attention. I still didn’t tell anyone in my house, or at school. What would they think? I could imagine it now. “I love Nirvana!” Everyone would take off their rap-blasting headphones, stop reciting their favorite rap lyrics and stare at me with accusing eyes.
Support came in the form of my English teacher, Mr. Eiferman. He was a kind of hippie from the ’60s, and would sometimes talk about the latest in rock. Once he brought in a VCR and showed us an Unplugged show that featured some rap artists. Then he started to rewind the tape so he could show us the most popular group of that year-Nirvana. Everyone else in the class was less than enthusiastic, but I couldn’t wait. Then the bell rang. I was horrified.
Listening In On the Down Low
The next day I asked Mr. Eiferman if he could make me a tape of Nirvana’s latest album. (I didn’t even know the name of it.) He agreed and offered to include their first album Bleach. I said no. I was taking this musical transition slowly. I was only interested in the current album. He brought me the tape the next day. I couldn’t wait to get home and listen to it.
As soon as I got in the door I headed straight for the tape deck. Then I paused. I wasn’t the only one who lived in the house. What would everyone else say? So I closed the door and played it at a low volume. I heard the opening guitar riff to “Teen Spirit” and then braced myself for the bass and the beat. I felt like swinging my head violently back and forth.
After the first song I stopped the tape and rewound it, afraid of what else Nirvana had in store for me. Then I realized I couldn’t be afraid anymore to show people I loved the music. My mother was out shopping and only my brothers and sisters were in the house. They were never afraid to blast the music they loved. I turned the volume up and braced myself again-this time for my family’s reaction.
Exposed!
The music blasted. No one opened the door. I felt tense, waiting for something to happen. Then the door opened. My brothers Aaron and Austin peered in the door, looked at me, looked at the tape deck, looked at each other, looked at me again, and then slowly closed the door. I didn’t feel comfortable.
The next song came on and at first it reminded me of heavy metal. I didn’t know if I could get used to this. My youngest brother Alton came in and stood in the doorway. He took a seat and started singing the words. I never saw Alton so interested in music unless it was Michael Jackson or the theme to Ghostbusters. Then I started singing. Then we both started to air guitar. I started to relax. I wasn’t alone.
Nirvana opened my mind up to other music that wasn’t related to rap. My friend Jessica made me a copy of Pearl Jam’s Ten and I started subscribing to Rock Video Monthly, which sends me a VHS tape of 10 new alternative videos every month. In addition to my old faves, A Tribe Called Quest, Red Man, and Wu-Tang Clan, I also started listening to Pearl Jam, The Lemonheads, Eve’s Plum, and Stone Temple Pilots. I was reborn.
So, to my fellow rap fans, I say: Give alternative music a chance. If Nirvana is not your cup of tea, there’s Stone Temple Pilots, Smashing Pumpkins, Soundgarden, Alice in Chains and a lot more I probably don’t know about. You don’t have anything to lose except a closed-minded attitude about music.

SIDEBAR: Good-bye Kurt
On April 8th, 1994, I was listening to Nirvana’s album Nevermind. I listened to it three times. I paid special attention to the songs “Teen Spirit,” “Breed,” “Lounge Act” and “Something in the Way” because Kurt Cobain’s voice on those songs is spellbinding. I was lost in Nevermind-land all that day. Late that afternoon I went out to the store. When I got back in the door, my nephew Charlie told me that Nirvana was dead. I knew it must have been Cobain that he was talking about but I didn’t want to believe it. I sat and waited until the news came on. It was true. Kurt Cobain, 27, dead from a self-inflicted gunshot wound. A lot of people made fun of the thing, calling him “Kurt Nobrain” and other things. But I was shocked, hurt and a little depressed. I knew he was a junkie and he was having problems with his wife. I don’t know what kind of person he was because I never met him. What I admired was his songwriting and musical abilities. That should have been enough to make him want to go on because he made a lot of people happy. But I don’t know what was going through his mind, so who am I to judge? Kurt Cobain never knew me, but he changed me. Because of him, I learned to appreciate new forms of music. And his morbid lyrics and banshee wail gave me a place to go when I felt depressed or lonely. May he rest in peace wherever he is, and may we all strive harder to be stronger than he was.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.