Is there tension among teenagers because of differences in musical taste? According to Eric, a 19-year-old college student, who listens to rap, punk, and indie rock, there definitely is.
“The kids that listen to rap and hip-hop, they come up to you and make fun of you,” he said. “Sometimes they even wanna fight you. A group of kids stepped to me and tried to take my hat. So I took one of them and pinned them up against the wall.”
This wasn’t the only time Eric was hassled.
“I was walking down the hall with my poppy red hair and a bunch of kids were like, ‘Hey, look at the headbanger, let’s go surfin’ dude, and after we can smash our heads on the punk-rock,’ ” he says.
“There’s lots of condescending kids who call ya sh-t so they could feed their egos,” agrees Jaime Jantz, 18, who listens to punk and hardcore.
In her school, Jaime was considered an outcast by the other students because of her music. “I think that’s why I had few friends in high school. They make you feel unwelcome. They give you a feeling of isolation.” For Jaime, “they” were the jocks and conservative kids.
Carlos, 17, who goes to City-As-School HS in Manhattan, has had similar experiences.
“Say like I’m listening to my Walkman and they say, ‘What’s that you’re listening to?’ and you say punk-rock, they get the image of you killing your mother and father or something,” says Carlos.
Kareem Wilson, 17, a resident at a boy’s group home in Staten Island who is into rap, says, “Yo, in school, there’s this group with this group and that group with that group. To, me though, they all look the same. Except those kids with the freaky colored hair. What’s up with that?”
David Hu, 17, of Christopher Columbus HS, talking about his school in the Bronx, also sees musical cliques that create barriers between teens.
“Outside of school there’s usually a group of White kids who try to act Black. And there’s like people who listen to rap across the street,” David says.
Negative Stereotypes
“You walk into the lunchroom and all the rappers are over there, and all the white preppies are over here,” notes Eric about his school. “Everyone is in sections. It’s a group security thing.”
This tension comes from stereotypes associated with each kind of music, and rap, which seems to dominate in popularity over other types of music, receives a lot of negative stereotypes.
“All hoodies are really ignorant and violent and dangerous,” claims Malcolm, 16, from Curtis HS on Staten Island, “and want to beat me up.”
Carlos says that he also stereotypes kids who listen to rap music because of their
attitudes.
“Their attitude is just a ‘bad ass’ attitude,” he says. “The lyrics talk about killing people because they ripped ’em off. And talk about f-cking girls every night.”
“Most of the hoods hang out together,” Carlos continued. “They have a one-track mind. And fashion becomes so important to them. They feel it’s a way to be accepted. Some of them think that they’re better than everyone, but they’re just ignorant.”
But rap isn’t the only music that is stereotyped.
“Preps who listen to mainstream music are all brainwashed, controlled, uncreative, unoriginal asses,” says Eric.
“Most of the time I think that jocks are idiots because all they want to do is get laid to music like the ‘Humpty Dance’ and Ton-Loc,” says Jaime.
“Those kids with the hair, they do crazy drugs right?” Kareem replies, when asked if he has any stereotypes about his peers.
“I think that all ravers are stupid,” says Malcolm, “like burn-outs.”
Dissing Grunge
So we all worry about being judged, but at the same time a lot of us judge others because of their music.
“I knock on anyone who doesn’t like what I like,” admits Jaime. She says she puts down other people “so I don’t have to look little in their eyes.”
“I mostly dis grunge because it’s stupid,” admits Carlos.
“We be bustin’ on them headbanger guys all the time. Yo, I don’t know, they’re funny,” says Darius Leonard, 17, from Staten Island.
“Country-Western is so far removed from anything that I listen to that I have to crack a joke about it every now and then,” says Eric.
Since music plays such a big part in our lives, it is very important for many of us to be with other teenagers who share our musical interests.
Easier to be Down
“Well, no one wants to hang out with someone who can’t understand where they’re coming from. People do it for security,” says Darius.
“If their musical taste is obvious, and I can see that they’re a person that I could relate to, then it’s easier for me to be down with them,” says Eric.
For Jennifer, 17, “It’s easier to hang out with someone who listens to your to your type of music. If not, we just don’t relate.”
All these stereotypes obviously cause problems in how we relate to each other. If everyone stereotypes each other’s interest, then we automatically dis(like) what is new to us.
“What people don’t understand, they fear. Then they get preconceived ideas about what a person is based on the type of music they listen to,” says Jennifer.
And what they fear, they’ll close themselves off to.
“We assume that everyone who listens to the same type of music acts and thinks the same way as the artist,” says Eric. “All the different music…seems to tell kids to do different things, and each music has an image that goes along with it. They all conflict.”
The issue of musical diversity and the tensions it causes may seem small in comparison to all the other problems that we face as teenagers, but we are a generation that stands for change, strength, and positivity. It’s up to us to break the barriers and be accepting of all.
“I think that people should learn more about everybody,” says Freedom Tripodi, 20. “And if we do it through music, then we could have so much fun.”
“We need to understand each other. Music is the universal language,” agrees Kareem.
“I think it’s ignorant, because we’re all young people going through the same things,” says Malcolm.
“The kind of music someone listens to…is a reflection of what they’re into as a person,” concludes Jaime. “But…no one takes the time to get to know someone below the surface.”
“Hey, look at the headbanger…”: How Music Keeps Us Apart
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.