When you start applying to colleges one of the big decisions you have to make is whether you want to go away to school or stay at home.
I always thought I wanted to go away. It seemed more glamorous to me because no one (like your parents) is there to supervise you and tell you what to do. But lately, staying home has started to sound pretty good. Since I’m an only child I depend on my parents a lot. If I stayed, at least I’d always have them there to back me up, not to mention feed me and wash my clothes.
After talking to some college students about their experiences I learned that both going away and staying at home have their pros and cons. You just have to figure out what’s right for you.
Doing Your Own Laundry, Making Your Own Decisions
For many people going to college means that they’re not kids anymore. They start to feel and act more adult. This is especially true if you go away. Slade Anderson, 19, of SUNY/Oneonta said now that he isn’t living at home he has to remember to do things for himself that used to get done for him.
“I have to do my laundry at a particular time,” Slade said. “And if I don’t do it I won’t have clothes to wear.” He also has to change his sheets, pick up his mail, and keep his checking account balanced.
Loretta Chan, 18, of SUNY/Albany is having the same experience. “I’m learning to clean up after myself,” she said. But Loretta doesn’t really mind having more responsibilities because she also has more freedom than if she had stayed home. “If I had stayed I would have a curfew,” she said. Elisha Spencer, 18, of Virginia Union University, agreed that one of the good things about going away is “you don’t have to listen to no one.”
People who live at home while they go to college admit that they are less independent. They may want their parents to start treating them like they’re adults, but it usually doesn’t work out that way.
‘You’re Still Our Baby’
Claude Fravien, 20, of Brooklyn College, said that even though he works and pays for school himself, “When you stay at home…you’re somewhat controlled by your parents.” Karina Sang, 19, of Hunter College, agreed. “My parents have loosened up since I’ve been to college…[but] as long as you live with your parents, your parents still view you as their baby.”
Others said that having their parents around was one of the good things about staying home. When I asked Yelena Dynnikov, 18, of Queens College, if she was missing out on anything by not going away to college, she said, “Of course I’m missing something. I’m missing that empty feeling in my stomach, [the] feeling [that] you’re alone. Your mommy’s gone…your friends are gone.”
Jennifer Morales, 19, of New York University, said what she’s missing is “being on my own.” But she also said “that can wait till later. I don’t feel I’m ready.” Karina agreed that staying in New York has been the right choice for her. “I can’t see myself making a life away from home,” she said.
Dorm Life 101
But homesickness doesn’t seem to be a big problem for people who went away. They all had things they missed-boyfriends, little sisters, old hangouts-but for the most part they were enjoying themselves. In fact, some of them felt guilty because they don’t miss home enough. “My mother just complained last night that I don’t call her enough,” Slade said. “I felt bad.” I guess when you’re trying to gain your independence you can’t please everyone.
The people who went away said that dorm life can sometimes substitute for family life. Slade said that “you make friends pretty fast when you live in a dorm.” As Elisha Spencer put it, “The people you see in class, you don’t just see them in class. You see them everywhere because you live with them.”
Loretta said that everything you do at college can become a social activity-“you meet people in your dorm when you’re doing laundry,” as well as in classes, at the campus center (where everyone hangs out), and through other people. And, if you get bored, Slade said, “You can go around dorm rooms and talk to people, play cards, and rent movies.”
Peace, Quiet, and Nothing To Do
On the other hand, campus life is usually not as exciting as life in New York City. Of Albany, Loretta said, “It’s dead here on weekends” with only one dance club to go to. She also complained about having to “walk two miles to a drug store.”
Students who went away did have some good things to say about the slower pace of college towns. “It’s much quieter,” said Slade. “Not half as many cars. No gridlock.” Dana Steinberg, 20, of the University of Maryland, agreed. “It’s clean,” she said. “People are respectful. [Drivers] actually stop for pedestrians…it’s not as crazy [as New York].”
For people who stayed in New York, one of the big advantages of going to school here is that it’s so ethnically and racially diverse. Karina Sang said that “At Hunter, there are people from all over the world. If I went away, I probably wouldn’t have that experience.”
Andrea Facey, 20, also of Hunter, agreed. She said you can see how diverse the school is just by going to the cafeteria. “They serve Haitian, Chinese, White, Jamaican food…they try to cook what everyone likes,” she said.
That diversity is one thing that people who went away to school said they missed about New York. Loretta, for one, is very aware of being in the minority on her campus. “I’m Chinese,” she said, “everyone here is White.” (SUNY/Albany is actually 69% White.)
Stay At Home, Save $$$
Another benefit of staying in New York is that it can be a lot cheaper than going away. Andrea Facey applied to some out-of-town schools but now she’s glad she decided to go to Hunter because it’s keeping her out of debt. “My boyfriend goes to Rochester,” she said. “He took out loans…I didn’t have to…I feel going away makes no sense.”
Elisha Spencer agreed that cost was one of the downsides of going away. “Your money’s tight…[your] money goes faster.” In addition to tuition fees, you have a lot of other expenses. You have to pay rent instead of living at home for free and you have to buy a lot of things for your room. “I wish I [had known] a lot of the stuff you need,” Elisha said. “When you’re in a dorm you need everything because you’re not at home.”
Another reason for staying in New York is…you get to stay in New York. Some people just can’t imagine living anywhere else. “I’m a city girl,” said Yelena Dynnikov. “I would miss New York City too much.”
Yelena loves it here so much that she even made fun of people who choose to go away to school. “What are they studying?” she wondered. “How to milk cows?” Jennifer Morales agreed that New York City is “the best place to go to college.”
Staying in New York can also be a thing of convenience. Yelena chose Queens College because “I live a block away. I just get up an hour before class and run over.”
So how do you decide whether to stay or go? Everyone I spoke to said you have to think about what’s important to you. If you like late night Chinese take-out and crowded subways, you may not be happy in a small town. If you can’t stand rush hour traffic and pushy street vendors (like me), maybe it’s time for a change from big city life.
The other thing you should do is find out as much as you can about the schools you’re considering before making a decision. “I’m a big believer in visiting the college,” Jennifer said. She realized how important that is when a friend of hers went away to a school she had never visited and discovered that she didn’t like it. “She ended up transferring to a school in New York,” Jennifer said.
Choosing a College: Should I Stay or Should I Go?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.