Think about your local comic shop. All the crisp, mint condition comic books sitting on the stands. The employees who are eager to get into heated discussions with you about new storylines. Discovering those great bargains in the discount section. Oh, the joy and peace.
By now, I’ve probably turned off most of our female readers. I mean, how many females have you seen in comic book shops? How many do you know that collect, or even read comics? I sure don’t know any that do. Why is that?
“I read books,” said Rosa Ng, 17, of Brooklyn Tech HS, “but, like, comic books are stupid.” Felisha Lawson, 16, of Harry Van Arsdale HS, agreed. “Comic books are flat and corny,” she said. June Lau, 17, of Brooklyn Tech HS, actually went into a comic book store, but she didn’t like what she found. “I flipped through a comic book and I saw pictures everywhere, and I thought,’Wow, how do people follow this?'” she said.
These girls are not alone in their attitude. Employees of Forbidden Planet, a large comic book store in Manhattan, say that only 10 to 20% of their customers are female, and most of them are buying gifts for males. The ratio of female to male customers is about the same at St. Mark’s Comics, also in Manhattan, according to owner Bruce Cutler.
Guns and Muscles
There are a number of reasons why comic books don’t appeal to girls as much as they do to guys. For one thing a lot of girls are turned off by the typical characters and storylines. As Bobbie Chase, an editor at Marvel Comics of such books as Ghost Rider and The Incredible Hulk put it, “Comic books are historically superhero, superpower fantasy, which males are more interested in than women.”
Action/adventure comics full of characters armed with huge muscles and complex weaponry certainly don’t appeal to June Lau. “The cover page will be dark and gloomy,” she said. “Very violent, very unattractive.” June doesn’t think that appeals to most girls but, “guys like violence, guys like to see blood and gore.”
Aris Iliopoulos, an employee at Forbidden Planet, said that women aren’t raised to be interested in those kinds of stories. “Little girls play with dolls, little boys are into superhero type things,” Iliopoulos said. He explained that a lot of comics are about “a bunch of guys running around with guns” or “two guys beating the crap out of each other. “I don’t know how that appeals to women.”
Sexy or Sexist?
Another thing that may turn girls against comics is the way women are portrayed in them. “I think most comic books are sexist,” said John Heneghan, another employee at Forbidden Planet. “All the female characters are dumb and don’t do things but look pretty in bikinis.”
Santos Perez, who owns a comic book stand across the street from the Prospect Avenue subway station in the Bronx, agrees. “What turns most girls away from certain books is the way women are drawn…[they’re] drawn provocatively…women in G-strings and tight suits, which may appeal to the male readers, but honestly turns a lot of females off,” he said.
For example, Psylocke, a female character in X-Men known for her martial arts skills, wears a skin tight, sleeveless blue leotard cut high at the thighs with high boots and blue ribbons twirled around her legs and arms. Like most female characters in comics, she is very well-endowed physically. That bothers Frances Sims. “They exaggerate on body parts,” she said of comic book artists. Sarah Clement, 16, of James Monroe HS, agreed. “Be realistic, all women are not like that,” she said.
But Bobbie Chase of Marvel doesn’t believe that the way comics are drawn is sexist. “Both male and female anatomies are exaggerated in comics…I don’t think the women are exaggerated more than the men, I think the men are exaggerated just as much,” she said.
Girls Who Kick Butt
Chase also defended the female characters, saying they did a lot more than just look sexy. “There are women in Marvel Comics that are leaders of their own businesses, are the leaders of superhero teams, who are portrayed as successful and smart professionally, and they don’t just stand around waiting for the men to act.”
There is proof enough of this in the X-books, like X-Men and X-Factor. The female members of the X-Men are just as prominent as the male members. The leader of one of the X-Teams is Storm, an African woman who can control the weather. Another Marvel comic, Silver Sable, is about a female mercenary and business woman.
And if you want to find female characters who are just as tough and violent as the males, Santos Perez recommends Image Comics’ Wild C.A.T.S. “If they open this book they would see two or three girls kicking butt,” he said. But even these characters wear provocative clothing that graphically shows off their figures.
One reason why the art and storylines seem to be so male-oriented is that the comic book industry is dominated by male writers and artists. “There are no females working in superhero comics,” said John Heneghan of Forbidden Planet. Abby Wohl, 18, another employee of the store agreed:”Most comics are written by man and for man.”
Still a Man’s World
Bobbie Chase of Marvel informed me that her company has one female artist, Jan Duursema, who has drawn some X-Men books and also worked on Hawkworld for DC Comics. But that’s it. There are a few more female writers in the industry, like Ann Nocenti who wrote Daredevil for Marvel and Jo Duffy and Louise Simonson, who wrote for DC’s The Death Of Superman. But the bare truth is that almost all comic books are created by men. “I’d like to see one comic written, drawn, and produced by women, like a women label,” said Abby Wohl.
Even though they are in the minority, there are at least a few female comic book readers and collectors. What do they like to read? The comic book vendors I interviewed said that, in general, girls prefer comics that go outside the mainstay of superhero, muscles and machinery, good vs. evil material. They tend to like comics with soap opera-type plots or ones that deal a lot with fantasy.
Almost everyone I interviewed mentioned Sandman, part of DC Comics’ Vertigo line, as a women’s favorite. The Sandman character has the power to give people dreams. Aris Iliopoulos, of Forbidden Planet, called Sandman an “adult” comic and said that of girls read it “like crazy.” Bruce Cutler of St. Mark’s Comics called Sandman an example of “how thoughtful comics can be.” Also popular with female readers are Love and Rockets, a soap opera-like comic set in South America, and Marvel Comics like X-Men and The Incredible Hulk, which also have soap opera elements, according to Bobbie Chase.
What Do Women Want?
Still, these are exceptions. If comic books are to become as popular with girls as they are with guys, a lot has to change. Abby Wohl suggested that the comic companies “Look for more women writers and artists.” Santos Perez recommended that the companies “Have some marketing researchers get in the comic shops and ask the girl readers what they want.” Sarah Clement said they should introduce some new plots, “like women beating up the men and no sexy stuff…” They could also try out some new characters. “Put out female heroes, they always portraying male heroes,” said Felisha Lawson.
Some of these changes are starting to take place. The New York Times recently reported that a number of new comics featuring females as the stars are being introduced this year, including DC’s Catwoman, Supergirl, and Black Orchid and Dark Horse Comics’ Ghost and Barb Wire. And Bobbie Chase said that Marvel has been “toying around with the idea of doing a romance comic.”
And the comic book merchants I interviewed seemed confident that the number of women readers is going to increase. “Women reading comics is the fastest growing part of our industry,” Cutler said. Perez agreed. “As the days and years go by, they are picking up the comics, and seeing heroines and saying, ‘Let me see what’s it about.'”
Comic Books: Why Girls Don’t Get It
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.