“What would you say if I were to offer you $1 million for one night with your wife?” asks billionare John Gage (Robert Redford) of David Murphy (Woody Harrelson), a man on the edge of losing all he owns, in the new movie Indecent Proposal. This question has gotten a lot of people thinking. Many feel that casual sex or sex for that kind of money isn’t such a big deal.
But isn’t it? Can someone respect herself after selling out like that? And is it right for a man to buy a woman’s body? For the woman to let herself be sold? The questions of self-respect, right and wrong, and decency never come up in Indecent Proposal. It’s all just sex, money, and possessions.
One night after being big winners at a gambling casino in Vegas, David and his wife Diana (Demi Moore) are at home counting their money. David, joking around, throws the wads of $50 bills onto the bed, and Diana rolls around in them. “David, I love you,” she tells him, “even without the money.”
But after they lose it all, they agree to the deal with Gage. They see it as the only way to keep their dream house and get themselves out of debt. David and Diana are so in love they believe that they are “invincible.” Even in this movie things aren’t that simple.
In a heated scene after the night Diana and Gage spend together is over and done, David flies into a jealous rage. “I did it for you,” Diana tells him, tears in her eyes.
“You did it for yourself! You were attracted to him!” He slams his fist into the door, turns to look at her, opens it, and leaves. Diana is left to cry by herself. We are left to wonder-why did she do it?
“She’s a pig,” my friend told me. “She never should have done it. It just wasn’t right.” Although I wouldn’t go as far as to call her a pig, I have to admit that the whole thing doesn’t seem to be much of a dilemma for her. She doesn’t once stop to think about whether or not what she is doing is wrong. She’s completely blinded by the money, which is what Gage wants.
I didn’t appreciate the way Diana is treated like a possession either. She’s something that can be bought and sold by the two men, good only for sex. It’s because of this image of women in the media that guys in and out of the locker room talk about how they scored the night before and count girls as just another point, or a notch on their belts. Too often movies like this seem to be saying “boys will be boys.” I don’t think so. Women are worth more than sex, and it’s unacceptable for them to be treated that way, on screen or off.
Out of all the characters, I hated Gage the most. He is the bad guy- a womanizer who feels that he can buy anyone and own anything he wants. But the movie makes him out to be this smooth, suave, handsome, rich executive doing Diana and David a favor by offering them the money. That made me hate him even more, because while people might say Diana is a bad person for going through with it, I think Gage is the worse person for even offering. It definitely is an “indecent proposal,” it just isn’t portrayed that way.
But despite what I thought through most of the movie, I have to say that I enjoyed the ending, because although Diana is treated as an object through most of it, she is the one who gets to make the ultimate choice. I liked the end because it was unexpected and romantic. “Money can’t buy people’s emotions,” Diana tells Gage, early in the movie, and in the end she’s able to prove it to him.
“Indecent Proposal”: Selling Herself Short
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.