When Your Father Is a Stranger

“Somewhere in the Darkness,” by Walter Dean Myers, Scholastic Hardcover, $14.95.
I haven’t seen my father since I was a baby and I’ve often wondered what it would be like if he were to come back.
That’s what happens to Jimmy, the main character in Somewhere in the Darkness by Walter Dean Myers.
Jimmy is 14 and in the 10th grade when the book begins. His mother died when he was a baby and his father’s been in jail for murder for as long as he can remember. He lives with a close friend of his mother’s-a lady he calls Mama Jean.
One day, Jimmy comes home from school to find his father, Crab, on the doorstep. Crab has returned from prison because he wants to prove to Jimmy that he’s not a murderer.
The rest of the book describes a trip that Crab and Jimmy take in search of the one man who knows that Crab was framed. But it’s also about another kind of search. Crab and Jimmy are each trying to find something to bond them together, something that connects them as father and son.
First Impressions
Jimmy is looking for something he can love or respect about his father but at first he can only see the darkness in the man. All he knows about his father is that Crab was a criminal who was never around. Jimmy’s impression doesn’t improve when he finds out that Crab wasn’t released from jail but escaped and that he is paying for their trip with stolen credit cards.
“It don’t make a difference if you didn’t kill anybody,” Jimmy tells Crab. “Not if you’re going to steal some money or credit cards or something. That’s wrong too. It don’t make you good just because you didn’t kill nobody!”
Crab knows he hasn’t been the greatest father or even the greatest person and he wants to do something about it before it’s too late. While he was in prison Crab found out that he was really sick and he doesn’t want to die without straightening out his life. He needs to know that he has done something in his life that was worthwhile.
“All I got in this life is you,” he tells Jimmy. “And I don’t even know you…I need to look in a mirror and see something I can respect. Maybe even look at you and see something I can respect, and that respects me.”
Dream Dad
Before meeting Crab, Jimmy had many ideas on how a father was supposed to act. “For some reason he had always imagined a father as somebody who told him to come home at a certain time or who got mad when he didn’t do his homework. He had imagined them going to baseball games together or maybe for walks in the park.”
He looks for some resemblance between Crab and this dream father. At one point, Crab tells Jimmy that he’s going to teach him how to fight. That sounds to Jimmy like the kind of thing a father is supposed to do so he says he wants to learn even though he’s not really interested.
What does interest Jimmy is hearing Crab talk about his own father, C.C. It turns out that even though C.C. lived at home, he didn’t do any of the things Jimmy imagined a live-in father would do. C.C. was away a lot because he worked on the railroad and when he was at home he was more interested in hanging out with his friends than with his son.
This conversation, and their visits to places where Crab had played when he was younger, start bringing them closer together. Just when they are starting to get along, a dramatic turn of events threatens to separate them forever. Knowing that they may never see each other again, Crab tells Jimmy that he’s sorry for everything. “I know, Daddy,” Jimmy said. “I know.”
It Touched Me
This is the first time Jimmy calls Crab “daddy.” It shows that in spite of everything, he is finally starting to think of Crab as a real father. The shared experience of their trip and everything they learned about each other along the way gave Jimmy something to hold on to. He and his father aren’t strangers anymore. They finally have a relationship.
I didn’t really like this book in the beginning because I felt it wasn’t saying enough about what the characters were thinking and feeling. How could a book about such an emotional subject-the return of a long lost father-be written in such a flat way?
But that changed as I got into it. When I began to really understand it, it touched something in me. There’s something special and heartwarming about a father who wasn’t the perfect father trying to form a bond with his son.
Somewhere in the Darkness asks a big question: what is a father? Does a father have to be someone who takes you out to baseball games or who yells at you when you don’t do your homework? Reading this book I realized that the answer is “no.” A father can just be a stranger who has a place for you in his heart.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.