Romance Novels: Always a Happy Ending

“Michael leapt from the bed and pulled her into his arms. Hurt, anger, passion were evident in the heat of his gaze. ‘I can’t stop you from leaving,’ he said as his mouth claimed hers, ‘but I won’t let you forget.'”
The hero and heroine in this climactic scene are from “Different Worlds,” a romance novel by Elaine K. Stirling (Harlequin Temptation, 1991).
Romance novels are very entertaining. They offer you a chance to get away from reality. Not everyone likes romances for that reason, but that’s my reason for liking them. Romances show you that in another world, people do have happy endings. Romances cheer me up when I’m feeling down. I read them so that I don’t give up hope. People who are avid romance readers like me probably read them to escape from their own drab lifestyles.
“Rochelle sighed and a great calm filled her as his lips once more found hers in perfect sweetness.”
This is very the last sentence of “Enchanted Enemy” by Cassie Edwards (Zebra Historical, 1988). It’s the typical happy ending, but happy endings are what romance readers expect.
Readers Expect Happy Endings
“In real life, everything doesn’t end up with a smile,” says Dawnmarie Hughes, 17, Evander Childs HS. She admits that she’s attracted to romance novels because of “the excitement of the things two people can share and feel in a romantic way.”
Miriam Alvarez, 18, of Evander Childs HS agrees. She’s not embarrassed to admit that she likes romance novels because of “the relationships, but most of all the sexuality.”
“Romance novels are the best,” says Diana Griffith, 18, of South Shore HS. “They teach you a lot of things about life. You can learn from some of the mistakes that they make…It’s one of my hobbies and I enjoy reading [them].”
On the other hand, Lavon Isaac, an 18-year-old high school graduate says that she reads romances simply because she has “nothing better to do and it fills my spare time.”
I started reading Sweet Dreams (published by Bantam), a series of romance novels written specifically for teens, when I was about 11 years old. Soon afterwards, I felt that I was mature enough to read romances that were not necessarily meant for teens. So I started reading Mills & Boon, a series that was available in Antigua, the Caribbean island where I grew up. They were very popular with young adults. I’m now 17 and I’ve progressed to adult romances published by Harlequin ,its subsidiary Silhouette, or its main rival, Bantam/Loveswept.
Sold 200 Million Books
A recent article in the New York Times said that the giant of the field, the Canadian company Harlequin Books, which also owns Silhouette Books, publishes 60 titles a month and sold 200 million books last year in more than 20 languages. On average, I read approximately one novel a day or about five or six per week. I’m a wreck without my romances.
“Romance is a very popular topic with teens. One that’s never going to go out [of style] even though it’s as old as ‘Jane Eyre’ by Charlotte Bronte,” said Mary Jane Pacchi, a librarian in the Young Adult Services section of the New York Public Library’s Mid-Manhattan branch.
According to Pacchi, the books that are most popular with teens who use the services of her branch library are Sweet Dreams (Bantam), Sweet Valley High (Bantam), and Freshmen and Roommates (Ivy).
“Teens have characters that they can identify with. They come away feeling that they would like to get to know the characters,” explained Pacchi. Asked if teenage boys read romances, Pacchi hesitated: “They may, I’m not aware of it so much. I tend to think not.”
Not All Romances Are the Same
Contrary to popular belief, this genre (style of novel) is not all the same plot with just different covers. The only thing romances have in common is that they begin with different variations of boy meets girl, but then they go on from there.
“It has to have one man and one woman [and] a happy or positive ending. Whatever the author does to achieve that is good,” explained Isabel Swift, editorial manager of Silhouette Books. But the story line for each book can be completely different she insisted: “Authors don’t write to formula but they must write to reader expectations…I think for authors, their aim is to write a romance that simply sweeps the reader [off her feet].”
Asked what qualities make a good romance, Swift responded: “It really is the emotion, the ability to sweep the reader up in a story. It’s just that emotional quality, that’s one thing that a good romance has to have.” She added that each person has her own idea of true love, and to make the reader happy, a good romance has to depict true love.
Sweeping the Reader Off Her Feet
Liza Wright, publicity manager of Bantam Books for Young Adults, felt these novels must have “a combination of romance and action, so that you will always want to keep turning the pages-and [they must] have someone that people can relate to.” But Joan Schulhafer, publicity manager for Bantam/Loveswept argued that the standards for a romance aren’t different from the standards for any other type of novel: “Good writing always includes good characters, strong dialogue, and probably a healthy dose of humor.”
“Romance readers in general are 15 or older,” explained Swift. She also noted that about 10-20% of Silhouette’s readers are teenagers. The majority of the readers, however, are adult women.
“[Romance authors] write for [adult] women definitely,” claimed Schulhafer. “They write about what’s going on with women. They’re just basically aware of what interests women they know, and women in general.”
Schulhafer continued: “Romance novels will always reflect what’s going on currently in the world…they’re reflecting what’s going on…with women.”
But Dawnmarie cautioned teens not to expect too much from romances because their goal is to entertain and they don’t always reflect reality: “It’s not everything that’s written in books that teen-agers or adults should copy or use as a pattern.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.