People with disabilities are portrayed by the mass media as stupid, helpless, or different, and are denied roles which depict them as normal people who happen to have disabilities, according to Ellen Rubin, training coordinator at the Alliance for Mainstreaming Youth with Disabilities.
“The media portrays people with disabilities in stereotypic ways, making them laughable, pitiable, victims or perpetrators of crime,” said Rubin.
This is especially true for the mentally disabled, who are often portrayed in movies and on television either as violent criminals or victims of violence.
According to an article in a recent issue of The Medical Post, low budget TV shows and the news portray the mentally ill as unpredictable, dangerous, or evil. In some of these shows mentally ill characters are portrayed as killers, when in reality “only 3% of the mentally ill behave in a violent fashion,” according to the article.
‘As If They don’t Have Feelings’
Physically or mentally disabled villains are a common feature of all types of movies: in “Dirty Harry,” “The Sting,” and several James Bond films, there’s a showdown between the attractive, able-bodied hero and the disabled villain.
These negative media images of the disabled “program” the consciousness of the viewers and reinforce prejudice toward people with disabilities-people perceive a disability with a person instead of a person with a disability.
“The thing that is most unfair is that [the media] treat disabled people as if they don’t have feelings like other people,” said Rubin.
Rubin, who became blind as a result of a degenerative eye disease, added that “one-fifth of the population has some kind of disability,” so media stereotypes affect millions of disabled people as well as the non-disabled.
“Have you ever seen Mr. Magoo?” asked Rubin. “People with disabilities are portrayed as people to be pitied or laughed at. The cartoon shows Mr. Magoo as the quintessential fool.”
The TV character Mr. Magoo, who is visually impaired, is always shown mistaking a coat rack for a person, or bumping into walls.
“It’s highly exaggerated,” said Rubin. “This may occasionally happen, but it’s not the norm.”
Fairy tales and stories also stigmatize disabled people. In Hansel and Gretel, the witch who uses a cane is portrayed as evil. Wicked pirates and other villains in children’s stories usually have wooden legs, hunchbacks, and eye patches. Classic children’s literature exploits this negative stereotype of the disabled, fostering fear and prejudice at an early age.
Language is Not Neutral
The language used by the media also contributes to prejudice and discrimination against disabled people. Language, said Rubin, is “not neutral, it’s political.” Most disabled people are offended by terms like “deaf and dumb,” “retarded,” “Insane,” “crippled,” “handicapped” and “confined to a wheelchair.” Disabled people prefer the terms hearing, mobility, visually or mentally-impaired.
Asked what stereotype bothered her the most, Rubin said, “It’s the pity and the helplessness. In fact, we can do things for ourselves, but sometimes we do need help.”
But the media portrays all minorities, not just the disabled, in a negative way, if at all. The disabled-the minority group that anybody can join-are treated the same way.
And a triple minority-for example a disabled, Black, woman-is invisible in the media. “We are a society that does not celebrate differences,” said Rubin.
Some Realistic Portrayals
Can TV, movies, newspapers, and books portray disabled people more accurately?
“First of all, they can portray them as a whole person with interests and not just as a disabled person,” suggested Rubin.
Recently, there have been positive portrayals of the disabled in the movies. Last year’s winner of the Academy Award for best actor was Dustin Hoffman, who played an autistic character in “Rainman.” This year Daniel Day-Lewis won the award for his role as Irish artist/writer Christy Brown in “My Left Foot.” (See reviews on p. 18). Also, in “Born on the Fourth of July” Tom Cruise played Vietnam veteran Ron Kovic, whose psychological adjustment to being in a wheelchair was realistically presented.
And “Life Goes On,” a TV show currently on ABC, is critically acclaimed for its realistic depiction of how a family copes with a teenage son with Down Syndrome.
Rubin added a final thought: “People have strengths and weakness and get to know about the person first…all of us have limitations.”
How the Media Stereotype the Disabled
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.