“Teenagers should know that they’re being manipulated,” said Alphonso Wyatt, deputy executive director of the Manhattan Valley Youth Program. “It’s easy to manipulate someone to buy products. Ethics have changed. What they do now they wouldn’t or couldn’t do back then.”
Confused? The “they” Wyatt refers to are role models used by advertisers to aggressively pursue the youth market.
A role model-who could be just about anybody from a sports figure to a celebrity-sets a trend. Advertisers count on the tendency of teenagers to buy into this trend.
Case in point: rap artists are well known for certain types of clothing styles such as Gucci or Nike, heavy gold jewelry, and expensive sports cars. Since so many teenagers look up to rap artists as role models, they tend to wear certain types of clothing, sport heavy gold jewelry, and drive expensive sports cars.
Many teens who don’t have these things lust after them.
don’t get the wrong idea. Rap artists are only one example.
Looking For an Identity
Why do role models, in general, influence teenagers to buy things they don’t need?
“Because they get paid to do it,” said Wyatt. “For example, Michael Jackson endorses Pepsi. But he doesn’t drink soda.”
Donald Clayton, program director at the Genesis II Museum of Black Culture, blames the teenage response on the need for a sense of identity.
“Adults don’t have it, children don’t learn it, schools don’t teach it…so they go out and look for their own.”
Clayton also believes that the influence of role models is due to what he calls a “loss of imagination.”
By this, he was referring to how teenagers don’t want to be different; they want to conform. “They [teenagers] live in a staid environment…with all the peer pressure, nothing changes.”
Because of this “loss of imagination,” every time a new trend is introduced, teenagers are inclined, like sheep, to follow it.
Clayton went on to use the “Batman” trend as an example: “It captured their [teenagers’] imagination.” Weeks before the feature movie was released, people sported every kind of Batman paraphernalia, from T-shirts to shorts to medallions.
Unrealistic Expectations
Clayton thinks that role models play a very important part in consumerism. As a result of all the exposure to the fun lifestyles that are portrayed in certain advertisements and commercials (such as those for beer), a lot of teenagers have “great expectations.” These expectations often prove to be unrealistic.
Lisa Ballance, 16, a student at A. Philip Randolph HS, explained: “Teenagers respond to the role models with the most money. They see it and say, `I want it too.’ They think it means something. They only see the money…they don’t see the work that went into it.”
“Commercials appear innocent,” added Wyatt. “They’re designed to be lethal. The advertisers are after your money.”
A major problem here is that many teenagers go by the “easy money” principle. In other words, they want a lot of money, just like their role models, but usually aren’t willing to work for it. This is why some people resort to stealing or drug dealing.
“More advertising is geared toward young people,” said Clayton. “I think consumerism has changed in that it’s out to exploit the kids.”
Clayton used as an example a contest held by 98.7 KISS-FM offering a gold Mercedes-Benz as the prize. Clayton questioned what a teenager could do with a Mercedes.
He also pointed out that when some people see a teenager driving around in a gold Mercedes, they get the impression that the driver is a drug dealer.
A Need For Positive Models
“We need a different attitude,” said Clayton. “We need more natural role models…more normal people.” Clayton feels that the best role models for teenagers are their parents. “They [parents] do work so hard.”
Alix Bien-Aime, 16, of South Shore HS, explained what he looks for in a role model: “They must be positive, they must have helped people, they must believe in youth empowerment and nonviolence, and they must be firm believers in what they preach.” Alix’s personal role models are Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X.
Smurf, 19, a graduate of Springfield Garden HS, feels that sometimes teenagers choose role models as a result of peer pressure. “Everybody else likes them, they feel like they have to, too.” Smurf admitted that his one role model, Michael Jordan, influences him to buy Nike Air Jordans, but advised: “don’t be influenced by peer pressure.”
Michelle Belisle, 16, of Washington Irving HS, disagreed. Referring to teenagers choosing role models because of peer pressure, she said: “Some things are still personal.”
Michelle’s buying decisions have never been influenced by anyone but herself. “I’m a pretty headstrong person. Be yourself! You’ll have more people’s respect.”
Do you have a role model? Does he or she influence your buying decisions? Teenagers should stop and think about what they really want and why they want it. don’t be trapped by slick advertising.
How Role Models Influence Us to Buy
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.