Who’s Accusing Whom?

NYC Rating: ***
Let’s play wordgames. Say a woman is raped by three men on top of a pinball machine in a bar while numerous other men cheer them on. Is it rape?
If this woman had been drinking and smoking marijuana, is it still rape?
If she was wearing a sexy outfit as well, is it definitely and undeniably still rape?
The answer to all the above questions should be yes.
No matter what the external circumstances, if a woman says no, if she does not want to have sex, and if she is forced to have sex with a total stranger, a date, even her own husband, then she has been raped.
Unfortunately, in our society, this is not always the interpretation. Often, too often, the woman must first prove herself to be morally flawless before the man (or men-one out of four rapes is committed by more than one man) is prosecuted.
This is the dilemma that Jodie Foster confronts in her award winning performance as a rape victim in “The Accused.”
Foster Outstanding
Jodie Foster, as the raped woman, is great. In such an emotionally wrenching part there is a danger of overacting, but Foster keeps her cool and handles her character with very realistic control.
Kelly McGillis, on the other hand, who plays Foster’s lawyer and has the second biggest part in the movie, is lousy. She’s flat and unconvincing, but does not ruin what is otherwise a very good movie.
Because Foster’s character is so questionable (the night she was raped, she was both drunk, stoned, skimpily dressed, and flirtatious) the movie raises the issue about whether or not a woman “like that” is asking to be raped.
No woman who says “No” is asking to be raped, ever. The brutal rape scene in this movie should be enough to convince anyone. (By the way, this is one of those movies you probably won’t want to see alone.)
The movie is good, not great. But Jodie Foster’s riveting performance and the socially critical theme makes it one that should not be missed.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.