East Side High Through Hollywood’s Eyes

East Side High in Paterson, New Jersey. Seven years ago it could have been any one of the many New York City high schools with astounding dropout and teen pregnancy rates, where drug dealers rule, and violence between teachers and students is the #1 intramural sport.
Seven years ago Joe Clark became principal and with his bullhorn and bat began “laying down the law.” With the help of the school faculty and students who learned to believe that they had a right to an education, Joe Clark turned East Side High around.
This is the basis of the recently released “Lean On Me” which dramatizes East Side High’s comeback. The movie, which used Clark as a consultant, has been called by some critics as so pro-Clark as to be pure fiction.
I disagree.
Not a Perfect Hero
Morgan Freeman’s powerhouse portrayal of Clark does not give moviegoers the impression that Clark is some perfect superhero.
Freeman, as Clark, is often conceited, arrogant, and downright obnoxious.
But it is also clear that Clark cares about the students-personally and academically.
For example, when Kaneesha Carter (played by Karen Malina White) comes to Clark (Freeman) and explains that her mother is throwing her out, Clark and the assistant principal, Ms. Levias (the dynamic Beverly Todd) accompany Kaneesha to her home and help her work it all out. The scene between Kaneesha, her mom (Regina Taylor), Clark, and Levias is one of the most touching in the movie.
Another riveting moment is when Clark and student Thomas Samms (played by the talented Jermaine Hopkins) are on the roof of the school. Clark tells Jermaine to jump. Jermaine says, “I don’t want to jump.”
Clark asks Jermaine if he smokes crack. Jermaine answers yes. Then Clark cleverly responds, “If you smoke crack you must want to die. Jump.”
Clark is tough and unreasonable. His actions are not beyond criticism. He chains the doors of the school, despite the fire hazard, to keep out drug dealers. He throws out students who have been in school for five years. And he’s hard on the teachers and hard on the students.
But when you care about somebody you are tough and sometimes you make mistakes.
Tough Love
In the beginning of the movie, Clark isn’t very likable. But as the movie progresses you become more and more supportive of Clark because you feel his sincerity, and you sense that while the man has his faults he has what it takes to change the school.
And change it he does.
After a year the students’ verbal skills tests improve. But even more importantly there’s a student pride in the school that did not exist before (no more graffiti, the drug dealers leave etc.)
Maybe you think Joe Clark is a jerk, maybe you think he’s a hero, maybe you don’t care.
But if you care about the fate of Black and Latino kids in the deteriorating inner city school system, then the “tough love” method that Joe Clark administers is one of the successful alternatives that you should not ignore.
Love it or hate it, but see this movie.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.