Many colleges require that you send a personal statement as part of your application. Others make it an option. Writing that essay is one of a senior’s worst nightmares. You sit there ripping your hair out, staring at that blank page, trying to come up with some inkling of what to write about. And you can put it off only so long before the deadline is upon you and you have no choice but to write something.
Vickash Ramdeen, 17, of LaGuardia HS, was born with only three, tiny fingers on his left hand. He decided to write about his deformity and how it affected his life. “There was so much to say,” said Vickash. “I didn’t know where to begin.”
When he finally got started, he said he tried to show the admissions officer “how my disability has helped me to be a better person.”
Picking one important experience in your life and writing about that is one way to go. Some colleges, like NYU, even recommend doing that on their application. But according to admissions officers, there’s no single correct way to write a good essay.
A Look Beyond the Test Scores
John Buckley, associate director of admissions at Fordham University, says the essay is there to give the college a less statistical view of the student. “The statement is a direct reflection of the student’s personality,” he said.
Cathy O’Rourke, associate director of admissions at NYU, says students should look at the essay as an opportunity rather than as some kind of a test. “The essay is not used to judge the student,” she explained, “but rather to get an insight into the person behind the application.”
Anil Sant, 19, is a freshman at Queens College, studying engineering. “I’m more of a science and math person,” said Anil. “English isn’t exactly my best subject so I think, on the whole, writing is kind of hard for me.”
Anil knew he wanted to study engineering and he wrote about that. “I stuck to my motivation for choosing such a career field,” he said.
Admissions officers say that whatever you choose to write about, it’s important to stick to one subject. “Pick a particular aspect that appeals to you,” said Buckley. “And stay focused on [that] particular theme or topic.”
Touching, Funny, and Creative Essays
I asked Buckley if he could recall reading any particularly outstanding essays. He mentioned two.
The first was by a girl who wrote about a car accident she had been in. She described how a friend of hers had died in the accident. Buckley said the essay was “touching” and “conveyed all the different emotions she experienced.”
In the second, the applicant made up a story about meeting up with Ben Franklin as he discovers electricity. “This essay was quite humorous, creative, and quite well done,” Buckley said.
Admissions officers love creativity but, according to Buckley, “[It] should come to the student naturally and not be manufactured. The [main] idea is to be informative, share a little of yourself with the reader.”
Elba Gonzalez, another admissions officer at NYU, said that creativity comes in different forms. “Some students that are into the arts send in pictures, poems, and paintings…there really isn’t a limit to a person’s creativity.”
In spite of their inability (or unwillingness) to say exactly what makes a good essay, these admissions officers were very clear about the things which can count against you.
Handle With Care
They complained about students who use sloppy handwriting and bad grammar, misspell words, and fail to follow instructions. Some applications ask you to write about specific things like a significant experience or where you see yourself in 20 years. They might ask you to print or type, double space, etc. “This is not simply ‘fill in the blank’ like the application,” explained Buckley. “[It] should be handled carefully.”
It’s also important not to be repetitive or go on and on. “Admissions officers have a lot of essays to read over,” said Buckley. “It can be bothersome to have to read extremely long essays with no substance. The key to a good essay is to condense the specific ideas into a few pages.” (In Gonzalez’s case, “no more than two.”)
How important is the essay in the application process? According to the experts, pretty important. If you don’t have an opportunity to interview, the essay will be your only chance to give the college personal information about yourself.
The Essay Can Make the Difference
Buckley says how heavily it weighs depends on the particular school you’re applying to. But regardless of the school, “the [personal] statement can make a difference to scholarship students and those on middle ground,” he said. “It helps the admissions officer distinguish one student from another.”
The essay is never the only thing a college considers, however. “The essay itself doesn’t make or break the student’s chances,” said Gonzalez. “[Our] main concern is the student’s academic potential and whether they will be able to succeed at the college.”
For NYU, where Gonzalez and O’Rourke work, an essay is required. At Fordham it’s optional but, according to Buckley, highly recommended. “When a student doesn’t send in an essay what they are actually saying is that they’re not that interested in the school,” he said. “This then works against the student. It is really important that you send one in.”
When you do, Nigel says to “just make sure you write about something that you’re interested in and that you think will give the admissions officer a better idea as to who you really are.”
Writing the College Essay: Be Neat, Be Concise, Be Yourself
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.