Back in the 1930s and ’40s, a woman’s place was still in the home and the men brought the bread in, but you never would have guessed this from watching some of the movies back then. They were ahead of their time, portraying strong women fighting for what they wanted.
In His Girl Friday, for example, Rosalind Russell plays a newspaper reporter who breaks off her engagement after realizing that giving up her career in the big city for married life in the country would not make her happy. “You’ve got to take me as I am, instead of trying to change me,” she told her fiance. “I’m not a suburban bridge player; I’m a newspaperman.”
In Adam’s Rib, Katharine Hepburn plays a lawyer who puts her marriage in jeopardy when she agrees to defend a female client accused of murdering her husband. In Mildred Pierce, Joan Crawford portrays a divorced woman who builds up an empire of restaurants and still manages to take care of her family. Although I wouldn’t call Mildred Pierce a feminist film (it turns into a soap opera with mother and daughter fighting over the same man), it still manages to deliver a strong female lead.
Today, real women have more control over their lives than ever before, but strong women’s roles have almost vanished from the screen. Most Hollywood movies revolve around male leads with women playing small supporting roles-the wife, the girlfriend, the victim saved by the hero. The few starring roles for women in films these days are psychopathic killers, or cold-blooded, calculating women who use sex to get what they want (or a combination of the two).
Scary Single Females
Single white females with fatal instincts seem to attract Hollywood a lot. They are always making movies about unhappy single women that need a man and/or children to bring them happiness.
In Fatal Attraction, Glenn Close plays an unhappy professional woman whose desire to have a child before it’s too late causes her to become obsessed with a married man. The same applies for Rebecca De Mornay in The Hand that Rocks the Cradle. She is another lonely woman willing to do anything for a baby-even kill. And in Poison Ivy, Drew Barrymore plays a teenage girl who becomes obsessed with her best friend’s father. These three characters are portrayed in a totally unsympathetic way and are hated by audiences.
In these movies, it is always the unmarried women who are evil. For all three of these characters, the only way to get a family of their own is by destroying someone else’s. But in the end, these women are the ones who have the fatal attraction. They are the ones who get killed. The families that they’ve threatened live happily ever after, or at least until the man has another affair. (The scenario is slightly different in Poison Ivy-the Barrymore character does succeed in killing the wife. But it was really the father-daughter relationship that she was threatening and they’re closer than ever at the end of the film.)
Hollywood’s definition of a strong woman seems to be one who is cold, calculating, and ruthless. They have a lot of sex but never get emotionally involved with their partners, which enables them to keep the upper hand. (It also enables the filmmakers to put a lot of sex scenes on screen.)
In Body of Evidence, Madonna plays a woman who dates rich old men with bad hearts. After they put her in their wills, she kills them. When she goes on trial, she knows the steps to take to win the case. In Basic Instinct, Sharon Stone plays a mystery writer who kills to publicize her work, or maybe just for fun. Who knows? I was never sure what the point of either of these movies was. The plots got lost among the steamy sex scenes.
Women Are Bought and Sold
Another plotline that has been getting a lot of play revolves around women being bought and sold by men. When Michelle Pfeiffer received an award from the organization Women in Film earlier this year, she said, “This has been a very good year for women. Demi Moore was sold to Robert Redford for $1 million. Uma Thurman went for $40,000 to Mr. DeNiro. While just three years ago, Richard Gere bought Julia Roberts for…What was it?…$3,000? I’d say that was real progress.”
At least the character Julia Roberts played in Pretty Woman was a real prostitute. But in the other films that have followed this scenario-Mad Dog and Glory, Honeymoon in Vegas and, of course, Indecent Proposal-the men treat their wives and girlfriends as property and use them to settle their debts. And the women go along with it.
The roles women are getting these days are really frightening. There is so little to choose from that even some women who are big stars have opted to do bad movies rather than no movies at all. The ones who can afford it have started their own production companies so they can create their own roles. Others have left the movies for television, which still provides a lot of meaty female roles.
Who’s Behind the Cameras?
There are a few exceptions, but for every Thelma and Louise (one of the few films I have seen in the past few years where women really take control of their lives), there are 10 Fatal Attractions. Why is this? Back in the ’30s and ’40s, adult women were considered a major part of the filmgoing audience and lots of movies were made specifically to interest them. Nowadays it is young men who seem to go to the movies more often than anyone else and movies are targeted to them.
At the same time, there are still comparatively few women producers and directors in Hollywood. (Women only make up around 10% of the membership of the Director’s Guild of America, for example.) And they rarely get the awards, acclaim, or pay that male directors. Two years ago The Prince of Tides was nominated for almost every category except best director. Why? A lot of women in Hollywood think it was because Barbra Streisand directed it.
The same thing happened with A League of Their Own this past year. Directed by Penny Marshall, this powerful film about an all-girl baseball team was completely ignored by the Academy Awards.
What the Future Holds
Just recently female director Tamra Davis (CB4) was fired from Bad Girls, a work in progress about five prostitutes on the trail of bank robbers. I read that she was canned from the project because she wanted to give it a feminist perspective while the producers wanted a sexier film. She was immediately replaced by male director Jonathan Kaplan (Unlawful Entry).
But I haven’t given up hope. Another film currently in the making that should have a strong female lead is River Wild starring Oscar winner Meryl Streep. It is about a family that is attacked while on a rafting trip and the gun-toting mom (Streep) who goes after the bad guys who kidnap her children. Something else I’m looking forward to seeing in the near future is Mistress of the Sea, with Michelle Pfeiffer playing an 18th century pirate.
But I am somewhat afraid that these characters will never make it to the screen. Just recently I read a story in Entertainment Weekly about Dead Reckoning, a movie about a female lawyer who gets caught up in a Washington conspiracy. The star was originally supposed to be either Michelle Pfeiffer or Jodie Foster. Then Steven Segal expressed interest in the film so the screenplay is being rewritten. The lead character will now be a man, to be played by Segal.
Women and Hollywood: Fatal Attraction?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.