Will My Brother Be the Next Shooter?

Newtown proves we need mental health reform

December 14, 2012 started out as a normal day. Home sick from school, I got up a little late, showered, and turned on the news while eating breakfast. Suddenly a headline flashed across the TV screen: “ELEMENTARY SCHOOL SHOOTING IN CONNECTICUT.”
Over the following days, each time I read about the shooter, who killed his mother, 20 children and 6 other adults at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Connecticut before killing himself, my heart dropped a little. He was described as mentally ill and prone to violent, uncontrollable outbursts-like my brother.
My brother has a mood disorder. He has characteristics of bipolar disorder, but not full-blown bipolar; at least, not yet. He has intermittent episodes of violent rage in which he’ll scream, throw things, and sometimes attack my parents. He has also suffered from prolonged depressive episodes with suicidal thoughts, for which he’s been hospitalized twice.
As a kid, he was diagnosed with ADHD and prescribed Ritalin (though my father, who distrusts medication, encouraged him to spit out his pills). Then, around 7th grade, his violent rages materialized. They have continued for the past six years, often exacerbated by marijuana or alcohol use.
He has been to several therapists, but usually doesn’t like them and stops going. He’s also been on many different medications. While none completely suppressed his symptoms, my parents and I think the drugs were very helpful. Every time he was on them he did better in school, his mood was more stable, and he didn’t have as many “episodes.” But they had side effects, like hair loss and weight gain.
Feeling Helpless
About a year ago, my brother stopped taking medication. He thinks the psychiatric industry uses medication to “control” people. He claims he can do perfectly fine without meds, even though nowadays his episodes happen more often than not. And what can we do about it? Nothing.
Before, he acquiesced somewhat reluctantly to my parents’ demands, but now he’s refusing them altogether. We can’t forcefully spoon-feed him pills, nor can we admit him to a mental health care facility, unless a court decides he’s a danger to himself or others-and that’s very hard to prove.
I don’t know if he deserves to be institutionalized, but living in the same house as him is awful. Yet his disorder results in his inability to live independently. He’s very irresponsible-he can’t manage his time or money, he’s impulsive, and sometimes too depressed to get out of bed. I don’t know how he’d be able to maintain a job or pay bills.
At least in a psychiatric hospital he’d be getting therapy and medication. With consistent treatment, maybe he could become more functional and independent. Instead, he’s languishing at home. Affected by his mental illness, he refuses to take pills, thereby remaining incapacitated. Without help, he’ll likely continue to suffer from deep depression and uncontrollable anger.
We Need Reform
Because of this, I identify with the families of the people who go on shooting sprees and the frustration they must have faced. Too often, the public chooses to vilify the shooter’s family rather than examine the conditions that may have led to a shooting. Cases like these remind me of how helpless and scared I feel in the face of my brother’s outbursts. Most people don’t know what it’s like to live with a family member who is violently mentally ill, and how hard it is to get appropriate help.
I believe our mental health care policy needs to be reformed so that families can compel mentally ill people to get treatment. We also need to reduce the stigma around mental illness and seeking help.
I’m always scared my brother is going to snap and commit a random act of violence one day. While it’s unclear if the Sandy Hook shooter had a diagnosable mental illness, the shooters in mass killings at Virginia Tech in 2007, in Tucson, Arizona in 2011, and at the Aurora movie theater in 2012, all had histories of mental illness.
Gun control is the traditional response to shootings like these-and for good reason, since a violent person with a knife is a lot less dangerous than someone who can shoot 50 rounds a minute. But I think that mental health reform needs to get just as much attention, even though most mentally ill people are not violent.
Involuntary Treatment
The main problem with our current system is that it’s too difficult for families of mentally ill people to get appropriate help for their loved ones. For one thing, there’s no way to legally compel a mentally ill person to take their medication. Yes, I do believe in free will and patients’ rights. However, if someone is seriously mentally ill, they do not have the capacity to make decisions in their own best interest. The small number who are a danger to themselves or others need to be medicated, even if they don’t want to be.
Similarly, I think it’s a problem that it’s so difficult to compel mentally ill people to get treatment-either outpatient (where you attend therapy or day treatment) or inpatient (where you stay in the hospital for a period of weeks or months).
In New York, a judge can compel someone to get outpatient treatment, but their mental illness has to have landed them in a psychiatric hospital or correctional facility within the last 36 months, and they have to have demonstrated serious violent behavior towards themselves or others within the last 48 months. The point of getting help is to prevent violent behavior and to prevent landing in a facility; help shouldn’t only be available after these things happen. The same issue exists with laws on compelled inpatient care.
While I think my brother definitely meets the criteria for outpatient treatment, I don’t know how well we would be able to provide evidence of “serious violent behavior,” or what those standards are. When he’s not in the midst of a violent or depressive episode, my brother acts like a normal person; it wouldn’t be easy to prove (to a judge who doesn’t know and live with him) that he needs this care.
And I know my brother would hold a grudge against us if we did try to compel him into treatment. If we went through all that only for the judge to decide against treatment, his “episodes” against my parents would probably get a lot worse.
Jail Is Not the Answer
Therefore, I think the criteria should be less stringent. It should include mentally ill people who show potential for violence, without having to wait until they’vebeen institutionalized or have committed a crime. And families should be able be able to testify because they know the person better than a judge or doctor. (Psychiatrists, of course, should also examine the person to determine what treatment they need.)
As of now, many people who need long-term, intensive mental health care end up in jail. According to a 2006 report from Human Rights Watch, the number of mentally ill inmates in U.S. prisons and jails has quadrupled from 2000 to 2006, and continues to rise. Public psychiatric hospitals have been closing since the 1980s, and now the three largest inpatient psychiatric facilities in the country are in jails: Los Angeles County Jail, Rikers Island, and Cook County Jail in Illinois.
I don’t think that’s fair. Mentally ill people often aren’t cognizant that they’re committing a crime, or, like my brother, they have poor impulse control. Getting into legal trouble because of that is totally avoidable. My brother’s rages are a result of untreated mental illness. If he doesn’t seek help through medication and therapy, I worry that he could end up in jail too. The question is, how we can we make him get help, if he’s not willing to do so on his own?
Reducing Stigma, Improving Care
I think my brother’s reluctance stems from the stigmatization of mental illness. He never told his friends he was taking pills because he didn’t want to be considered “the crazy one.” If we let people seek mental help without destroying their pride in the process, I’m sure many more people would choose to take medication. No one wants to take pills if society tells them only “Insane” people do that.
To combat this, I think there should be a national awareness campaign. President Obama has called for a “national dialogue” on mental health. I think we should include a massive advertising campaign, with posters and TV ads that show people with mental illness, unashamed to acknowledge it and explaining that, with treatment, they lead normal lives. They should also show where and how to get help.
Why It Matters
Enacting these kinds of changes could help prevent senseless acts of violence. But that’s not the only reason they matter. While people with serious mental disorders only account for 4% of violent crimes overall-it’s far more likely that someone with a serious mental illness will be the victim of violence than the perpetrator-changes in our mental health care system in response to Sandy Hook would help the nonviolent ones, too. Research shows that roughly one out of every five American adults experience some type of mental illness each year. Shouldn’t we help those more than 45 million people, and their families?
If we make it easier for those with mental illnesses to get help, we’ll be improving the lives of innumerable people. We need to make mental health treatment more available and affordable, and give families a better way to compel mentally ill loved ones to get treatment when they need it but don’t have the capacity to make that judgment themselves. Lastly, we should work to reduce the stigma of mental illness and medication through awareness campaigns. I think that will make more mentally ill people want to seek help.
It’s certainly what my brother and my family deserve-and all the families who are struggling to find a way to help a troubled love one.
For more information on dealing with a mentally ill sibling, see our interview: ” Coping with a Mentally Ill Sibling .”
To read about new laws meant to prevent similar shootings, see our story, ” How the Government is Responding to Sandy Hook .”
This story is part of the health literacy series, which is generously supported by the Cigna Foundation.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.