Why Foster Parents Don’t Understand Us

Names have been changed.
My first foster mother, Hazel, had a beautiful house, laden with all types of beautiful, expensive items and furniture. The house was always clean, the kitchen floor was always waxed so that it would shine, and the refrigerator was always filled with food.
The bedrooms were also kept neat and clean. My room, which was on the second floor, had no door, but it was satisfactory, and the beds were very fancy. The attic was like a big room with five girls, five beds, dressers, and a television in the center of the room.
The basement was an apartment for her daughter and grandchildren. All in all, it was a spectacular house to live in.
In the morning, we all ate together. Same with lunch and dinner. We had it made (or so we thought). At one time our house had 15 people in all: my foster mother and father, her daughter, her four grandchildren, three adopted girls, and five foster children.
She Couldn’t Relate
All who were capable took turns washing the dishes, and we all had our assigned chores. Mine was to do the bathroom and keep my room clean. Things were so good that we even had regular snacks and dessert after meals. “Wow, what a life!” So why am I complaining? Why am I not still living there?
Hazel could not relate to some of the things that the foster kids in her house had been through. She didn’t understand the abuse we experienced and the effect it had on our personalities. So she often made ignorant comments and criticized our reasons for responding the way we did when certain problems arose in our lives. While we had adequate food and shelter, we didn’t have the understanding and patience we needed.
When I first moved in, Hazel started to gossip about the other foster girls in the house, even about those who were no longer living there. She often spoke about how mean they were to her, especially the teenagers. Hazel claimed that after the last teenager she had, she did not want any more because we were already set in our own ways, and it was difficult to train us the way she wanted.
Talking Behind Our Backs
When she talked about the other girls in the house, I would only listen and not comment. I never expected my turn to come, when she would talk about me behind my back just like she did the other girls. Hazel always treated me so nice that I didn’t see it coming.
I began to talk to her about my past, the problems I had living with my parents, the abuse I suffered at the hands of my father. Hazel acted as if she understood how I was feeling and how it affected me. Because of the abuse, I became someone who stayed by myself and kept everything that bothered me inside. That’s the society I came from.
Different Cultures
In the West Indies, it is very uncommon for people to talk about certain personal problems, such as abuse. You see, even if people know that something is wrong, it is very rare for people to become involved. Instead they will “mind their own business.” What’s worse is if the person who is victimizing someone else holds a respectable position in society. Then it either “never happened” or it is kept quiet.
Hazel and I were from different cultures, so she did not understand what life had been like for me in the West Indies. I trusted Hazel like she was my own grandmother, but she disappointed me with her attitude. Why do I say that?
One day I overheard her (she thought I was not around) telling one of her friends about my abuse and the problems I’d face dealing with it.
“Girl,” Hazel said to her friend, “she’s from another country and she is here ’cause her father molested her, and she didn’t say anything about it ’til she was older. She is just always so sad and depressed that sometimes it irks me. I can’t understand how her mother did not do anything about it. And her mother still lives with him, yuh know! Girl, I tell you, I would have packed up my bags and be gone.”
I could not believe that she could be so cruel and insensitive. How could she talk about me like that? I began to have hateful feelings toward her, but I did not show them. I didn’t want my caseworker or anyone at the agency to think that I loved to complain about her. After all, she claimed that she had a very good reputation within our agency.
Hazel also talked about a 15-year-old girl who lived in the house. Hazel told me that Sonia was slow in learning and would never be able to do anything for herself because she could not read or write well. I decided to make an effort to help Sonia read and write so that she could pass her classes.
One time Hazel said to Sonia, “You could do it if you really wanted to.” Then she would say to me, “She can’t never learn properly. She is too slow. I don’t know how she got so far into high school not knowing how to read and write. She must not have wanted to learn.”
I never believed that because when I began to teach Sonia, she was so eager to learn (although very frustrated because it was difficult for her to learn at age 15). But instead of encouraging Sonia, I would hear Hazel telling the other kids, “Better learn your work. Otherwise you will end up like Sonia and never be able to do anything for yourself.”
When Sonia was not around, Hazel would call her lazy and slow, but when she was in the room Hazel would tell her how good she was. Many times I would hear her talk about Sonia and felt sorry for her. If Sonia only knew what was being said about her.
She also talked about Kayla, another girl who once lived there and was my roommate. Kayla was 13 and had a baby who lived in another foster home. The other girls in the house did not know this, but I did because Hazel told me.
Negative Gossip
The fact that Kayla had a baby was supposed to be confidential, yet when Kayla was not around my foster mother would make comments like: “How could she be having sex at such a young age to end up with a baby? So she likes boys, huh? She is so big for her age and eats so much, soon she has to go ’cause I won’t be able to feed her. I tell you, girls these days are so full of heat.”
My problem with Hazel is that she was the opposite of what a foster parent should be. It’s bad enough that she gossiped about us, but what is worse is what she said. As a foster parent, and even more so as a parent who had kids of her own, she should never have made those negative comments.
More Than a Clean Home
When someone decides to become a foster parent, they should realize that they are going to be taking in youth who have had difficult experiences and they should be prepared to deal with these children. Foster parents should be selected and trained to deal with abused and neglected children.
After spending a little more than a year in Hazel’s “mansion,” I left her home and moved to another home where my new foster parents are truly parents.
Hazel had some good qualities. She made sure that we were always clean and well-kept. She always made sure that we were fed and that the house was clean and tidy. But she did not know what was most important about being a foster parent.
She would often say to us that we would never find a home as good as hers once we left.
Well, guess what? I found a loving and supportive foster home, so I guess I proved her wrong.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.