Why Couldn’t We Help Elisa?

There is a wild fire raging inside me because of the senseless death of innocent and helpless six-year-old Elisa Izquierdo. Child abuse is on the rise and no one seems to care. I hope this death finally makes New York and the rest of America wake up and take action.
It enrages me further that thousands of children all over New York City are being abused right at this moment in both biological and foster homes and little is being done to alleviate their suffering. We have the power to help them and prevent another tragedy.
Little Elisa met a dreadful fate and it makes me extremely sick to know that something so awful has to happen before the Mayor, the CWA, and the rest of society takes notice of the horrors being committed against children.
Too late for Elisa! She’s dead. But what is being done to prevent this from happening to another child? I especially want to know what will be done to prevent this from happening to young people in foster care.
Recently the writers and editors of Foster Care Youth United attended a meeting with CWA Commissioner Kathyrn Croft and other CWA officials. I asked one of the officials, “What is being done to prevent this from happening in foster care?” To which she immediately replied, “I am not prepared to answer that.”
Need for Changes
Why couldn’t she answer me? What was so difficult about answering a question like that? Would it have violated child confidentiality laws for her to give me a simple response?
In the aftermath of Elisa’s murder we hear that Mayor Giuliani and other officials want to get child confidentiality laws lifted. Well, bravo! Are we to believe that lifting these laws will solve the problems of children in abusive situations? I think not. There are numerous other important changes that have to be made to ensure that children are not abused by biological or foster parents:
o Let’s start with restoring funding to the CWA, plus adding some. The CWA has lost more than $200 million in State and City funding since Mayor Giuliani took office. Budget cuts which contributed to heavy caseloads and fewer social workers may have played a role in causing Elisa’s death. City officials claim it was mandatory for the city to cut the foster care budget-yet at the same time the Mayor found a way to raise his salary and the salaries of other highly-paid city officials.
o The social workers and other staff members who were fired or laid off need to be rehired or replaced by new, well-trained social workers. Openings for 200 protective service caseworkers have not been filled for more than a year.
o Social workers salaries should also be raised. Some social workers do not do their jobs effectively and use the lame excuse that they’re underpaid. I can’t argue-they do have a point. But social workers are the ones who work directly with and take a great deal of responsibility for the children. I wish the Mayor would raise social workers’ salaries so they could hire a staff of highly-trained and caring professionals.
o Let’s also restore funding for youth programs like the Door, which help not just foster children but all children. They provide refuge from the streets, counseling, and most importantly, places to get help if we need to escape abuse.
But suppose the CWA had taken Elisa away from her abusive mother. Where would they have put her? If she was placed in a foster home there is no guarantee Elisa would not have met another kind of abuse. I have witnessed children being abused and severely mistreated by foster parents. The system needs to be reformed to prevent or minimize the abuse of children in care. Children have to be put in safe, caring homes.
o The system needs to thoroughly investigate foster homes. Workers should make unexpected visits. While foster parents have a right to privacy, the children’s well-being should be the CWA’s first priority. The children have a right to be in a clean home with enough food and clothing.
o We need to strictly monitor the money that goes into foster care. The private agencies get large sums of money from the city to pay for the needs of kids in care, but much of it is not spent on the children. Foster parents receive monthly stipends ranging from approximately $400 to $500 per month (depending on the age of the child). In many cases almost none of it reaches the children.
In three of the four foster homes where I have lived there has been little and sometimes no food and clothing. One of my foster mothers refused to give me transportation money for night school, $1 to buy a pen, or a few dollars to buy a book bag. “Use your own money!” my foster mother would say. (She meant my $67-a-month clothing allowance.) While some foster parents spend their stipends fairly, others use it to buy cars, furniture, jewelry and pay the mortgages on their homes. We, the foster children, are left with nothing to call our own-not even a chair or a bed.
o When children like Elisa are taken from abusive biological parents, they should be placed with caring individuals who will try to understand and provide support for them. I have noticed several ads in newspapers emphasizing money as rewards for becoming foster parents. Instead of luring people whose only motive is to get money, we have to find more creative ways to get people who genuinely love children to become foster parents.
An aggressive new advertising campaign focusing on the rewarding aspects of raising children could have a more positive impact on recruiting foster families. Some time ago I noticed a television ad about adoption urging the public to get involved and take some responsibility for the children in their communities. It would be wonderful to have such an ad for foster children which would reach a larger audience of potential foster parents.
As far as I’m concerned, the uproar over Elisa’s death is an act. The media is putting pressure on the Mayor, the Governor, and the CWA, so that everyone cares about the tragedy of the “Little Princess.” If only a few people had cared as much as they now claim, perhaps Elisa would be alive today.
But the saddest part about this tragic story is that in a few months little Elisa will be forgotten until another innocent child is brutally beaten to death.
Why does this have to be? Please tell me-why do we care only when an innocent child is killed? Why do we care only when it is too late?

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.