Why Confidence Matters

NYC: What is confidence?
Dr. Lori Evans: You can have confidence in a specific area, like feeling confident that you’re a good soccer player, but you may not feel good about yourself in general. In psychology, we look at confidence as a more global concept about self-that you feel good about who you are as a person, that you’re able to rely on yourself and you have faith in your own ability to make good judgments and good decisions for yourself.
NYC: Why is confidence an important issue for teens?
Dr. Evans: When kids are entering their teenage years, it’s when they really start to form who they are. Sometimes kids go to high school and want to try on new identities. And with that comes the struggle of, “Am I confident in who I am?”
Confidence is also important at this point because you’re going to meet academic struggles, emotional struggles and relationship struggles. When you’re younger, your parents or teachers can step in and help. By the time you get to be a teenager, you’re navigating some of those things on your own. So you want to have the confidence that you’re going to be able to do it right.
NYC: How can a lack of confidence affect a teenager’s life?
Dr. Evans: If you don’t have a good sense of self, you may get into bad relationships because you don’t think you deserve better. It’s the same with academics. If you don’t have the confidence that you’re a good student, that’s the time when we see academic failure, even for kids who may have done OK up until then.
Being a good student doesn’t mean that you have to be good at a specific subject. It means that you believe that you can learn, that you’re open to learning, and that if you have trouble you can get help. That’s what someone with really good confidence can do.
NYC: What are some ways a teen can increase his or her confidence?
Dr. Evans: For teenagers, it’s the time to find the thing that you really love to do. You don’t have to be the best-it’s OK to try out for a part in a play and maybe get a small part even though you don’t intend on being a Broadway actor. Sometimes it’s just the flexibility of trying new things.
But the underlying traits are just as important as specific skills. Even a child who’s a really good baseball player in elementary school may not be able to make it on a high school team because it’s just above where they’re at.
What I want that child to know is that the skills they’velearned-good sportsmanship, good athletic ability, the ability to get along with other people-are also skills that are going to help them across the board. It’s important to value the underlying things that give you general confidence.
NYC: Can a person force himself or herself to be self-confident by changing his or her behavior?
Dr. Evans: Yes. You may not be confident in something, but the more you do it, the better you’ll get at it. For example, if I have to talk in front of a bunch of people, at first I think, “I don’t like this. It makes me feel nervous and I’m going to mess up.” It’s only after I do it a number of times that I say, “That went all right.” If I just avoid it then I’ll never get better at it. Sometimes we work backwards and change the behavior first and then we realize, “Ah, now I’m thinking differently.”
NYC: In 2007, O, The Oprah Magazine had an article about children having inflated self-esteem. It suggested that too much self-esteem isn’t always a good thing, and low self-esteem isn’t necessarily a problem. Can you talk about that?
Dr. Evans: I think what researchers are talking about when they say “too much self-esteem” is when you think from age 7 that you’re going to be playing major league baseball, instead of thinking, “OK, I’m going to try for this.”
Always thinking, “I’m better than you,” that’s not self-esteem. If you have real self-esteem, it gives you the ability to be flexible in your thinking and accept help. The best athlete takes coaching well. Michael Jordan listens to his coach no matter how good a player he is, because he’s confident in his ability.
Low self-esteem, on the other hand, isn’t something we want. People should be realistic about their abilities to a certain extent. But we want teenagers to reach for the highest possible, and understand that even if that doesn’t happen, they can still be great people and have a good time. I never discourage someone from trying something, even if it’s a reach. As long as they know, “If I make it, great; if I don’t make it, I’m going to be OK.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.