New York City welfare hotels are not places people like to check into: the paint on the walls is peeling, windows are broken, and the air reeks of urine.
The Allerton Hotel on 23rd St. is such a hotel. On one recent day, a mother and a little girl who appeared to be four years old were handing in their room keys to the person in the lobby, which is standard procedure at any hotel. The child, with tears in her eyes, asked : “Are we going back home, mommy?” The mother answered, “don’t worry about it!”
don’t worry? If one’s parents don’t have a home in New York City, there is plenty to worry about.
Homeless and Out Of School
The National Coalition for the Homeless estimates that there are one million homeless people living in the United States, including 750,000 school-age children, 57% of whom do not attend school regularly.
In New York City, 12,000 families, including 26,000 children, have passed through the New York City welfare housing system because they have no place to live.
Being homeless is bad enough, but the only road out of the cycle of poverty and frustration is a good education. It is hard enough to get an education when one has a home. It’s even worse without one.
One needs to look no farther than the Times Square Hotel. Teenagers were hanging out in front of the hotel. Inside, they were spending as much time out of their rooms as in them. School seemed to be the farthest thing from their minds.
Even those who do have school on their minds, find it difficult to succeed.
“I like school very much, but moving here has made it hard for me to go to school…I feel embarrassed when my friends ask me where I live,” said Jessica, a homeless teen living in the Times Square Hotel. She said she used to go to Clara Barton HS in Brooklyn, two blocks from her old home, but now goes to Norman Thomas in Manhattan.
The fact that Jessica now goes to a school in a different borough underscores a problem with educating the homeless: the lack of a permanent residence.
The New York City Human Resources Administration (HRA) continues to place families in shelters and hotels without regard for community ties or educational needs, according to a report on homeless
children published by Advocates for Children, an advocacy group.
In their attempts to house these families, the HRA does not place them in the borough where they formerly lived, which would be the most comfortable and familiar setting for them. Being moved from one place to another results in multiple school transfers and has a detrimental impact on school attendance and academic performance, according to advocates for the homeless.
Absent Four Days a Week
Advocates for Children reported that 71% of the homeless families they recently interviewed were sheltered in a borough different from their last permanent home. Edward Kissane, coordinator of School
District One, stated, “The attendance of the kids in my district is fairly good, but not compared with those of the other kids in the school who aren’t homeless.”
In fact, the average daily attendance rate for homeless students in high school is 51%, compare to 84% citywide, according to Advocates for Children.
The Board of Education reported that more than half-55%-of homeless high school kids are absent at least four days per week.
In addition to being located in a new borough or school district,
the students encounter additional problems, said Kissane, the school official.
For example, a lack of financial resources for clothes and supplies interferes with regular school attendance. Kissane said that some of the kids don’t have an adequate supply of clothes or food.
Some educators are not as disheartened. “There was a time that these kids were not treated fairly, but now they are receiving the proper education,” said Jill Blair, an assistant to schools Chancellor Joseph A. Fernandez. She said this was the result of a plan adopted by the Board of Education that allows homeless students and their parents the option of remaining in their previous school or attending the one in their current zone.
In January 1989, former Chancellor Richard Green gave each school district full responsibility for coordinating educational services for all homeless students in their area.
Transportation Problems
One Board of Education program aimed at helping homeless student involves “wake up calls.” Ruth Romer, community associate, said, “I come every morning and wake up the kids so they can make the bus, but first we ask the permission of the parents.”
Transporting homeless students, while improved, still has its drawbacks.
“There are 125 school-age kids in the Time Square hotel. They all attend six different schools,” said Romer. First, students are loaded on a bus that goes from hotel-to-hotel before departing for the schools. In addition to the extra time lost waiting for others to board, students must wait until the bus reaches their respective schools.
Problems generally afflicting the homeless include the lack of permanent housing, no bus or train passes, and the difficulty and delay in obtaining old school records.
Kissane, the school official said, “We made progress, but we have a long way to go.”
Why Aren’t the Homeless in School?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.