A few months before I left for my freshman year of college at the University of Michigan, one of my friends was complaining that she did not get accepted to Vassar College because she was Asian. She blamed it on the theory of the so-called Asian invasion.
This is a theory that because there are so many academically strong Asian applicants for admission to college, and because colleges want a diverse student body and only accept a limited number of any one ethnic group, it’s harder for Asians to get into the colleges of their choice.
Do Black Students Have An Unfair Advantage?
Although she only had an 86 grade point average and a 1290 on her SATs, my friend felt that she should have been admitted to the incoming freshman class.
(Vassar College generally wants students with a grade point average of 90 and above, and SAT scores of 1250 or above.)
She justified her belief by remarking that a Black girl in her school was accepted to Harvard with only a 92 grade point average and a 1380 on her SATs. (Harvard has higher admission standards than Vassar. It generally accepts students with SAT scores of 1390 and above.)
My friend then added that the only reason this girl was admitted to Harvard was because of affirmative action, a policy that takes race, and sometimes gender, into account in hiring and admissions choices. But now that I’ve learned more about affirmative action, I don’t think my friend was right.
Affirmative Action-How It Works
How does affirmative action work? Well, colleges and universities generally receive far more qualified applications than they have room to accept. A school like Harvard could accept three times as many students and they’d all be great, but they can select only a few.
Sometimes a person’s extracurricular activities-like if they’re really good at sports-will be what makes the difference.
Sometimes the fact that an applicant’s family is wealthy and could contribute large amounts of money to the university helps. Often students whose parents attended the school have an easier time getting in.
Affirmative action gives an advantage to applicants who are members of minority groups that are underrepresented on college campuses, both because they have been historically discriminated against and because they still experience economic and social inequalities. Mostly, affirmative action helps Black and Hispanic students.
Listening to my friend complain, I wanted to debate her assertions, but was so confused about affirmative action, that I just ignored her remark instead.
I didn’t know whether affirmative action had played some role in the girl’s admissions. I wasn’t sure if affirmative action stigmatized Blacks or helped them to progress.
I Wanted to Make It On My Own
At the time, I was opposed to affirmative action. Although I wasn’t exactly sure what affirmative action was, I didn’t like the way it made Black people seem unintelligent-as if we couldn’t get a job or get into college ourselves.
I’d worked too hard in school for someone to tell me that I needed affirmative action to get into college.
During the last semester of my senior year, my economics teacher had preached to the class that we had to work hard when we got to college.
He didn’t want anyone to accuse us of being beneficiaries of affirmative action, and he thought we had to prove that we weren’t by showing how well we could do.
From that moment on, I viewed affirmative action as a kind of handicap for Black students that made us seem like we weren’t quite smart enough to do it on our own.
Lawsuits on Campus Charge Reverse Discrimination
Still, I couldn’t help wondering if my initial views were narrow-minded, especially since it seemed as if every other Black person I knew supported affirmative action.
This was evident when Proposition 209 was passed in California, a bill to end affirmative action at public universities in that state.
This bill affected most of my peers and me so strongly that we avoided applying to any schools in California because we thought we would not be accepted.
I opposed affirmative action, but subconsciously I thought I needed it to be admitted into college.
After I finished applying to all of my colleges, I tried to think about affirmative action as little as possible. But this fall, when I started my freshman year at the University of Michigan, I was unable to evade the issue any longer.
For one thing, a White student name Jennifer Gratz recently brought a big law suit against the university for using affirmative action in its admissions process.
She felt that because of affirmative action, the school had accepted minority students with lower grades and scores than hers, and therefore had discriminated against her and other White students.
The lawsuit was a big topic of conversation among the professors and the students. But whenever I brought up the general issue of affirmative action among my friends, they would quickly change the subject.
Proving Ourselves to The White Students
From what I could tell, many Black students, like me, who were not wealthy, were either confused about affirmative action or were for it. A lot of the upper and middle class Black students were against it.
Either way, many Black students on campus felt stigmatized by affirmative action and felt that they had to prove themselves to the White students. They wanted to think and talk about it as little as possible.
A lot of White students, on the other hand, especially White males, would make jokes about it through the school newspaper or through the school TV stations. The Michigan Daily, the school newspaper, even wrote an article that had the headline: “Even Squirrels Need Affirmative Action.”
Another newspaper, the Michigan Review, which is radically right wing, wrote comments that White people are now being discriminated against, and who cares about diversity.
For a while, I stopped talking about affirmative action. After all, I didn’t know a lot about it, and I was receiving a lot of negative responses.
Righting the Wrongs of America’s History
But that semester, I also signed up for a class on affirmative action. As the first semester of school progressed, and I started to learn more about it and understand its purpose, my views on affirmative action began to change.
The class had 13 students in all-seven Black students, four men and three women, and six White women. There were no White men, or any Asian, Indian or Spanish students. The professor was Jamaican.
In the class, I learned that affirmative action was first instituted in the United States in the 1960s during the Kennedy years to remedy the effects of discrimination against Blacks. This discrimination included slavery, the Jim Crow laws, the Black codes, and other acts of injustice against African Americans that had cut them off from economic and educational opportunities, and had left most Blacks impoverished.
Cut Off From Educational Opportunities
Because so many Blacks had to live, and often still do live, in poor, segregated neighborhoods, they did not have access to equal economic and educational opportunities. More importantly, if you look around at our schools and neighborhoods, today, often we still don’t. And lots of businesses were reluctant to hire Blacks, or to promote them to higher-level jobs. For Blacks, many doors were closed.
Besides, some African Americans had seen their parents and their grandparents oppressed by the system for so long that they felt hopeless.
Many minorities have experienced serious discrimination in this country, but African Americans have been held back and put down for so long that some still feel that the system will not allow them to succeed.
As time progressed, affirmative action was extended to other minorities, including Asians, Hispanics, Native Americans and White women.
As the country became more multiculturally diverse, and in turn more multiculturally aware, schools and businesses felt the pressure to diversify also.
Many colleges and businesses today use affirmative action to make their organizations more diverse, rather than as reparations for Blacks.
Personally, I feel that the original purpose of affirmative action, to right social injustice, is what we should focus on when we discuss whether it is right or wrong. And it’s obvious that there’s still plenty of social injustice in our country that still needs to be righted.
Maybe affirmative action did help me to earn a place at the University of Michigan.
But I also think many of us who may have benefited from affirmative action have had to overcome many more obstacles than other students, and that has prepared us for the obstacles we encounter in college.
I also think I wouldn’t have been accepted if my academic record in high school didn’t show that I could succeed, and the proof is that in the end, I have succeeded.
Why Affirmative Action Is Fair
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.