I’ve been in the foster care system for over 13 years, and know what it’s like to feel the loss, pain, and hope that so many of our young people face on a day-to-day basis. During all of my years in the system, I never had the opportunity to voice my opinion to those in charge of my life.
Whenever I asked my social workers questions pertaining to my well-being and future, I was always told, “James, don’t worry about anything, I’ll take care of it.” But this was never the case. I always ended up taking care of myself in the best way I knew how.
I feel that foster youth should have much greater input into decisions affecting them. Anyone over the age of 12 should be able to give constructive suggestions to their agencies and have a say in planning for their goals. But sadly enough, from my experience, this is seldom allowed in foster care.
We at FCYU felt it was necessary to do an article examining how youth are heard and responded to in foster care agencies. For example, do youth have a way to give positive or negative feedback to their agencies? Are they involved in hiring and training staff? Are former foster youth on the boards of agencies? Have agencies changed the way they do things as a result of hearing from the young people in their care?
When I was first approached to do this article, I instantly became interested. I felt the need not only to represent for myself, but for thousands of other foster care youth.
My intent was not to expose, bash, or disrespect agencies, but to let them know that youth are capable of being equal partners in decision-making and want to be heard.
Below are 17 prominent New York City foster care agencies I interviewed about youth involvement.
I wanted to learn about youth involvement at every agency, but I was on a deadline, and some agencies don’t seem to return phone calls. I gave each agency at least three chances to respond to my phone calls. I had the opportunity to talk with some truly helpful, down-to-earth people, and with some who were not.
I would like to commend all the agencies who responded to my phone calls. And for the agencies who didn’t respond, or who don’t have ways for youth to be involved, I urge you to take a lesson from the positive contributors to this article.
Agencies With a Significant Youth Voice
Leake and Watts
The group home director, Carlton Mitchell, said Leake and Watts has a leadership council made up of group home residents. They meet twice a month or when necessary. Youth must meet certain criteria to participate, such as wanting to get their lives together and having good attendance in school.
“If we don’t voice our opinions, the agency can do anything to us,” says Jermelle McNeil, an 18-year-old youth council member who’s been in foster care for three and a half years and who now resides in an independent living apartment.
The main issues discussed in the leadership council are relationships with other residents, problems in the home, and recreational activities.
The Leake and Watts youth council also has a support system between residents and staff. If a council member is having a problem, he or she can go to adult staff for help and advice.
Michelle Jones, a 19-year-old council member, presently resides in a mother/infant group home. Michelle has been in and out of foster care for seven years.
“I’ve been in the program for about one and a half years now,” Michelle said. “I want to make a better future for ourselves and a better life for our children. I feel this youth council really does listen to us. If we have any problems, the counselors are always here to help us out in any way that they can. I wouldn’t change anything about this agency!”
Mr. Mitchell feels the growth of the leadership council is steady, but it changes a lot because some residents move on. He said positive changes have been made as a result of youth input. One example is the Behavior Management Program, which helps residents maintain a good behavioral status through a point system.
“I think one of the ways that our youth council could be improved is by having more participation from young people, more activities, and meetings with various people that could help youth,” says Jermelle.
Leake and Watts said they don’t include young people in staff training and staff hiring. But keep up the good work!
Graham-Windham Services
It took me several phone calls over two weeks, but the aggravation was worth it when I spoke to independent living social worker Asif Talukdar, who was genuinely cool and helpful. Graham-Windham’s youth council meets weekly with Mr. Talukdar. The agency is in the process of adding a teen peer support program, which will be a part of the youth council.
In order to participate in both councils, young people must be chosen through social workers or child care workers. Subjects top on the list during council meetings include the services young people receive, how effective the services are, and young people’s plans on leaving foster care. Money management is also a major concern among residents. Mr. Talukdar says the youth council has helped residents to become more focused on doing things for themselves instead of always looking to staff members.
Mr. Talukdar says youth council members are invited to give their opinions and suggestions in staff training and hiring. Former foster care youth have been employed by the agency. Graham-Windham Services also has an internship program for foster care youth, which mainly focuses on social work issues.
Although there aren’t any youth on the agency’s Board of Directors, Mr. Talukdar is very open to the suggestion. “Our goal is to have youth communicate with us. We do accept and want constructive criticism. The most important factor is communication.”
Lakeside Family & Children’s Services
After several phone calls, Bruce Weichbrodt, director of quality assurance, returned my call. He was very informative. Mr. Weichbrodt feels youth input is vital when making agency decisions. Lakeside has two youth councils. The Group Home Council members meet with social workers and child care workers. The Foster Care Council members meet with independent living workers. Both councils meet monthly.
Foster Care Council members mainly talk about issues in the foster home. Clothing allowances are mainly discussed among Group Home Council members.
When tackling the subject of staff training and hiring, Mr. Weichbrodt personally feels it’s a good idea for young people to be involved, but Lakeside doesn’t include young people. At present the agency doesn’t have any foster youth on their Board of Directors, but they have had former foster care youth on their Board.
Agencies Developing a Youth Voice
Brookwood Child Care
Darci Rosenberg, independent living coordinator, told me that Brookwood is in the process of forming a youth council in association with the Youth Advocacy Center. Ms. Rosenberg said youth will be chosen by their school attendance and participation in meetings. They will also be able to give suggestions on decisions affecting them.
St. Christopher’s Jennie Clarkson
This agency is in the process of forming a youth council and an advocacy program among its female residents, which will be expanded eventually to the males in the agency. I spoke with parent advocate Jasmine Johnson and 16-year-old future youth council member Latisha Williams.
Ms. Johnson acts as a mentor and big sister to the young women in the program. If a problem should arise between two residents, Ms. Johnson helps resolve it. Latisha Williams also acts as a problem solver, intervening in personal and residential disputes. “If two residents are having problems with one another, I try to get the both of them to work it out in a positive manner,” she said.
The young women meet two to three times a week with Ms. Johnson and staff members. The girls range in age from 13 to 17. Some even have on-campus paying jobs, which gives them a sense of responsibility.
When asked how the young women will be chosen for the youth council, Ms. Johnson stated that she will look for leadership material-someone who is well-spoken and who can represent for the other residents. In their meetings, the young women often talk about the harsh realities of group home life, such as stealing, marijuana smoking, and restriction. Although these young people have seen and faced hard times, their main objectives in the youth council will be teamwork and unity.
Coalition For Hispanic Family Services
John Paul Gonzalez, director of education and youth development, informed me that the agency is in the process of forming a program called Youth Leadership Development. The young people in this program will be making short video documentaries on a wide range of issues related to foster care and the community.
This youth council will meet weekly with staff and agency consultants. Mr. Gonzalez also stated that the goal of this council is to help youth become thinkers and problem solvers.
Agencies That Didn’t Respond or That Responded Negatively
Good Shepherd Services/McMahon
After being bounced around the switchboard and voice-mail for a day, I talked to Sister Claire Napoleon, director of social services.
As I started my interview questions, Sister Napoleon became agitated and impatient. Her phone manner got worse after she was told that I was interviewing her for a story in FCYU. She became defensive and began questioning me on how I got her name and the agency’s name.
As I gave her examples of my article’s focus-that youth voices are important or that youth should have a formal way of expressing concerns-Sister Napoleon replied in a sarcastic tone, “Youth do have independent living!”
Her reply to the rest of my questions was, “No comment.”
Lutheran Social Services of Metropolitan N.Y., Inc.
Pastor Rouse, deputy director of programs, would not answer or comment on any questions from me pertaining to this article. He said we needed to get ACS permission in order to interview him or anyone in the agency. When told that the subject of the interview was not a confidential topic, but youth involvement, he still refused all comment without ACS approval.
Angel Guardian Home
I left messages for Gloria Singleton, independent living director, but my calls were not returned.
Abbott House
Sister Mary Jane Fitzgibbon in the community relations department said she had no knowledge of any youth council at the agency.
I tried several other departments. After a runaround with the switchboard, I reached a foster care worker and left a message about the nature of my call. I was told that someone would get back to me. I never got a response.
St. Vincent’s Services, Inc.
I called three separate times and was transferred to several different departments. My messages weren’t returned.
Children’s Village
Markham Breen, assistant director of recreation and W.A.Y. (Work Appreciation for Youth), always seemed to miss my numerous phone calls. (He finally returned my calls, but too late to be included in this article.)
Little Flower Children’s Services
I spoke to staff in the Home Finding Unit and to Roger Rigolli, supervisor of independent living, but no one had answers or know who I should speak to.
Rigolli suggested that I call Little Flower’s Wading River office on Long Island.
When I did, I spoke to the director’s secretary, Kristy. She said she’d have the director get back to me. (No response).
St. Dominic’s Home
I left messages on three separate days, and I’m still waiting for someone to get back me.
New York Foundling
I left two messages with the secretary to Valerie Gundersen in the development department, but no one called back.
Jewish Child Care Association Of New York
After several games of phone tag, I never caught up with Richard Johnson, director of the Youth Residence Center.
Episcopal Social Services
I called three times and finally got in contact with the director’s assistant. In a firm voice she said, “When the director gets a chance to call you, she will.” (In other words, I shouldn’t call them anymore.)
Conclusion
Writing this article was not an easy task. Calling all of these agencies and getting substantial answers was like pulling teeth, with the exception of a few agencies. But I must admit that I’ve learned and gained so much knowledge on reporting. (Thanks to my homies and peeps Al Desetta, Keith Hefner, and Tina Rosenberg of The New York Times.)
Let’s cut to the chase-without input from foster care youth, there will be no change in foster care agencies, and no reform of the system itself. Think about it-if we’re the ones keeping agencies in business, we deserve the right to be heard by them.
I was a little teed off with some of the unprofessional responses I received from certain agencies, but I expected this. It isn’t often that someone calls them to ask questions about the young people in their care.
I also felt some of my interviews with these agencies were “public relations” sessions that provided little information about youth councils. It is best when agencies are completely open as to how things are really done. (Without cover-ups or drama!) It is also best when youth councils have an actual impact on how agencies function, rather than just serve as “rap sessions.”
I’m hoping this article will open the eyes of those who are in charge of our lives and well-being. (Namely, ACS officials and social workers, as well as all other staff and foster parents.)
I’m also hoping that we can all work together for positive change, a word that is used excessively by many foster care officials and authorities. Will fundamental changes really be made within the foster care system, or is “change” a convenient word to cover up never-ending problems?
And when we talk about change, let’s not forget the concerns, needs, and interests of youth. We have the right to be included in making agency decisions that affect us.
Note: As mentioned earlier, my intent was not to bash or dog out foster care agencies. But from my personal dealings with the foster care system for over 13 years, I feel I do have the right to speak out on issues affecting me. Youth issues are not being taken seriously enough and this must be addressed.
Where’s the Youth Voice in the System?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.