When It Comes to Sex, Women Foot the Bill

The role of a health insurance company is to help people pay for health care, right? Health insurance companies help cover the cost of hospital stays, visits to the doctor and prescription drugs.
Birth control pills are the drug most commonly prescribed to women between the ages of 15 and 44, according to The New York Times. But many health insurance companies do not cover them, or other prescription contraceptives like Depo-provera and Norplant, and never have. Does that make sense?
Wait, it gets better. Many of the same companies that won’t pay for birth control began to insure Viagra, a drug to cure impotence (that’s when men can’t get an erection), as soon as it came out.
Having Sex v. Having a Child
A lot of women’s rights activists think this policy is a form of discrimination against women and I think they’re right.
I don’t understand how insurance companies can think that Viagra is more worthy of being covered than birth control. Is a man’s being able to have sex whenever he wants more important than a woman’s being able to prevent getting pregnant?
In my opinion, access to birth control will have a much bigger impact on a person’s life than access to Viagra.
I’m sure that not being able to get an erection when you want to have sex is no fun, but having a child, particularly if you’re not ready or if you can’t support it, affects every aspect of your life-not to mention the child’s.
A Double Standard
And the bottom line is that it’s unfair. Women of child-bearing age spend 68% more of their own money (as opposed to what’s covered by insurance) on health care than men do, much of it on contraception, according to The New York Times. (That’s because prescription contraceptives are expensive. Birth control pills cost about $30 per month.)
Even though they’re not exactly the same, both birth control and Viagra are drugs that affect people’s sex lives.
“They both allow more freedom [to experience] sexual pleasure,” is how Alexander C. Sanger, President of Planned Parenthood of New York City put it.
If a woman is worried about getting pregnant, her freedom to have and enjoy sex is limited. “This disparity of covering Viagra and not birth control says that insurance companies believe that freedom to experience sexual pleasure belongs to men only,” Sanger said.
Margaret Sanger’s Fight
Getting access to birth control has always been a big issue for women. When Margaret Sanger (the founder of Planned Parenthood and Alexander Sanger’s grandmother) opened her first clinic in 1916, it was shut down by the police.
Margaret Sanger was arrested many times for providing women with information about birth control. But she continued to fight to make birth control legal because, as a nurse, she had seen so many women crying when they found out they were pregnant, because they could not support the children they already had. She had also seen women die because of illegal, unsanitary abortions
What’s the difference between then and now? Not all that much, in my opinion. Sure, birth control is legal now, but if the people who need it can’t afford it because it’s not covered by their health insurance companies, can we really say that it’s “available”?
If it is a choice between birth control or rent, food, or electricity, it’s pretty obvious what most people are going to choose.
Women’s Needs Are Ignored
In the past, insurance companies argued that covering birth control was just too expensive. According to Planned Parenthood, many health insurance companies don’t see reproductive health care as part of basic health care and don’t seem to realize that, in the long run, covering birth control is cheaper than covering the costs for prenatal care and giving birth.
But when it comes to Viagra, which costs about $10 a pill, money has never been an issue, as far as the insurance companies go.
What does this basically say? That what men want is more important than what women need. Let men have their pleasure; who cares about who gets impregnated because of it? Men should be able to have sex whenever they want without any costs, but women should never be able to have sex without risking pregnancy.
In short, when women want to have sex, there’s a price to pay. For men, it’s a free ride.
If Men Got Pregnant…
Pregnancy shouldn’t just be a woman’s issue, but too often men act like it is. Why should they care? It’s not like they’re the ones getting pregnantâ(Hey, now that’s an idea.)
The birth control v. Viagra controversy says a lot about how our society approaches sexuality in general. We say we want low teenage pregnancy rates, fewer single mothers, fewer kids in need of caretakers, and we definitely don’t want to read any stories about mothers trying to kill babies that they don’t want.
How do we expect to get what we want without giving women cheap and easy access to birth control?
There is only one good thing that has come out of this. Women who used to just accept having to pay for birth control have became angry and started a serious campaign for equality.
They are demanding that laws be passed to force insurance companies to pay for contraception as well as Viagra. In 1999, 10 states passed these laws. Unfortunately for us, New York wasn’t one of them.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.