I was interested to find out how advertising companies target teens and what effects, if any, advertising has on teens’ lives. So I decided to interview media literacy expert Renee Hobbs, a professor at Temple University’s School of Communications and Theater in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, and founder of the university’s Media Education Lab.
-Isma Aslam
NYC: What is media literacy? How does it relate to advertising?
Renee Hobbs: Media literacy is the ability to critically analyze messages. A very large portion of the messages we get exposed to these days are advertising and promotional messages. It’s not always obvious how advertising works to affect our attitudes, our beliefs and our emotions. So learning to analyze advertising is a big part of being media literate.
NYC: Why do advertisers target teens?
Hobbs: Advertisers target teens because teens are just beginning to establish their buying habits. Their moms bought Crest, so now that they’re 17, they want to buy Colgate or some [other brand]. They’re establishing their unique identity outside of family [through buying]. In this kind of consumer culture we use buying to reflect our identity, and that’s what teens are all about.
NYC: Is there a problem with establishing identity through buying?
Hobbs: The culture of advertising equates your personal identity with your buying behavior, and that’s a big problem. Your personal identity is all wrapped up in what you own, so your identity is kind of fragile. “I own this brand name.” “I have this cool piece of technology.” That’s not much of an identity to go on.
There are probably too many kids in America who invest a lot in establishing their identity by what they buy in the mall instead of by hard work, developing their creative, communication and writing skills, and their talent.
I think that’s the biggest way advertisers affect teens negatively. The purchase of products becomes a substitute for figuring out who you are.
NYC: Is there anything wrong with the way companies advertise to teens?
Hobbs: One of the things that bothers me a lot is the way advertisers use sexuality to sell to teens. I also don’t like the way advertising reinforces rigid gender roles.
One [example] is the way that energy drinks like Red Bull are marketed. Women don’t drink them because most of the time they’re marketed to men. And what kinds of colors are used to market energy drinks to men? Colors like red, black and bright neon green.
Advertisers have recognized that most of us are unconscious about the way color can be connected to identity and emotion. And an energy drink in a black bottle with bright red letters communicates a type of masculinity different from a light green bottle with yellow letters. Advertising reinforces gender identity in ways that sometimes we’re not even aware of.
NYC: How can teens fight back against pressure from advertisers?
Hobbs: Teens are fully capable of analyzing and resisting advertising, and the single best thing that a teen can do is ask questions. Asking questions about advertising creates that “aha!” experience-you see the ad in a new way.
I always try to encourage people to ask when they look at advertising: what values are presented and what’s left out? Asking critical questions is a good way to begin the process of resisting advertising.
If you’re watching an ad for Red Bull, ask what values are presented? You’re going to see how the idea of strength and power and invulnerability are communicated through the idea that just by drinking this drink you’re going to be strong and powerful. Then you start realizing what a goofy thing that is.
We [should also] ask what’s missing when we look at a Red Bull ad. We don’t see any information about what is in the product. [We don’t see anything] about whether or not huge doses of caffeine are healthy for our bodies or whether or not drinking more than one might make you feel really uncomfortable because of the over-consumption of stimulants. Looking for what’s missing leads to some insight, too.
What’s Wrong With Red Bull Ads?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.