“The baby will be a girl,” said my mother. She was standing by the bathroom door as I washed my face. She’s pregnant and had just gone to the clinic to find out the sex of the baby.
“Oh! How do you know?” I asked.
“The doctor told me,” she said sadly.
“That will be great. I want to have a sister,” I said. I really didn’t care what my new sibling would be, but I was trying to make my mother feel better. I knew she was anxious about having a baby girl because my grandmother wants her to have a boy.
In China, where my family is from, sons are valued more than daughters. That’s because traditionally when a daughter grows up and gets married, she goes to live with her husband’s family. But a son will stay by his family’s side forever, look after his parents in their old age, and take on the responsibility of the family’s work after they retire.
Give Me a Grandson!
When my mother found out she was pregnant again last February, my family was very happy about it, especially my grandmother, who’d always told my mother how much she’d love to have another grandson. So that day when my mother came back from the clinic with the news that it would be a girl, my grandmother was in despair. She asked my 36-year-old mother to have more babies until she has a boy.
When my mom told my sister Judy and me about that, we were angry and thought my grandmother must be crazy. How could she even say such a thing to my mother? What would happen if my mom just kept having more girls? My parents would be stuck with more mouths to feed and my grandmother would still be unhappy.
Even though my grandmother now lives in America, she’s never let go of the idea that boys are more valuable than girls. She’s afraid of being alone in her old age if she doesn’t get another grandson. And there’s some truth to her fear. Even in America, most Chinese families I know still follow the tradition where women leave their families to go live at their husbands’ houses. So to my grandmother, my sister and I are only part of the family temporarily, while a boy would stay with her forever.
One Child Allowed
Boys have become even more valuable ever since China created the “One-Child Policy” in 1979. That’s when the government decided that to prevent the country from overpopulating, women weren’t allowed to have more than one child each.
The policy still exists today in China. When a woman is discovered to be pregnant with a second child, a government representative warns her to have an abortion immediately.
If she doesn’t, I’ve heard that the woman could be punished by losing her job or having to pay fines equivalent to a few years’ salary for each parent.
In some villages, though, I’m told that officials actually encourage women to have a second or third child so fines can be imposed. The money they collect belongs to the local government, but corrupt officials sometimes keep the money.
That happens in the Chinese village I lived in before moving here at age 11. But since most of the women in my village are poor farmers and can’t afford the fines, they have to have run away to hide from the officials.
$2000 for a Boy
Fortunately, my mother could afford the fines for us while we were in China, since my grandparents and other relatives sent us money from New York. My mother paid about $1,525 for me, her second child, and about $2,000 for her third-born child, a son. She didn’t mind the fine because she was able to get a boy, like my grandmother wanted.
But my little brother ended up having serious health problems. Last year when he was 6, we found out he had a tumor in his brain that was causing his left side to be weaker than his right, making it difficult for him to walk.
He had brain surgery in May 2004. The surgery was successful but his emotions changed afterwards. He started having uncontrollable outbursts and sometimes even yelled at my grandparents. My grandparents wanted to have a healthy grandson. That’s why my grandmother asked my mom to have another kid.
Girls Not as Good?
My grandmother also prefers boys because she thinks they’re better at earning money. When my mother and other cousins immigrated to America, they worked at cafes and found the jobs so exhausting and difficult that they quit. Now they’re unemployed and the only people in our family with jobs are men.
I think that’s part of the reason my grandmother treats my sister and me like we’re not important. We never even met my grandmother until she came to China to see my brother when he was born, when I was 10 and my sister was 11. She came to see him, not us.
She treats my sister and me well, but not as well as she treats my brother. It makes me feel uncomfortable and confused. How can she treat her grandchildren differently because of our gender?
I think my grandmother even values men more than she values herself. She was born in a poor family. She wasn’t allowed to arrange her own marriage and she didn’t meet my grandfather until their wedding. Her father decided everything for her and she says she appreciates all he did for her. Since then, she has believed daughters have no right to choose their own spouse.
Trapped by My Culture
Her ideas make me feel like I can’t decide my own future. I want to go to college, major in math and become a math teacher, but my family has asked me to be a policewoman or a nurse when I grow up. I feel like I have no right to make my own decisions.
When I get married, I know I’ll go live with my husband’s family because that’s our tradition and I feel I have to follow it. It makes me angry to feel so trapped by my culture. But at the same time, I know that if I go against the traditional female role that may mean the end of my relationship with my family, and I’m not willing to risk that.
My mother doesn’t completely share my grandmother’s views. She doesn’t want to have more children. She thinks it will be a burden for my father, who’s the only one who works. On the other hand, she doesn’t want to disappoint my grandmother. So, she has compromised with my grandmother. She’ll try one more time after this baby and hope that the next child-her 5th and final child-will be a boy.
My Future Sister’s Future
As for me, I just want my future sister to be healthy. I also don’t want her to grow up with the same pressure and family structure that I’ve grown up with.
I hope that things change, but I don’t think they will. I think she’ll still have to follow our own traditions even though she’ll be nearly a generation younger than me. But I do think my future sister might rebel against the tradition more, since she’ll be American-born. And I hope she does.
SIDEBAR: Girls Rule!
Although boys are valued more than girls in most of China, in one remote area of southwestern China, itÕs the opposite. In the Mosuo culture, which has a population of about 50,000 and has existed since ancient times, women have all the power. Women live with their maternal family, own all the property and hand it down to their daughters and sisters. Women only see men at the end of the day when they choose which man they want to take home that night. During the day, each man lives with his own motherÕs family and works at home, but his main job is making babies. Those babies are raised entirely by the mother and her family, though-the word ÒfatherÓ doesnÕt exist in Mosuo culture.
