If We Ran the World: A Roundtable About Patriarchy

Recently, three female writers from Represent and YCteen-Chantel Jackson; Angie Carty; and A, who prefers to be anonymous-talked about how women are kept down by the patriarchy. Patriarchy refers to all the ways men still have power over women. It still shows up a lot, despite laws supposedly granting women equality.
Patriarchy includes under-reporting (or allowing) rape; women’s bodies and clothes being constantly commented on; women making less money than men; laws against access to birth control and abortion; women expected to do more housework and childcare; men outnumbering women at the top in government, business, religions, and many other places. It’s the double standard of “boys will be boys,” but girls who have sex are “hos.”
The three young women described how patriarchy affects them.

Have you ever felt objectified, like guys are treating you like a body, not a person?
Chantel: When I was in the 8th grade, I joined the junior Knicks basketball team at the YMCA. I was the only girl and I asked my teammates not to do the slap-ass with me. But they still did it, so I quit because they wouldn’t listen. I was 13. It made me sad. I really wanted to play.
A: Some guys on the street try to sexualize my friend and me when we skateboard. They say, “Look at her ass.” They take me out of my element and make me feel self-conscious.
Chantel: They prey! Older guys hit you with “Age ain’t nothing but a number.” For you, maybe, but not for me!
Angie: I had on shorts and knee socks and this guy was trying to talk to me, and I said, “I’m 16!” and he said, “I’m 16 too.” He was 30! Girls are sexualized so young, and they put it on the girls. Your mom says, “A man is coming over, change out of those shorts.” Get the guy who’s looking at a young girl out of the house! Men need to realize that they’re not entitled to our bodies.
Do women look at other women through men’s eyes?
Angie: Yes. I had low self-esteem, and I felt ugly, and I looked at girls who dressed provocatively and said, “I’m not like them. I’m modest and I have values.” But women tearing down other women benefits men who don’t respect us. It keeps us from unifying against them.
Chantel: It’s OK if a woman dresses sexy. It’s OK if a woman isn’t feminine. You don’t have to bash people for things like that.
Angie: If we weren’t judging on those superficial things, we’d judge people by how they really are on the inside. Like that girl in the crop top-she might help the homeless.
Chantel: As you get older, girls are less judgmental of each other and more judgmental of men.
Angie: Movies train men to think that if she says no, she’s just playing hard to get and you’re supposed to try harder. And we women internalize this misogyny [hatred of women]. We see it as normal. If a guy keeps trying, we think “Oh, it’s so romantic, he wants to win my favor.” When really, not knowing how to take no for an answer is a huge red flag.
Only about 20% to 30% of rapes are reported, and fewer than 1% of rapists go to prison. Why do you think rapists continue to basically get away with it?
Chantel: I think some women feel like if they do report a rape, nothing will happen. So they don’t tell. It’s a lose-lose. You get bashed if you come out or if you don’t.
A: Looking at the statistics, it looks like basically rape is normal. Nobody reports it because they feel like it’s inevitable.
Angie: The shame is immediately placed on women when they’re raped or molested. Women are “stained” or “dirty” after a sexual assault. You should be shaming the man instead.
A: And as a woman, you get blamed for what you were wearing.
Angie: Clothes are not consent, consent is consent.
Chantel: They decide who you are by what you’re wearing.
How would you define consent?
All Three: Mutual agreement.
Angie: If you’re in the middle of having sex and say no, it becomes not mutual anymore and he needs to stop.
A: Growing up, I hoped I’d marry the person I lost my virginity to. I was 18 and dating this guy I really liked. I told him I didn’t want to have sex when we made out, and he went along with that. But I guess one time, he didn’t really care and he kept pushing me. Once it was in, I just stopped saying no. I felt like it was all over. I’m pretty sure I’m not the only person that happened to.
What changes would help?
A: We should put more emphasis on defining consent.
Chantel: Every rape or assault charge should be brought to trial.
A: The statute of limitations shouldn’t apply.
Angie: In 30 years, the victim is still going to be thinking of the assault. The rapist may not be thinking about it all that time.
Chantel: People are scared of the outcomes of telling, so they choose not to. But that weight on you can become overwhelming much later, so you should be able to tell whenever you’re ready.
How can a man prove he’s a feminist ally?
Angie: Through action. Are they going to rallies and protests in support of women? Or just saying, “I support women, now have sex with me”? Some guys think if they white-knight enough you’ll have sex with them.
And by listening. Men shouldn’t talk over you and tell you, “Here’s what women need; here’s how we should change things.”
They should stop expecting praise for everything. A guy will say, “Well, I was at a party and this woman was so intoxicated, but I didn’t rape her.” Really, you want a cookie because you didn’t rape someone?
Does pressure to be “manly” hurt men too?
Angie: The idea that emotion is inferior is part of toxic masculinity. Boys are taught: don’t cry, keep it all inside, no one wants to hear that, you’re weak if you show emotion. But girls are taught from a young age to be more vulnerable and to share secrets.
If a guy vents to you and tells you something personal, then he’s like, “Wow, do you want to be my girlfriend?” But I’ve been doing this with my girlfriends for a long time, and it doesn’t mean there’s a romantic bond.
Chantel: A guy will tell me something personal and say, “I can’t talk to my bros about this.” I’m like, “Then you need to get some new bros.”
Angie: I believe that a lot of male anger comes from the fact they can’t talk about what’s bothering them, and it sits in them and it rots.
There’s always going to be groups for abused women, and we’ll flock to those groups. Men and boys need those safe spaces to talk about the issues in their lives.
Can you envision a world where nobody’s oppressing anyone?
Angie: I can’t. It’s hard to imagine a world where someone’s not trying to get over on someone else and take what they have. It’s been happening since cavemen went to steal other people’s meat.
Chantel: People should stop grouping people; that’s the only way things could get better. I know people need individuality and group identities, but I think we need to emphasize how we’re the same. It’s maybe because I’m pansexual, but genders don’t mean that much to me. Division by gender is keeping us back from a lot of things in society.
Angie: If the world were suddenly to become a matriarchy [ruled by women] tomorrow, I think we wouldn’t oppress men like they’vedone to us, because we have the knowledge of what they’vedone to us. But if it started out a matriarchy, men would be on the bottom of the food chain. It’s human nature to oppress those who you think are less than you.
A: we’re starting to rise up against the systems oppressing us, and eventually we’ll be somewhere else. I think we’ll be in a better place in 10 years. Change is slow, but sure.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.