As a teacher at Chelsea Vocational HS, Robert Mitchell often found himself advising students on where to go to college. When they wanted information about specific schools, he would refer them to college guides. But he became frustrated with the ones that were available because most of his students were Black and Latino and the guides “wouldn’t [even] explain what percent of African-American students were male or female.” One guide he read had “a really quick paragraph” about African-American affairs on campus, but that was it.
That’s what inspired Mitchell to write The Multicultural Student’s Guide to College. He hopes his book will “fill the void left by the other guides by providing information that will allow students of color to make confident and wise college choices.”
The Multicultural Guide took Mitchell three years to write. His first step was to put together a list of the best liberal arts schools in the country. After selecting the schools, he sent their administration offices questionnaires to fill out. These asked for statistical information. To get the student perspective, he also tracked down the minority student organizations at different colleges, called them up and interviewed anyone who answered the phone.
About 10 or 20 of the schools on his original list didn’t make it into the book because there were no students of color attending those schools. Of the schools that do appear, Mitchell says there are a few that he wouldn’t want to send any of his students to. He wouldn’t tell me exactly which ones, but said if you look carefully at the way he wrote the descriptions, you can probably figure it out for yourself.
For instance, there’s the University of Alabama. In his description of the school, Mitchell points out that there’s a lot of segregation and racial tension among the students. He goes on to write that one fraternity celebrates “Old South Day,” when they glorify the days of the Confederacy, and hang the Confederate flag out of one of their windows. After reading that description, I certainly didn’t want to go there.
Historically Black Colleges
One issue that Mitchell’s book raises that isn’t really addressed in other guidebooks is whether it’s good for African-American students to attend historically Black colleges. Students who choose that option want to learn in an environment that is relatively free of racism and where the Black student is the center of attention. There are a variety of other reasons, too-from the opportunity to study with Black professors and attend classes where topics of special interest to the Black community are incorporated to interacting daily with lots of other motivated Black students.
But a drawback is that you “don’t get to interact with the White community.” This may sound like a blessing to some, but in order to get a taste of the real world, you have to be in contact with all types of people, especially White people.
Finding Your Best Fit
If you choose to attend a predominately White school, Mitchell says to “make sure there are resources that allow you to…feel comfortable there,” such as a Black student union. He says that Black, Latino, and Asian students can definitely be happy at a predominately White school. “I know they can,” he told me. “My students who went to DePauw (the small liberal arts school in Indiana that Mitchell himself attended) made so many good friends.” His former students who chose DePauw “were happy” and they got a “good education.” But he emphasizes that students have to figure out for themselves what kind of environment they’ll “feel most comfortable in.”
If you feel that neither a predominately Black nor a predominately White school is the move for you, don’t feel that you’re out of luck. The guide also profiles a lot of schools that are pretty well integrated with students from different racial and ethnic groups as well as foreign students. Attending these schools is a learning experience in itself. You learn how to communicate with all different types of people, which is what you’ll have to do when you graduate and venture out into the job market.
Even though the book is called The Multicultural Student’s Guide, Mitchell emphasizes that the ethnicity of the student body is just one of many things you should consider when choosing a school. The choices you make should depend on what you think would be “your best fit.” Don’t depend on your counselor or your mother to tell you what school you should go to. After all, you are the one that has to go there, not them. Says Mitchell, “I try to talk to my students to get… them to know themselves.”
Mitchell says that you should think about a school’s location -is it in a small town or a big city, close to home or far away-and make sure it will be OK with you. You should also look at a school’s academic program. I know this sounds very simplistic, but you should make sure the schools you apply to offer the major you’re interested in. Another thing that many people don’t think about is the retention rate, which tells you what percentage of students who enter a school as freshmen actually graduate. If it’s low then that means that there is something wrong. Mitchell says that “if it’s like 30 or 40%, [a student should think] that’s not for me. If it’s 80% or 90%…that’s better.”
Top Picks
Mitchell would never dictate a school to any student of his, or anyone who asked him for advice, but there are some schools that he particularly recommends to students of color. His alma mater, DePauw University, was first on his list. “I’ve sent a lot of my students there,” he said. “They liked it a lot.” The retention rate there is about 92%, so it’s a very good school to look into. He also recommends Oberlin College in Ohio and Rutgers University in New Jersey. He says that students he’s spoken to seem to love Xavier University of Louisiana in New Orleans. They also have good things to say about Williams College in Massachusetts and Howard University in Washington, D.C.
No matter what kind of college you want to go to-predominately White or Black, small or large-Mitchell advises you to “begin the search early, in your junior year.” He says to “study for your SATs. Get in touch with counselors. Find out about scholarships.” He also advises you to visit the schools you want to apply to and see them for yourself.
What Minority Students Need to Know: A Teacher’s Advice
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.