Weird? Shy? Nerdy?-Think Again!

Everybody knows what it’s like to be quiet and shy at least once in their lifetime. Like many teens, Rosanna Gautreaux, 17, of A. Philip Randolph HS, said she feels that way “when I’m around a new crowd, but when I get to know them, I loosen up.”
For Joyce Owusuansah, 19, of City College, it only happens “when it comes to guys. Your heart stops and [you] can’t say nothing and the words will not come out right.”
We’ve all been in situations like these, but when you’re overly quiet or shy, people have a tendency to shut you out of their conversations. Half of the time they forget you’re even there.
The Loner Image
When you take quietness too far, certain people sometimes get the wrong idea about you. “[People] think you’re stuck up,” said Diane Aranda, 17, also of City College.
Angi Baptiste, 18, a graduate of New Utrecht HS, says that people sometimes think “that you’re innocent. You’re not a wild person. They think of you like a mama’s boy or mama’s little girl.” And my sister, Jennie Kwan, 14, of Lafayette HS, said being too timid can get you a reputation “as a weird, shy, nerdy, loner kind of person.”
Whether they considered themselves quiet or not, most of the teenagers I spoke to said that when you’re that way people don’t get to know who you are and you don’t get to know them either. “A lot of times if you’re quiet and shy, you won’t have friends,” said Mohamed Khan, 17, of City-As-School. “You feel bad ’cause you don’t know many people and that leads to depression.”
Leon Antoine, 14, of John Dewey HS, who started out a shy person and decided to change, agrees: “You miss out on life [and] on your childhood.” Leon told me that these days “I have a big mouth and I use it a lot. I made new friends, a lot of friends.”
Good Listeners
But being quiet does have its advantages as well. Both Joyce and Rosanna agreed that quiet people are better able to stay out of trouble. Mohamed, who considers himself a shy person, said that “you become a good listener…I learn better not saying anything.”
“[Quiet people] show a little more respect than people who yap and yap and go on and on,” he added.
Interestingly, the word “respect” came up a lot during my interviews. “I treat quiet people with more respect than people with loud mouths,” said Leon.
Wild on the Inside
Rosanna also treats those who are quiet differently. “I give them a little more attention so they can open up,” she said. Diane and Joyce, on the other hand, both said they treat quiet people the same as they would anyone else.
However you treat them, it’s important to realize that not every quiet person is as timid, “stuck up,” “innocent,” or “nerdy” as people may perceive them to be. Angi put it best when she said, “Quiet people are not as quiet as they seem to look.”
People like Angi and myself have a tendency to think a lot and keep to ourselves much of the time. But that doesn’t mean that we’re purposely ignoring you or that we sit home reading books on Saturday nights. Some of us are really pretty wild on the inside, we just don’t show it on the outside.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.