From gossip problems to fights over girlfriends or boyfriends, from group rivalries to differences with teachers, conflicts are part of our everyday life. Sometimes these conflicts build up, feeding resentment, hatred and anger, and sometimes even exploding into violence.
But conflicts can often be settled peacefully through an intermediate who helps each side explain the problem and reach a solution. For example, last summer, Miguel Ayala, 20, got angry with another guy at his group home because he’d stolen Miguel’s CD player. Miguel started a loud argument that almost drove them to a fight.
But their group home has a program that helps fix these kinds of conflicts. When the staff saw Miguel about to fight with the other guy, they immediately sent them to the office for mediation.
They Kept the Friendship
“The first thing they asked me to do was to not antagonize the situation any further,” said Miguel. They agreed that the other guy would pay Miguel back for the CD player.
“The mediation fixed the conflict,” said Miguel. “The guy and I kept the friendship going.” Plus, Miguel said, “The mediation helped me see that I had an anger problem, and that I needed some type of control.”
Some schools also have mediation programs to help teenagers settle beefs with each other. Martin Luther King Jr. HS, in Manhattan, is one of five New York City schools with a program called Project SMART (School Mediators’ Alternative Resolution Team), run by the victim assistance and anti-violence organization Safe Horizon.
From Dirty Looks to Getting Jumped
Project SMART, which has been at Martin Luther King HS for 13 years, trains students to be intermediates who can help resolve conflicts between students. According to Frank DiSpigno, the assistant director of mediation programs for the youth division at Safe Horizon, conflicts can range from small situations like a dirty look in the hallway to getting jumped outside of school at dismissal.
By getting to the conflicts before they get out of control, Project SMART keeps students from doing things that would get them suspended. According to DiSpigno, 97% of the cases brought to the program have been resolved.
Sueann Bowen, 16, is in her third year as a Project SMART peer mediator at Martin Luther King HS. Her job is to listen to each side of the story, come up with a fair solution, and, of course, keep everything confidential. That means she can’t discuss the cases she mediates with anyone.
‘I Put Myself in Both Persons’ Shoes’
“I decided to work as an intermediate because I love to help people,” said Sueann. “I love to listen to other people’s problems.”
Students who want to be intermediates go through a three-day training, where they learn listening skills and proper language. According to Sueann, “an intermediate has to sit straight, speak properly, and be neutral.”
This last one is the most important requirement. An intermediate can’t take one side or the other. “There’ve been many times when I wanted to say, ‘You are wrong,’ or ‘You are right,’ but I controlled myself,” said Sueann. “I just put myself in both persons’ shoes and keep it to myself.”
During a mediation, people can’t curse. They all have to listen when a person speaks and one person speaks at a time. While others talk, the mediator has to take notes of everything that is said and done.
Parents Rarely Need to Be Called
While the conflicts that Sueann helps resolve are not necessarily violent, “there have been situations where we had to call parents because students start to be violent with each other during the mediation,” she said. “We call parents when we feel that the problems have gotten out of our hands, but it rarely happens.”
Most of the time, said Sueann, they find a solution. “Either the opponents come up with them or I do. I see when it works because I keep on having meetings with them and find out if my solution really helps or we keep on having mediations until we have the right solution,” she said.
When I asked her if her job was stressful, she grinned. “It’s actually fun because people believe in me and they trust me,” she said. “I get to meet people and the feeling is great.” She said people have stopped her in the hallway to thank her for mediating their conflicts.
Learning to Solve a Situation
Sueann said she doesn’t understand why other schools don’t use conflict resolution programs. “Other schools use suspension as a punishment, but that doesn’t make sense,” she said. After all, getting suspended just makes students miss school, and is that really a punishment?
Conflict resolution programs help people communicate with one another and come up with a workable agreement for both sides of the conflict. It’s not about being punished for doing something wrong, but learning how to solve a troublesome situation.
As Miguel said about his experience with a conflict resolution program, “It helps to solve problems without using any physical violence.”
We Can Work It Out
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.