I used to be an avid reader of teen magazines. From when I was 10 until I was 13, I devoured Seventeen and YM every month. I was just becoming a teenager and I wanted to know how I was supposed to act and what I was supposed to do. The magazines had everything I was interested in (or thought I was interested in)-information on clothes, makeup, and boys.
The magazines told me that to be normal and happy I had to look good and have a boyfriend. But I wasn’t as pretty or thin as the models. I wasn’t dating yet either. Every time I read another article on how to deal with your boyfriend, I would feel as if there were something wrong with me. The feeling that I didn’t quite measure up stayed with me for years.
Eventually, I matured and realized that I was perfectly normal and that the magazines were giving me a wrong message. Looking back, I’m glad that I didn’t start dating then. I realize now that if I was so easily influenced by some dumb magazines, I probably wasn’t ready.
Boys, Boys, Boys
Teen magazines haven’t changed since then. The August issue of YM had an article on how to get guys to commit; an article on guys’ biggest-ever dating disasters; and two girls’ opinions on whether they would date a guy that their best friend had a crush on.
In the August issue of Seventeen there was a fashion spread on sweaters featuring a girl who is distressed because her boyfriend is going away to college. In the August Sassy, I found an article called “Chronic Long Distance Boyfriend Distress.” What I didn’t find was even one article on girls who don’t have boyfriends and don’t want them.
As if that weren’t enough, two of these magazines devoted entire issues to guys. Seventeen’s July “Boy Crazed” issue had more than 10 articles and photospreads about guys. There was a quiz to help you rate your boyfriend; a photospread that followed two boycrazy girls’ on their hunt for Mr. Right; and an article about the winners of Seventeen’s “Best Boyfriend Contest,” featuring quotes from their lucky girlfriends and pictures of the happy couples.
YM’s April “Major Guy Issue” had about the same number of articles and photospreads on the subject, including: “How to Survive the First 60 Days of a Relationship,” and a quiz to help you figure out whether your relationship is healthy or harmful.
Just For Fun?
By printing so many articles on how to relate to guys, these magazines are giving teenage girls the impression that dating should be a major part of their lives. If it’s not, there must be something wrong with them.
Elizabeth Granfort, the Beauty/Fitness Director of YM, says that’s not true. Granfort feels that YM’s message to readers on dating is to “do it for fun.” Granfort said her magazine shows “two sides” to relationships with boys: “how to get them” and “how to get rid of them.” She said “all” her readers are interested in “how to get” boyfriends. What Granfort doesn’t seem to understand is that a lot of us don’t care.
Roberta Anne Myers, articles editor at Seventeen, says that in her magazine, “there’s something for everyone.” Where are the articles on resisting peer pressure to date? On how to have a successful friendship? Not in Seventeen or YM!
Instead, these magazines give us articles like “100 Guys Talk-What 100 Guys had to Say about Love, Sex, Dating and You” (April YM); “Real Back to School Clothes…Rated by Real Guys” (August YM); “Why Guys Love Long Hair” (July Seventeen); and monthly columns like “Guy Talk” in Seventeen and “What He Said” in Sassy. In short, guys’ opinions on everything- especially clothes and dating.
Articles like these tell us that what guys want is very important and that we should keep their likes and dislikes in mind when we decide what clothes to buy, how to wear our hair, and how to act. Girls’ opinions, on the other hand, are limited to letters and reader polls. Why don’t they have girls rate outfits?
“A magazine isn’t going to convince you to date,” YM’s Granfort says. I disagree. A magazine can inflict an enormous amount of pressure on teenage girls-especially younger teens who don’t really know what they want. Younger girls view teen magazines as handbooks on how to be a teenager. I know I did. Teen magazines can influence how girls act as much as they influence how we look. They shouldn’t, but they do.
Wanna Life?: Get a Boyfriend!
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.