Violent Times, Violent Movies

Over the last year or so, a lot of films have come out that deal with the impact of gangs, drugs, and violence on city youth. The news media has criticized some of these movies-particularly New Jack City and Juice-for encouraging real-life violence. For example, an editorial in the New York Times stated that “films like Juice are clearly packaged to appeal to the most violent segments of the audience.”
I disagree. Movies such as Juice attempt to realistically portray the problems faced by city youth. They don’t promote violence. These movies show the downside of using or dealing drugs and joining gangs, and show that there are alternatives.
Juice is about four teenage guys who do everything together. They consider themselves a crew, not a gang. In the beginning all they do is cut school, hang out, and shoplift. They aren’t violent. They don’t jump other kids and they don’t carry guns. But anger, peer pressure, and one crew member’s obsession with “juice” push them further.
First, they decide to rob a store-because they want money and because they want to teach the store owner a lesson for always chasing them away from his place with a gun. One of the guys, GQ, doesn’t want to go through with it but he’s pressured by his friends.
Friend Against Friend
To pull off the robbery, the guys decide they need a gun because they know the store owner has one. They don’t plan on shooting the man, but Bishop (the kid obsessed with juice) ends up killing him anyway. After they all get away from the scene of the crime, Rahim, the leader of the crew, tries to take the gun away from Bishop. Instead of giving it up, Bishop kills him.
Watching the movie, you don’t admire Bishop. He is like the villain-the kid on the wrong track. The guy that the audience cheers for is GQ, the one that didn’t want to get involved in the robbery in the first place.
What sets GQ apart from the other crew members, especially Bishop, is that he has a goal in life-he wants to be a DJ. It’s not what his mother really wants for him, but it’s an honest goal. GQ doesn’t want the type of respect that one gets by having a bad reputation on the streets. He wants the type of respect that one gets for working hard at being the best in something.
Bishop is another story. The movie shows how, because of his insatiable desire for power, nothing else is important to him-not even the lives of his friends. An advertising poster for Juice read: “Juice. Power. Respect. How far will you go to get it?” Through Bishop, the movie shows the consequences of going too far.
New Jack City is another movie that deals directly with drugs, gangs, and violence. It’s about a family of drug dealers who invent the “perfect drug” and use it to monopolize the local drug trade. They murder their way to the top and continue murdering to stay on top. Eventually they begin to betray and kill each other.
In the beginning of the film, the head of the family, Nino Brown, frequently asks, “Am I my brother’s keeper?” and all the members of his drug organization would answer in unison: “Yes, I am.” We find out that these are just words later in the movie, when Brown’s brother unknowingly hires an undercover cop who ends up destroying the organization.
Livin’ Large. . .For a While
The brother comes to apologize to Nino,who begins to cry but doesn’t hesitate to take out his gun. The brother asks, “Am I my brother’s keeper?” Brown thinks for a while, says, “Yes, I am,” and shoots his brother. At the end of the film Nino Brown gets a taste of his own medicine when he is killed by a citizen determined to bring him to justice.
New Jack City clearly illustrates that drug dealing and drug abuse both lead to undesirable and destructive ends. Nino Brown had the money, the cars, and the girls, but he lost it all. The movie shows that any gain achieved through dealing is merely temporary.
While addressing the drug dealing, the movie also shows you the intensity of drug addiction. A drug dealer who is less successful than Nino Brown becomes addicted to his product and, as a result, loses everything. He goes into rehab to try to kick his habit.
After months of struggling to set himself straight, it only takes the mere sight of drugs to rekindle his addiction. The message of this segment of the movie is: don’t try drugs at all because prevention is far better than the cure.
It’s true that both these movies depict violent acts. Unfortunately, violence is a problem in our society; we can’t pretend it doesn’t exist. And these films don’t just show the violence, they show the consequences of violent behavior. This makes for an effective anti-violence, anti-drug message.
The Real Deal
If the theaters were showing a “Read my lips, don’t do drugs,” message by George Bush, then the youth of America would not pay $7.50, or any price at all, to go see it. The message wouldn’t be taken seriously if it were coming from a person who didn’t really know how it is.
It is because these movies are dramatic, entertaining, and realistic that the audience will sit there for over an hour and watch them. Watching these films, you might even say to yourself, “These people [the filmmakers] really know what the deal is.”
The basic message conveyed by Juice and New Jack City is similar to the one contained in lectures we get from our parents, the public service commercials we see on television, and the lessons we get in health class. Same message, different packaging. And the difference in the packaging will make young people more likely to listen and learn.

SIDEBAR: We All Lose
At the opening of Juice in lower Manhattan in January, a 16-year-old was stabbed by another youth in a fight over a woman. When New Jack City opened in Los Angeles last year, hundreds of youths went on a rampage and ransacked 21 businesses. In other parts of the country, fights broke out at theatres showing the movie. Similar incidents occurred at theatres showing Boyz N’ the Hood when it first opened. These three movies made by Black filmmakers and dealing with Black issues got a bad rap because they were dogged by violent incidents. Even though these films conveyed a strong anti-gang, anti-drug message, the news media blamed them for inciting the acts of violence that took place in and around the theatres. Now, whenever a new movie about the problems facing Black youth comes out, a lot of people worry that fights and shoot-outs will follow. When Juice was about to open, many theatre owners, anticipating problems, felt they couldn’t show the movie without increasing security. Some of them said they would rather not show the movie at all because they didn’t want to spend the extra money.
Violence Costs
Eventually, the studio that released the movie agreed to pay the price of additional security out of fear that the movie wouldn’t get shown and all the money that had been invested in it would be lost. Now I don’t think any of these movies “incite” violence. What usually happens is that, on the nights that these movies open, there are a lot of people who go to see them. There are long lines of people waiting to get inside. A lot of these people are on edge because they get sick of waiting. As a result, fights break out for the simplest reasons, like if somebody thinks you cut in front of him. Sometimes the theatre oversells tickets and people who have been waiting on line for over an hour find out that they aren’t going to be able to get in even though they’ve already paid for tickets. These people, who haven’t even seen the movie, are often the ones who end up getting violent but later, on the news, you hear that it was the movie that caused the problem. The other thing that happens is guys from opposing gangs will end up at the theatre because everyone wants to see the movie the first night. These guys would get into a fight anywhere they ran into each other-it just happens to take place at the theatre.
No More Black Films?
Whether it is the movies that are causing the violence or not, these incidents are going to make it harder for Black filmmakers. In a time when Blacks are coming out with more movies and are trying to take their share of Hollywood, these incidents may undercut what has already been accomplished. If the violence continues, more and more theatre owners may decide to stop showing movies by Black filmmakers, especially if the films deal with violence. People may get afraid to go see the movies because they’re worried about getting caught in the crossfire. That would mean that the studios would no longer want to invest any money in Black films because they’re not going to be able to make a profit. These violent incidents, even if they’re not really caused by the movies, tarnish the image of Black filmmakers and make it more difficult for them to make their films. So when you go to the movies, go to watch, not to fight. Stop the violence!

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.