Unforgettable? Or Unwatchable?: Let Me Be the Judge

“Nihao,” anime fans (that’s “hello” for those of you who don’t speak Japanese.) With the many new anime titles coming out you may find yourself perplexed, trying to figure out which ones you should be burning to see, and which ones you want to see burned.
Being the nice guy that I am, I have decided to help with this task by reviewing two recent video releases from the U.S. Manga Corps: Judge and Record of Lodoss War, Volume 1.
These tapes are very different in setting (Japan’s corporate world in Judge; a fantasy land in Lodoss). They also differ in quality-one is an anime legend in the making; the other a mediocre excuse for a movie.
Tetsuo, A-ko, Kenshiro, Ranma, Lupin, Gohan-to the ordinary reader these words must look like gibberish but the anime fan will recognize them as some of anime’s most interesting characters.
Fans will now have to expand that list to include the names of Parn, Deedlit, WoodChuck, Ghim, Etoh, and Slayn -some of the characters from Record of Lodoss War.
Gargoyles, a Dragon, and a Fine-Looking Witch
Lodoss War is an OVA series (like a TV series, except it’s made especially for video tape) consisting of 13 episodes about six heroes and their adventures on the Island of Lodoss. These heroes are an RPG (role playing game) blend of characters, with a dwarf, elf, thief, and wizard in their ranks and the action they provide on the first three Lodoss episodes is incomparable.
In the first episode, we see our heroes face and defeat a small group of gargoyles and one very, very big dragon. We also get introduced to Karla the Gray Witch, the villainess of the series (and the best-looking witch I’ve ever seen-no marks except for a beauty spot; nice black hair; elegant clothes; kind of tall, though). She’s the one who unleashes the dragon on our heroes.
Later on, it is hinted that Karla used to be good so I am dying to see the other tapes to find out what could have turned her from a good and FINE looking witch to a bad but still FINE-looking witch.
The Quest For Adventure
The rest of the tape’s episodes show how our heroes met and their motivations for the quest they’re on (e.g. Ghim the Dwarf is looking for a friend’s daughter, while Slayn the magician hopes to improve his magic). The most interesting motive is that of Parn, the warrior of the group.
Parn’s father was once a famous knight who had somehow been disgraced (how that happened will naturally not be revealed until a later tape). After finding out that he was going on a quest, Parn does a very unusual thing. He dons his father’s armor, packs up his things and sets his house on fire. Parn then walks off with his house burning in the background.
This scene stunned me because it showed me how serious Parn is. He sacrifices everything (true it was nothing much-just boring village life-but at least he had a roof over his head) for adventure and a chance to become a knight.
After watching this scene, along with the many other action-packed moments (not to mention the catchy songs) in Lodoss War, you can be sure that I want to see the other episodes. If they are as good as the first tape, Akira and Lupin are going to have to make space on my shelf for a new classic.
Unfortunately, folks, we now must move from classic anime to a classic example of a failure, namely the movie Judge.
Don’t Believe the Hype
When I read the description of Judge on the video box I got excited. It described Judge as a movie with “cataclysmic battles” and “the most terrifying courtroom case ever presented.” Well somebody needs to sue U.S. Manga Corps for false advertising cause Judge never lives up to the hype.
The “cataclysmic” battle promised on the video box is ^%$#@*&#. I think I would’ve gotten more excitement out of watching replacement baseball than watching the Judge and Defense (one of the villains, a wizard who protects criminals) fight it out with their Demons of Hell. The Judge gets the crap beat out of him until he is saved by one of his Demons, a bird who fires knife-sharp feathers.
As for the animation, while not the worst (Marvel Action Hour wins that title), it’s nothing special. It’s standard anime style (freeze frames, good art, identifiable eyes) which while good is not enough to save this movie.
Judge could have been decent if it had been better thought out. The idea of someone avenging the murderers of the dead is unique, but if you don’t hook an idea up with good dialogue (unlike the god awful exchange between the Judge and Defense at the end of the film) and believable situations it won’t work.
Four Good Scenes
However Judge does have its moments (four-I counted them) such as the scene when the Judge kills his first victim-a man who embezzles money from his company, frames his girlfriend for the crime, kills her and then plans to escape to the U.S.
Unfortunately for this sleaze, Judge decides to send him on a “detour,” using a move he obviously copied from Alfred Hitchcock’s The Birds. Instead of the U.S., the bad guy ends up in hell. Judge arranges to have the villain’s tongue pierced with a nail and, in the movie’s best moment, uses his “Sheet Demon” to cause the bad guy to jump off a cliff to his death. He lands on an American flag (the “Sheet Demon” in a new form) at which point the Judge remarks, “You always wanted to be embraced by America” (ouch).
One Is Tasty; the Other, Tasteless
Despite this scene, Judge’s predictable action and disappointing ending (the way Judge finally gets his last victim is dumb), makes this a movie only to be seen when an immediate dosage of anime is needed (like after watching Wild C.A.T.S.). All in all, a forgettable film.
There you have it, folks, the two extreme ends of the anime spectrum in terms of quality-one as tasty as a Sunday roast (Lodoss) and the other more comparable to Spam (Judge). Both movies are subtitled (Lodoss is also available dubbed) and are available from your video store or U.S. Manga Corps.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.