We live in a multi-cultural society. For that reason, I think, a school designed for Blacks with a basically African-American curriculum and largely Black staff would not give its students a realistic view of the world.
The students who would attend the proposed Ujamaa Institute would not be able to adjust later on. They wouldn’t have learned that the world consists of many different cultures that must constantly interact with one another.
Supporters of the plan say that Black male students don’t have enough positive Black role models. I agree. But Blacks do not necessarily have to have Black role models. We choose role models because of their achievements, not their skin color. I am Latina but I don’t have only Latino role models. A role model is someone you can admire and respect regardless of their race.
Each Group Might Demand It’s Own School
The creators of this school say it is not exclusively for Black males. But that’s how the curriculum is designed. They are not planning to teach Latino students about their history. If their argument is that students need to learn about their own history and culture, then Latinos would need their own school too. And every other racial group would have the right to demand schools that meet their own needs.
The Ujamaa Institute would also “welcome” females, but it does not address the social problems Black and Latino females suffer from. What about their lack of self-esteem? What about the high rate of teenage pregnancy?
Even if the school does work, it will only help the few students who get in. What about the thousands that are not attending this school? Or is the next step segregating the schools more and more until all schools are designed for a specific sex and race?
Yes, the current school curriculum needs to be changed to include the history of other races besides White Europeans. We all need to learn about each other’s races and our own. In seven years I’ve heard my country, the Dominican Republic, mentioned about twice by history teachers.
The money that would be used for the Ujamaa Institute would be put to better use improving existing schools, offering more history courses, and more counseling overall.
This proposed school would not help the majority of students out there, and if it were taken as an example would deprive many students of a well-rounded, racially mixed education.
Ujamaa Promotes Segregation
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.