TV Debate: Should Students Be Tested for Drugs?

Imagine walking down a hospital hallway wearing only a robe and your underwear, while all eyes are fixed upon you. This can’t happen in America, right?
Wrong.
This is exactly what 25 students at St. Sabeani, a parochial junior high school in Chicago, go through four times a year. No, these youngsters are not the carriers of a deadly disease-they are being tested for drugs, at random.
“The Jane Wallace Show,” a nationally syndicated talk show aired on the Lifetime cable network, addressed this controversial issue in an episode entitled “Drug Testing in the Schools: Making the Grade.” The show was taped Jan. 25 and was shown on Feb. 12. I attended the taping with students from my old school, I.S. 145 in Queens.
The segment featured a parent and student from St. Sabeani, as well as a representative of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU). Ken Shultz, athletics director at Flossmoor HS, also in Chicago, and Amanda Levenberg, 18, student body president at Flossmoor, also participated in the discussion.
Flossmoor has launched a random drug testing program aimed at its athletes since federal law prohibits testing of the entire student body in public schools. St. Sabeani, however, a private school under no restrictions and with the approval of many parents, has established a testing policy involving a pool of 152 students selected quarterly from all of its attendants.
From this group, 25 are chosen at random and given a date on which they have to provide a urine sample at a local hospital, according to Sheila Grace, a parent and a member of the school board at St. Sabeani, who appeared on the show.
What Comes First-Society or Personal Rights?
We are faced with a moral dilemma in this situation: what comes first-the welfare of society as a whole or an individual’s rights?
“There’s a very fine line between protecting one’s rights and invading them,” declared Shultz, who said that random drug testing is justified since it helps all of society. Flossmoor tests its athletes for the presence of alcohol, marijuana, cocaine, steroids, and other drugs, according to Shultz.
Pointing out that if a student tests positive, no reference is made on his record and parents are called to school to initiate an individual counseling program, Grace strongly supported the program at St. Sabeani. She also stressed that these tests are accepted by the students and parents of the school “who want to show the world that they are drug-free.”
The main argument against these programs, presented by Loren Siegel of the ACLU, was that they are an invasion of a person’s privacy. “It violates one of your most basic rights,” she charged, adding that a student being tested is regarded as “guilty without being proven so.”
Voicing similar opposition, Levenberg said: “I have nothing to hide but I don’t want to give up my privacy.” She was also troubled by the fact that students are under suspicion during testing even if they do not use drugs.
Sherman Grace, 13, an eighth grader at St. Sabeani, however, does not perceive drug testing as an invasion of his privacy. He has already been tested and he did not mind, as he said very simply: “I have nothing to hide.”
Will Testing Stop Abuse?
Another, perhaps even more important issue, was then raised: what happens when a student tests positive?
Both schools retest the individual since a prescription drug could have determined the outcome of the test-they are anything but perfect. If the result is positive again, then a comprehensive drug counseling program is set into play, involving the entire family.
The effectiveness of this counseling was also questioned, as Adam Bart, a drug counselor from the Dynamite Youth Center in Brooklyn, and Michelle Cargus, 17, a recovered drug addict, joined the panel.
Cargus, who began using drugs at 11, described her experiences throughout the years and stressed that random drug testing would not have helped her. “I would have still found a way to get high,” she said.
Although she lived in a stable social environment, neither her family nor her teacher detected her addiction until she was 15-after two overdoses and a minor heart attack.
This stirred a heated debate, as Cargus insisted that testing would not have made a difference while the officials of both schools argued that she would have been referred to professional counseling long before her addiction was finally discovered, had she been tested.
“If the parents have their heads in the sand, we will pull them out,” said Grace.
One audience member, also a former drug addict, admitted that random drug testing might have helped him solve his problem earlier.
Student Reactions
Students from Joseph Pulitzer I.S. 145 in Jackson Heights, Queens, who were interviewed after the show, had mixed feelings about the issue. Surprisingly, many of them supported drug testing in the schools and did not feel it was an invasion of their privacy. Most had an “I have nothing to hide” attitude.
Typical of their remarks were those of sixth grader Kim Kwang, 12, who said: “We should have drug testing because it gives addicts an opportunity to get help.”
Tamar Kushman, 11, another sixth grader, suggested a different approach, as she felt that the money spent on these tests could be better utilized in the classroom-to make all students aware of the dangers of drugs.
Citing the margin of error in testing, Jean Laurenceau, 12, a seventh grader, concluded that such testing would be ineffective.
The issue also drew feedback from I.S. 145 principal Perry Sandler, who said that he would feel uncomfortable if he had to test whole groups of students. “I would, however, like to see legislation that would allow us to test a [single] child whom we suspect is a drug abuser,” he said.
Jane Wallace told New Youth Connections that she was unsure about the effectiveness of random drug testing.
“You can figure out a way to cheat it,” she observed. She does, however, encourage testing athletes and she has some confidence in the counseling programs offered to abusers by the Chicago schools.
All of this leaves us with a moral dilemma, as we ask ourselves: should we give up the opportunity to save hundreds of lives in order to not threaten one of our most basic rights?
In order to answer, we must first look deep within ourselves and decide how much we are willing to risk. We should then look at our society-torn by a deadly plague called drugs-and perhaps re-examine our decision.
The Jane Wallace Show invites schools to be in the audience during taping. Free transportation is provided. Call Lifetime Television at 718-706-3575.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.