“Tracking is when students are placed in courses based on assumptions about their sex, race, or language proficiency,” said Lisa Syron of the Center for Public Advocacy Research.
It is caused by people in the school system who are “blatantly sexist or racist,” Syron continued, and it happens primarily to “young women of color, minority students, and students who are not fluent in English.”
Mark Weiss, principal of Bronx Regional High School, defined tracking this way: “It’s usually not a deep judgment about the real difference among students. It’s based on race or ethnic background or behavior, rather than academic achievement or ability.”
And according to a high school teacher who is also a parent: “Tracking is a sin. It cheats, deceives, and promotes the kind of laziness in a child that we need to prevent.”
Segregation By Race, Gender, and Class
Tracking-or the segregation of students by academic ability within a school according to race, gender or economic class-can be one of the reasons why only 133 Blacks and Hispanics received science doctorates nationwide in 1987. In some advanced science classes in the public high schools, Whites outnumber Blacks 12 to 1, in a system where only 20% of the students are White.
Tracking can start from the first day a student steps foot into school.
“We know that some school systems test kindergarten children for admission to first grade,” said Weiss.
Most students who are tracked don’t know it and the few who do know often don’t care.
Robert [not his real name] is an assistant principal at a public high school in Manhattan. In an interview, Robert agreed to speak about tracking in his school, which has a student body that is 90% Black, Hispanic, and Asian, but only if his real name was not used.
According to Robert, “Tracking is the placement of minorities and females in disproportionate highs in low ability groups and special education. The tracking system prevents Blacks and Hispanics from getting into good colleges, and slows them down intellectually as well.
The Poor Pitted Against the Middle Class
“If you went into a classroom in my school,” he continued, “you would see poor Blacks in non-Regents classes, middle class Blacks and Whites in Regents classes. Blacks are pitted against Blacks. The middle class kid gets a better chance than the poor kid.”
The student who is tracked may be given math applications, consumer math, or remedial math in place of an algebra class or a geometry class, which are required Regents classes. This same student may be given earth science or life science in place of biology or chemistry.
Robert said that “recommendations made by a teacher make it easier to do this.” In his school, he said “It is an unspoken word that says a Black not be placed in an advanced science class.”
Robert went on to say that a “coded language” is used by teachers to refer to Black students in recommendations for advanced and honors classes, as well as special programs.
He cited “language such as’this kid comes from a certain district or part of the city’ and the usage of the words `them’ and’they.'”
Myth of Tracking
According to Syron, “Tracks dictate the sequence of courses to be taken not only within the subject area, such as math, but in all of the different subject areas required for the diploma.”
According to a study of tracking by Jeannie Oakes, “Rather than help students to feel more comfortable about themselves, the tracking process seems to foster lowered self-esteem among these teenagers.”
In her study she found that the popular belief that students function better when grouped with those of the same ability is a myth. When classes have students of mixed skills, Oakes writes, the students who are not so bright tend to do better, and the high achieving students do just as well as they did when they were in the tracked classes.
It was easy for those students who are aware of being tracked to express their sentiments.
Lisa, a student at Canarsie HS, said, “It’s not fair that I have to take a non-Regents math class because I couldn’t pass the Regents.”
Temi, a student at Bronx Science, said that “Science and math are taught to those who have the knack, and those who don’t aren’t blessed with knowledge.”
Some students blame guidance counselors.
“Guidance counselors should inform you. They are not there to just tell you,’You need to go to summer school,’ but to help you not to have to!” said Bilal Al-Amin, a Bronx Science senior.
This was also the opinion of Syron.
Not Enough Individualized Counseling
“There’s not enough individualized counseling,” she said. “Too many students only see guidance counselors when they’re in trouble, or two or three times a year.”
Syron added: “Students often aren’t aware until graduation of their math and science [requirements] because there is no individualized counseling.”
This means that many a student will spend four years wasting time. The student tracked for remedial or lower level courses can lose out not only in getting into college but also in the job market. Without basic biology and algebra, getting into a good school or finding a job can be very hard. Most entry level jobs in business demand math skills.
Tracking is a means of having Blacks, Hispanics and women run the slow pace.
Weiss thinks that “we’re all susceptible to some kind of tracking, and we have to be conscious of it.” He went on to say that “It makes the teacher’s standards for the children go down.”
Robert, who said he has been denied a principal’s position because of his opposition to tracking, says that “Tracking is institutionalized. It is part of the bureaucracy and will take several generations to end. Tracking is also built into the testing system.”
He said the problem is made worse by the small numbers of Black and Hispanic teachers and administrators in the school system.
Tracking is a serious problem that needs to be addressed-and soon. Lack of challenge and low teacher expectations put many students at risk. It is time to teach all our youth-no matter what sex they are, or how light or dark.
Tracking: Blatant Sexism and Racism in the Schools
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.