I’m sitting in a corner of a mostly gay cafe in the Village when I notice a cute guy sitting across from me. Hoping that he’s glancing at me too, I look again. Our eyes meet, but I quickly turn away. I’m feeling nervous, so my stomach tightens. Still, I take a chance and look back.
He’s still looking! Could he be interested? Taking his gaze as a sign, I walk over to sit next to him and sayâ well, that’s when I get stuck. It doesn’t matter, though, because in reality, I’m still sitting in my chair, too shy to approach my admirer.
I’ve had a few experiences like that, unsure of myself and too afraid of rejection to make the first move. There are gay spots like the West Village pier where some guys will go up to people and ask them out immediately. Sometimes I wish I had the guts to do that.
Afraid of Rejection
Some of my insecurities hinder my ability to approach guys. Throughout my life, there have been people who said they would be there for me but then left. So it’s hard for me to trust and reach out to people that I already know, much less strangers.
I’m also insecure about my body image and feel unattractive most of the time. I feel that if I get rejected by someone I approach, my looks would be the reason.
When I see someone I’m attracted to and I’m dealing with my anxieties, a series of thoughts rush through my head.
I ask myself: “What happens if he says yes? Will we hit it off as friends? If we started dating and it gets serious, will it last? Is he ready for an actual relationship, to deal with all that comes with it?”
After these initial questions, I begin to wonder if he’s feeling and thinking the same things I am, especially since some gay guys haven’t come to terms with their sexuality.
Gay Drama
I imagine drama, having to deal with the possibility of hiding our relationship from others, especially his parents. Or what if he’s just sexually experimenting with men but is really straight? Then I would be left with the emotional aftermath of our break-up.
Even though some gays have a lot of issues, they seem to have no problem “hooking up.” Still, according to what my friends say and from what I overhear at cafes and parties, a lot of these guys aren’t interested in each other’s feelings or trying to get to know each other. Instead, the hook-ups are mainly for fun, for a one-night stand.
I don’t have a problem with others having casual sex, but I’m not looking for that. I hope to find a guy who’s caring and who would stand by me through tough times.
I want someone who wants to become close friends before anything serious begins, so that when there are hard times we would still have a bond that’ll be hard to break.
The Center’s My Best Bet
Where would I find a guy like that? For now, I think my best bet is a place like the Lesbian & Gay Community Center, where I’ve made friends.
I feel more comfortable striking up conversations there with people I don’t know because the Center has more of a group environment, with many familiar faces, and feels safer.
Even though I haven’t met anyone there who I’m interested in dating, when a chance comes along, I think I’d be more likely to try asking someone out at the Center than trying to hook up in a cafe or on the pier.
Still, I have a ways to go overcoming my anxieties about asking guys out. I have to work on building my confidence about how I look and what I can offer a guy. I’m also trying to be more carefree and not overanalyze situations.
I’ve talked about my feelings with my friends and they all say that I worry too much. They tell me that I should just enjoy the thrill of seeing a guy I’m attracted to and that there’s little to fear with that. If I do get rejected when I ask someone out, it’s simply his loss.
Of course, that’s easy to say and much harder to experience. Though being the aggressor is a fun idea, I hope that other guys will find the courage to ask me out. That takes some pressure off me and shows that they’re interested enough in meeting me to take a risk. Then again, maybe they’re as anxious as I am.
SIDEBAR: My First (and Only) Date
The idea of going on dates frightens me, especially since I’ve only had one date so far and it was a set-up. My best friend Effy met a guy named Mike online, but wanted to hook me up with him since he thought we had more in common. The plan was that Effy and I would meet Mike together and then Effy would leave, pretending to have to go home to eat dinner. I was a bit nervous about the whole idea, especially since we were setting this guy up, but I agreed to the plan because I thought it would be fun. I hoped Mike and I would have lots to talk about and crack jokes. I also thought I could get free food.
Meeting at Starbucks
We all met at Starbucks. When I first saw Mike through the window, I was excited. He looked like he could have been in a Gap commercial; he was skinny and had short, blow-dried brown hair, with light brown skin and hazel eyes. Effy and I introduced ourselves and then ordered a few iced Frappuccinos. But despite my initial excitement, my anxieties began to creep in. I was feeling the pressure of having to strike up a conversation on what was going to be a date, which is different from just talking to a friend. So when Effy left Starbucks, I thought, “No, don’t leave me!” I was left with the challenge of getting to know Mike. We talked a lot about our studies and future plans. I found out he was a student at a university and wanted to eventually become a surgeon. But in between our chats were silent moments that made me feel strange because I wasn’t sure what to say next. Despite the awkward moments, I was becoming more comfortable with him and thought the date was going well, until we went to an Italian restaurant. Even though eating is the best part of a first date for some, I was nervous that I might get a severe case of the klutz, and drop food onto my lap, and choke on my water and spray it all over him. Plus, I was worried about how I looked, so I was glad that the restaurant was candlelit because that brings depth and warmth to people’s faces and skin. As I was figuring out what to order, Mike told me about his travels around the world with his parents, especially his trip to Italy. Since I didn’t consider myself as cultured as he was, I tried acting more “sexy” by looking deeply into his eyes when he talked to me.
Trying Too Hard
I also did this to seem sure of myself and my convictions when I was speaking. I hoped that I sounded interesting to him, that he would find me attractive; but because I was trying too hard to come across a certain way, I had trouble with my words. As our dinner progressed, there weren’t any sparks, but at least it wasn’t like a scene from the movies where I wanted to splash a glass of water into his face. Plus, he paid for my meal! Afterwards, there was this slightly uncomfortable feeling between us when we were walking around, as if we were expecting each other to hold hands or kiss. But nothing happened. (I don’t kiss on the first date.) We got on the subway and went home.
Not Ready for Relationship
I liked him though, and knew that I wouldn’t mind getting to know him and seeing where our dating could lead. But a day or two after the date, Mike gave me a call and said he wasn’t ready for a relationship because he was too busy with school. He said that we could still be friends and hang out some time, but I knew that wasn’t going to happen because it sounded like a line. Even though I was disappointed that my first and only date wasn’t a love connection, it’s given me insight into how the next one may be and what to expect. Now I know that it’s harder than I thought to talk and joke around with a stranger. I also realize that I prefer to go on a date that’s not a set-up because I suspect that I would feel more comfortable knowing the person as a friend before we hang out romantically.
