After countless superficial friendships and years of just trying to fit in, I finally found a friend who I could confide in, relate to and just basically be myself with.
There was only one problem -he was in love with me. And that was something neither of us knew how to deal with.
My friend was a loner. He spent most of his lunch time reading science fiction novels or watching other people.
He seemed shy, and there was a darkness about him that almost kept me from talking to him.
But it only took one conversation for me to realize that, in fact, he was kind, and we had a lot in common.
I Confided In Him
We would discuss how two-faced some girl was or how fake some guy was, and laugh until tears streamed from our eyes.
Whenever one of us was feeling depressed, we would buy a quart of Midnight Chocolate Chip ice cream and cheer each other up. I had never felt so free-spirited in my life.
I began to confide in him, and he saw a side of me I was normally afraid to show.
My other friends and I would greet each other with hard pounds on the back and eye each other as if we were challenging each other to a fight.
Whenever we talked, we would yell so the entire block could hear us, throw our arms in the air, and use terms that weren’t even remotely close to the words in Webster’s Dictionary.
But with him, I didn’t have anything to prove.
He Told Me He Loved Me
Then, during the second year of our friendship, I was sent to live with my father in another state.
We called each other often and he would write me long letters telling me how much our friendship meant to him.
One time he even told me he loved me.
Of course I took it as he loved me like a brother, even though I always thought it was “gay” to tell another guy you loved him.
When I came back to New York, we started spending a lot more time with each other. We even spent entire weekends together.
One night, for some strange reason, he decided we should sleep in the same bed instead of him sleeping on the floor as usual.
Nothing happened between us. I thought this was odd. But I’d known him for three years. This was my best friend. There was no way that he could be gay!
I guess I was kind of in denial. Still, there were times when I did wonder if he was gay.
‘Real Men’ Lusted After Women
Usually when he got upset, he would sway his hands, roll his eyes and say things like, “Uh-uh, oh no she didn’t!” in an effeminate tone.
But the thought of him being gay frightened me, so I just put it out of my mind.
At the time, I thought the signs of a gay male were lots of gaudy jewelry, a feminine voice and a shirt tied in a knot above the belly button. (OK, so maybe I was a little naive.)
I never had any gay friends and, to my knowledge, no one in my family was gay. I never thought about how I felt toward homosexuals because I didn’t have to.
All I remember hearing when I was growing up was that being gay was “nasty.” It just wasn’t normal to me.
All the images of “real men” I’d ever seen were of guys who never cried, who drank beer, ate beef and absolutely lusted after women. And I guess that’s the way I thought it was supposed to be.
Would I Still Hug Him?
But if my friend was gay, would I still hug him or play fight with him? Would I even share the same spoon with him again?
As the months passed, I started to notice that he would get jealous when I hung out with my other friends.
And whenever I became involved with a girl, he would always point out her flaws.
I got annoyed with the way he was acting. Gradually, I stopped hanging out with him so much. I didn’t call him or stay at his house as often.
People who knew we hung out would ask me if he was gay. I would always deny it even though I wondered the same thing.
I was afraid that if people saw us together they would think I was gay, too.
I started to joke around with my friends, saying, “If one of my boys ever told me he liked me, I’d knock him dead in his face!”
My friend knew I’d changed, and soon we grew angry with each other and argued a lot. Then we stopped talking altogether.
Then one day he approached me and handed me a letter.
He not only admitted he loved me as more than a friend, but he told me he wanted to have sex with me.
Beyond Pissed Off
When I heard that, I felt really angry, and sad. I felt like all those times he touched me he was trying to make a pass at me. And I felt like I could never look at him the same way again.
Maybe I was being selfish because I was only thinking about how I was feeling. I never thought about how frightened or humiliated or frustrated he might have been. But after that I just didn’t want to have anything to do with him anymore.
He wrote me another letter. This time he included a tape.
I was beyond pissed off, but I placed the tape in my walkman out of curiosity. My anger only increased when I discovered they were love songs!
Why couldn’t he understand that I didn’t share his feelings and that I never would?
I wanted to express myself but I was feeling too many emotions at once. I felt like the words were massive hands gripping my throat.
Acting Like a ‘Macho Man’
After that, I became embarrassed and paranoid.
I thought every guy was trying to hit on me and whenever I saw a gay couple I became tense.
When we passed each other, I would roll my eyes in the other direction and cringe my face. I went from not paying any mind to homosexuals to actually despising them.
I had to prove I was a “macho man.”
But it was more complex than that. This was my best friend-someone so close to me I considered him a brother. It was difficult for me to turn my back on him.
I Felt Lonely
Despite how angry and hurt I was, I felt lonely because I knew I had lost a true friend.
Months passed, but I couldn’t put it out of my mind. Over time, I began to think how I would feel if I were in his shoes, and some of my confusion became understanding.
He was still a person and I should have respected him for his courage to be honest with how he felt about me, even if I wished he would have respected me when I told him I didn’t share his feelings.
He Couldn’t Accept Himself
After that we did try to become friends again.
It took almost an entire year before we could sit down and talk things out. When we finally did, we sat at opposite ends of the room, our legs stretched out in front of us in a casual manner.
We both acted nonchalant, but my palms were moist with sweat and I could feel my heart pounding rapidly against my chest.
We would become friends again if he understood I didn’t have feelings for him and he didn’t try to force his feelings on me, I told him.
And for a while we did. But his feelings didn’t go away, and soon we found ourselves in the same situation all over again.
I think a big part of the problem was that he couldn’t really deal with the way he himself was feeling.
Even though his feelings kept coming back, he told me he definitely wasn’t gay. When I suggested he go talk to a counselor who worked with gay teens, he didn’t want to. And he tried to pretend that his feelings for me were no big deal.
I felt like he wasn’t honest with me. I didn’t want to give up on him, but I felt like he gave up on himself.
More Open-Minded, Still Uncomfortable
But, the truth is, he wasn’t the only person with feelings to work out.
I realize that even though I’ve tried hard to be friends with him, and I’ve become much more open-minded, my feelings toward gay people haven’t changed completely.
I’ve realized that discriminating against homosexuals is no different than discriminating against people because of their race, ethnicity, culture or gender.
But I’m still not completely comfortable around them.
There are moments when I find myself shifting uncomfortably when I come in contact with a man who I think might be gay.
My heart beats a little faster and my muscles tighten. I try to grit my teeth and just ignore it, but I can’t.
In my mind, I picture my friend telling me those things and staring at me with that look in his eyes.
Or there are times when I become angry and I curse out other males, calling them “f-king faggot.” It doesn’t matter if I think the guy is gay or not.
I don’t realize how strong my anger is until those moments when my eyes are narrow and my voice is rough.
Right now my friend and I have basically stopped being friends. Recently, I’ve called him several times. It was awkward, but we may get together to talk.
I wish things could have worked out between me and him. And I still think about rebuilding our friendship. But I also have my doubts.
I’m concerned about his feelings or my anger resurfacing, and about both interfering with our trust.
I don’t know if it’s possible, but maybe in the future we’ll both learn to handle our emotions better, and be able to become friends again.
Too Close for Comfort
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.