Thrifty Guide to Chelsea

New York is one of the most fashionable places in America. And if you want style for a bargain price, you’re in luck: The city is also home to tons of thrift shops. NYC staffers visited a few thrift stores in midtown Manhattan and created this guide for you. We rated each store’s quality of merchandise, selection, presentation, value, and atmosphere on a scale of one to five stars, with 5 being the most impressive and 1 being the least:
The Family Jewels Vintage Clothing
130 W. 23rd St. (between Sixth and Seventh Aves.)
212-633-6020
The minute we stepped in this store, we fell in love. When you enter, you are greeted with jazzy cabaret music, which goes with the theme of the store. It was like walking into the past; from the shiny bracelets, chains, and earrings to the classy and feminine clothes, all the merchandise looks like it came from a classic, old-fashioned Hollywood set. Even the people who work there look like they’re right out of the 1940s or ’50s. Everything looked so classy and colorful, we wanted to stay there and never leave.
Quality: 3.5 stars
Selection: 4.5 stars
Presentation: 5 stars
Value: 3 stars
Atmosphere: 5 stars
Goodwill Chelsea Store
103 West 25th St. (between Sixth and Seventh Aves.)
646-638-1725
This probably had the widest range of merchandise, including Easter stuff, old records, and even wedding gowns. All the clothes were in pretty good shape, and some actually looked new. Two racks of shoes included brands such as Steve Madden and Kenneth Cole. Also on the plus side: The store was bright and clean, and the staff was friendly.
Quality: 4 stars
Selection: 5 stars
Presentation: 5 stars
Value: 4 stars
Atmosphere: 3 stars
Angel Street Thrift Shop
118 W. 17th St. (near Sixth Ave.)
212-229-0546
When we entered Angel Street Thrift Shop, we felt a definite ’70’s vibe as a huge disco ball hangs from the ceiling. There are carts of music, shelves of books, and clothes for men and women. There is also old furniture for a low price, though it looked cheap and we were disturbed to see a filthy crib for sale. In general, we felt uncomfortable and unwelcome, with store clerks staring at us as if we were burglars trying to rob their store.
Quality: 3 stars
Selection: 3.5 stars
Presentation: 2.5 stars
Value: 2 stars
Atmosphere: 2 stars
Housing Works Thrift Shop
143 W. 17th St. (between Sixth and Seventh Aves.)
718-838-5050
The name speaks for itself; if you’re looking for furniture, this is the place to go. It also sells clothing for men and women, but it’s a dull place that seems more suited for elderly people (or young people who just dress old). We also felt unwelcome here. The sales clerks looked at us suspiciously when we asked to look around the store.
Quality: 3 stars
Selection: 3 stars
Presentation: 3.5 stars
Value: 3 stars
Atmosphere: 2 stars
Salvation Army
208 Eighth Ave. (between 20th and 21st Sts.)
212-929-5214
If you have a particular item you need to buy, you’re likely to find it right away here. The store is organized by color and category: baby clothes, children’s clothes, jeans, outerwear, dress pants, blouses, tank tops, etc. We found a range of affordable stuff, including a pea coat for $30 and dress pants under $20. The downside: The store smelled like sweat and some of the clothes were worn down, or a little dirty.
Quality: 3 stars
Selection: 3 stars
Presentation: 3 stars
Value: 4 stars
Atmosphere: 2 stars

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.