Thick vs. Thin: The War of the Weights

Everywhere you go, there is a battle between slim girls and thick girls.
The weapons are looks or words like: “Now, she knows she can’t fit into those jeans. I don’t even know why she wore them. The zipper can’t zip that size 12 waist when it’s a size five pants. What she needs to do is take her fat butt home ’cause she ain’t cute.”
Or: “Now look at this bony girl wearing that skirt, she looks like she’s about to break. Does the child ever eat? I know she don’t think she’s cute with those chicken legs. An anorexic looks better than her.”
Words like these sound familiar? Of course they do, because we’ve all heard them (maybe a little less severely) from friends, family and jealous people. Sometimes they even come straight out of our own mouths.
Everyone’s a Critic
Your appearance is the first thing people see when they look at you, and if they don’t like what they see, they will criticize you and sometimes even hate you without knowing you.
People are always talking about other people’s figures because they’re either jealous, ignorant or have low self-esteem, and it makes them feel better to talk about someone else.
You see it all the time on talk shows, where there’s a 300 pound lady in a leopard-print mini skirt saying she looks better than the skinny girl on the panel because she has more to strut.
And at family reunions there’s that one aunt who has about eight kids and has never gained a pound who brags about how you’re gonna wish you look like her when you get that old.
Girls vs. Girls
To tell you the truth, girls fight in these battles more than boys do. It seems like girls are always making bad comments about other girls’ figures when they know those comments would hurt them if the tables were turned.
I interviewed seven girls of all different shapes and asked them common questions about their weight, like: What comments do people say about them and what comments do they say about others?
Many girls beat around the bush and tried to give innocent answers such as, “I never say anything about fat people or skinny people, and people never say anything about me.”
If this were true, I would never have had to do the interviews and the whole teenage life of girls would be just splendid.
Since it’s not, you know many girls were frontin’- frontin’ probably because they were afraid and embarrassed to say how they really feel about themselves and others.
The Comments Hurt
My friend Aisha Green, a sophomore at Teaneck High School in New Jersey, said people say things that make her uncomfortable with her weight, and sometimes they hurt her feelings.
“Some people call me fat and it makes me feel bad. I’m OK with my weight, but I wish I was skinnier,” Aisha said.
I’m 16 years old, am 5feet 7inches and weigh 112 pounds. People are always commenting on my body. Whether it’s negative or positive, I have to hear it all.
I always used to pay more attention to the negative comments than the positive. I thought there was something really wrong with me, and I hated my figure.
They said things like: “You’re too skinny, you need to eat more.” And, “You’re too skinny to be showing your legs.”
My body was always on my mind. I felt like the whole world was looking at me and couldn’t wait to say something.
I felt people were telling me the truth, and it was my job to do something about it. Even though I got mad and told them I didn’t care, I would go home and look in the mirror to see what was wrong. I knew I was skinny, but I just didn’t know what was so bad about it.
I worried too much about what other people thought, and if they didn’t like what they saw, I surely didn’t want to be it.
Taking It To an Extreme
Now I look in the mirror and love it because I don’t see who I want to be or what the world wants me to be, I just see myself. I realized that there is nothing wrong with me and stopped paying attention to everyone’s stupid comments.
Thank God I never got so extreme that I felt like I was worthless, but for many girls it’s not that easy to get over feeling bad about their bodies.
Some girls starve themselves, dress in baggy clothes, or don’t want to party or go out, all because of what other people think.
It doesn’t help that girls are constantly being told what’s wrong with them. If girls were told what’s good about them, they might not worry so much.
Tashika Perry, a 16-year-old Graphic Arts student, said she gets a lot of positive comments from people about her size.
“I love my size! People don’t call me fat, they call me thick and that makes me feel good. Sometimes I think real skinny people are jealous of my size,” Tashika said.
“I don’t ever want to change my size,” Tashika said proudly. “One comment I received from a guy was: You look like a plate of umm, with a side of umm, with a umm umm on top.”
Making Girls Feel Uncomfortable
I think it’s OK to give positive comments, but not nasty hurtful ones that people sometimes take to the extreme by saying them to the person in her face.
It’s not cute to see someone always saying something bad about another, especially because it makes you wonder if that person ever talks about you. And believe me, we all know someone like that.
And the worst part is that we often hear these nasty comments right at home.
It seems like family members feel it’s their job to tell you that you’re too fat, too skinny, too tall, too loud.
Half the time we don’t care about the remarks, but when we feel uncertain about our appearance and our families add to our discomfort, those remarks hurt.
Parents Should Help, Not Hurt
Besides teaching you manners and morals, your family helps you figure out your identity. So why should parents and family members make it harder for you by telling you that you’re too fat or too skinny?
I think it’s terrible that little kids have to hear nasty comments right at home.
My 4-year-old niece already gets comments about being overweight. She just says what older girls say- that she’s not fat, she’s big-boned. She even says she’s on a diet, while asking for a second plate of macaroni and cheese with an innocent and adorable smile on her face.
For now, she doesn’t really mind the remarks because she’s still in her world of innocence and toys. But later on, I hope she doesn’t hold on to her hurt.
I love my niece’s size, and I can’t imagine her any other way. Maybe that’s how she’s supposed to be. Maybe everyone is supposed to be the way they are, and that’s why changing our bodies is so hard.
Girls: Boost Each Other Up!
To tell you the truth, there’s nothing wrong with being thick or slim. So girls shouldn’t make rude comments about each other’s bodies.
Our bodies show our uniqueness, style, identity and femininity. And when someone says something negative about your body, it affects how you feel about everything else, too.
Your weight doesn’t affect your education, talents or goals, but your self-esteem does. When that’s low, your whole life can seem low when it’s truly not.
Girls should boost up each other’s self-esteem, no matter what size they are. Even if you don’t like the way someone looks, that’s not a reason to hate her or think you’re better than her.
I think if a girl is respectable, has a nice personality, or is doing something positive, that’s the number-one thing she should be complimented on. People should comment on a girl’s personality, not on her size.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.