The Whitest Black Girl

“What are you?”
When I was a little girl, kids used to ask me this question all the time.
At first I would be surprised. Then I’d answer, “I’m Black and Puerto Rican.” I thought this would satisfy their inquiry, but I could see the rejection of my answer in their eyes.
“No you’re not,” they’d say. “You’re White.”
I remember this happening first on a cool autumn day in 1st grade. My classmates and I were doing our assigned work. All of a sudden one of them shouted out, “White girl.”
White Girl Alert
“White girl, White girl, Nicole’s a White girl,” she shouted.
“No, I’m not. My daddy is Black and my mommy is Puerto Rican,” I said.
“No, you’re not,” she screamed. “You’re White, look how light you are.” Then she started to laugh.
I looked at my arm. I was White. She was right. I began to cry.
I had my father-who is 6 foot 4 inches and has a reddish-brown complexion-pick me up from school the next day. He made that girl feel oh sooo stupid, and helped me win my argument.
Still, a couple of days later, the girl was at it again, calling me White girl. It didn’t bother me as much as the first time, though. My skin was starting to grow thick.
Always Being Asked to Choose
As a biracial child, there’s a certain tolerance level you have to build up to protect your feelings, because you’re constantly being asked to choose one side or the other.
When I go to fill out a simple form, I am forced to choose between Black (non-Hispanic), Hispanic (non-Black) and Other.
“Pick one only” is written in bold letters. Sometimes I choose “Other,” but usually I check Black and Hispanic both. When my forms come back, there’s nothing that says Hispanic. It seems as though just Black was picked for me.
But it’s not just strangers who want you to choose. It’s your family, friends and colleagues, too, whose little comments here and there choose for you.
The Whitest Black Girl
If I’m discussing something with my best friend, and we’re having a disagreement, she’ll say jokingly, “What would you know about that, White girl?”
And my 15-year-old niece, who’s Puerto Rican, defines me most of the time by calling me Black girl. She doesn’t call me T’a Nicole or Aunt Nicole, she calls me Black Girl.
One day she said, “You know, Tia, you’re the Whitest Black girl I know.”
Now when she said this, I wasn’t mad at her, because she simply said out loud what other people think. The question in my mind was, “Why does she feel the need to label me?”
From Mulatto to Multicultural
I suppose that ever since Black people were forced to come to this country, in some way or other their biracial descendants have been forced to label themselves.
Mulatto, mutt, confused, mixed, biracial, multicultural are among the many names given to describe people of a mixed race.
History tells us how Black people were brought here unwillingly, beaten, chained and stripped of their culture.
History tells us how these “mixed” children got here, too. In the beginning it was usually by force-rape by the White master of the Black slave. Sometimes it was adultery, possibly love.
Throughout History: The Lighter the Better
Sometimes their White masters made them house slaves, and gave them the tiniest bit more freedom and respect due to their lighter complexion.
This added to the resentment that field slaves carried for their lighter sisters and brothers.
After the Civil War, Black people with lighter complexions had some advantages, too.
Black sororities and fraternities segregated based on the different shades of Black. Very light-skinned Black people would sometimes try to “pass” as White, so they could receive economic, social and educational advantages they would have otherwise been denied.
Some Black people even went so far as to bleach their skin.
A Different Degree of Racism
Even now, I guess I do receive a different degree of racism than my darker counterparts.
For example, at my job, I am able to listen in on and even be a part of race discussions with White people that they wouldn’t have around someone darker than I am.
I was even told when I got offended about a comment that I wasn’t Black.
And sometimes I think some White people feel more comfortable with me than with darker Blacks.
I don’t think it’s really conscious. It’s just that a part of them relaxes because we share a common resemblance, our skin.
I’m Black and Puerto Rican
Perhaps that’s why some Black people may be offended by my color, and so they want me to declare who I really am.
But I don’t want to choose.
It makes me angry when people call me White girl because I know that that’s not true.
Besides, if my Black friends call me White girl, what they really mean is “bad.”
But it also makes me angry when people call me Black girl, ’cause that’s not true either.
When my friends call me Black girl, usually I feel loved, for a moment, because that means they’ve accepted me. But in the next moment, I feel invisible.
Half of me being recognized is just as bad as none of me being recognized. I’m Black and Puerto Rican.
I think we’re so used to thinking in terms of Black and White in this country, that often people can’t understand when there’s something, or someone, in between.
And because they can’t understand me, they try to alienate me. Kind of like when you were a kid and you were bad at a subject and earned low grades.
What came out of your mouth when you mother asked you why? “I hate that subject. I hate that teacher, she’s mean.”
Because you couldn’t understand the subject, you rejected it.
Getting Beyond the Black/White Divide
Maybe for people to feel secure with themselves and their heritage, they have to know who they’re dealing with. Boundaries have to be set.
Are you Black or White? You can’t be both. How do I socialize with you if I don’t know how to cast you?
But I think if we’re going to define ourselves, we have to get past the Black/White divide, and past the color of our skin.
Now that I’m older and I have a better understanding of my whole culture, I proudly state who I am. “I’m blessed!” That’s what I tell people when they ask me the question.
I’m also a person with a rich background.
A big part of my identity comes from my father, because we were always close.
As a little girl, my father would tell me things about my descendants that filled my heart with pride.
Even though I was always closest to my father growing up, I was closer with my mother’s side of the family.
My mother was the ninth born in a total of 15 kids. Needless to say, I have lots of cousins and they keep coming.
Two Different Grandmas, Two Different Worlds
My grandfather came to America from Puerto Rico to become a doctor, but changed his mind after he found God.
Manuel T. Sanchez became a minister. Together he and my grandmother, Pilar, built their church, Iglesia Antioqua, with sweat, determination, faith and love.
Today the church still stands on Atlantic Avenue in Brooklyn.
On Thanksgiving, my mother’s huge family would come together at my Grandma Pilar’s house.
Aside from the turkey, stuffing and cranberry sauce, there’d be arroz con gandules (rice with beans) and benin (baked pork).
Salsa and merengue would float through the air as the kids played hide-and-go-seek.
Later that night, my sister and I would visit my father’s mother, who lived right across the hall from us, my grandma Hawkins.
A second after entering the door, my cheeks would be torn from my face, my head would be rubbed, and I would grow dizzy from being tossed in the air.
My grandma would ask me if I wanted food with funny names like chitlins, collard greens and yams.
Once all the food was on my plate, I would try my best to find somewhere to put it. After all, my stomach was already swollen from the afternoon.
Black and Beautiful, Spanish and Strong
But part of me loved having two Thanksgiving dinners, and two cultures to call my own.
Hearing my grandma Hawkins’ sweet southern voice, hugging her big, soft body, hearing my abuela call “Nicolasa,” is part of me.
So is racing to the front door knowing that this tall brown man is my Daddy, and staring into my mother’s beautiful green eyes.
Knowing that my ancestors were kings and queens, Black and beautiful, Spanish and strong, is part of who I am.
It’s a feeling that I have inside, that tells me, “You are who you are, and that’s uniquely you.”
The colors of my past still shine through, if in a more subtle way, removed from what they once were.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.