“I’ve always thought it would be better to be a fake somebody than a real nobody.”
This isn’t an uncommon desire, but the man who says this is anything but common: Thomas Ripley, the main character of Patricia Highsmith’s 1955 mystery novel and now of Anthony Minghella’s film The Talented Mr. Ripley, is a sociopath who dreams of being somebody else-and will make his dream a reality by any means possible.
Ripley is a loner who scams his neighbors and daydreams of a more exciting life.
When he is sent to Mongibello, Italy, to convince the wealthy Dickie Greenleaf to return home to his family, Ripley finds himself fascinated by Dickie’s life. Dickie receives monthly allowances from his rich father, paints as a hobby (in the movie, he plays jazz), and divides the rest of his time between the beach and the Mongibello nightlife.
Taking Envy Too Far
Ripley, understandably envious, begins to impersonate his new friend in hopes of one day becoming him. Eventually he does this by killing Dickie and taking his identity. The rest of the story centers around the unavoidable obstacles Ripley encounters as a result of “becoming” someone else.
I’m sure everyone has known a person, be it a celebrity, acquaintance, or friend, of whom you think, “I would love to be him/her for just one day.” This is a familiar feeling, and that’s why so many viewers are able to see a part of themselves in Tom Ripley, even if you don’t necessarily agree with his actions.
However, Ripley doesn’t realize that wearing Dickie’s clothes and spending Dickie’s money will not turn him into Dickie. He is still Tom Ripley, and he still despises himself.
Though many of you may have heard of or seen the movie, it is much less likely that you have read the book by Patricia Highsmith on which the film is based.
The movie and book are similar in plot, but the characters are considerably different. In the movie, Ripley has been changed from sinister to shy, and Dickie turns from likable to conceited. The story was made less complex, to make the movie appealing to a wider audience.
An Unremorseful Killer…
The Tom Ripley in Patricia Highsmith’s book is cool, sophisticated and in control. He knows exactly what he is doing when he decides to murder Dickie and take over his identity.
Ripley kills because he wants to; he wants the thrill of controlling his fate. (Of course, Dickie’s money and glamorous lifestyle also play a role in Ripley’s decision.)
Ripley’s feelings about his crimes arise only once or twice during the novel, and are dismissed with a wave of the hand and an “Oh well, I did what I did so I could get ahead in my life.” Ripley shows little remorse. Because of his callousness, the reader loses sympathy for him and begins to hate him for ending Dickie’s life.
Or A Meek, Little Mouse?
In Highsmith’s novel, our sympathy goes to Dickie, who is self-assured, friendly and likable. He has his flaws (such as his mild homophobia), but the pros of his personality far outweigh the cons.
It’s true that when Dickie gets tired of Ripley hanging around and tells him to leave him alone, the reader feels upset on Ripley’s behalf. But Dickie’s disinterest in Tom is understandable.
Ripley is “weird.” He makes Dickie feel nervous and uncomfortable. Why shouldn’t Dickie distance himself from a man who scares him? (And as it turns out, Dickie’s fear of Ripley is vindicated.)
In the film, Matt Damon’s Ripley resembles a meek, little mouse who murders Dickie out of anger, and then realizes that the only way to avoid prosecution is to become him. The film portrays Dickie (Jude Law) as a selfish jerk whose favorite hobbies are drinking and cheating on his girlfriend Marge (the ever-annoying Gwyneth Paltrow).
Sympathy for a Murderer
Since Ripley is a “nicer person” than Dickie in the movie, the audience is able to overlook Dickie’s murder and hope that Ripley prevails in the end.
The film version also explores Tom Ripley’s homosexual side, which is barely hinted at in the novel. Perhaps this new addition to the movie is a result of how times have changed since 1955. Obviously, audiences today are more accepting of homosexuality than they were in the 1950s.
Then again, perhaps his homosexuality is explained in the movie because the film’s Ripley is a quiet man who seems unsure of who he is (how appropriate, then, that he may be hiding his true sexuality as well).
Manipulated into Caring
The novel is definitely more disturbing than the film version. As I read the novel, I found myself hating Ripley, being disgusted with him, and wishing that he would be brought to justice. But watching the film, I actually felt sorry for Ripley. I understood him; his actions were was a lot easier to sympathize with.
“Manipulative” may or may not be the right word to use when describing Anthony Minghella’s film, but there is no doubt that the plot of the story was altered in order to earn the character of Ripley more sympathy. I think that’s because movies usually want us to sympathize with a character. You won’t root for a character if you don’t care whether he lives or dies.
The movie includes sequences of Ripley’s dreams and haunted daily thoughts as well as a “confessional” scene where Ripley tells his lover Peter Smith-Kingsley exactly how lonely and isolated he has felt his entire life. It practically forces you to care about him.
Typical Hollywood
Highsmith’s novel is more of an achievement because she is able to keep the reader transfixed, even if you can’t sympathize with Ripley. I hated him as a character, yet I loved the book.
The film, although great, is more standard, with the mixed-up guy who murders because he has no choice. It’s for an audience who wants to go to a movie and root for the main character.
But with its themes of murder, homosexuality, jealousy, disgust, hatred, confidence and acceptance, it’s still worth watching.
“The Talented Mr. Ripley”: Is He a Monster or a Mouse?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.