The Student Advisory Council: Droppin’ Science on the Chancellor

I first heard about the Chancellor’s Student Advisory Council (SAC) last fall at a meeting of Brooklyn student leaders (I’m Student Government President at Sheephead Bay High School).
From the moment I heard about it, I knew I wanted to be part of it. The way Deputy Chancellor Ed Seto, from the Board of Education put it, a group of high school students would have the opportunity to voice their views face-to-face with the Chancellor and his staff. We would have an open dialogue with him and be able to discuss any area of school life that we felt should be addressed. Since this was my senior year, I knew I wouldn’t have another opportunity to tell the Chancellor my opinions on the problems in the schools and my suggestions on how to make them better.
More Than a Bunch of Nerds
When the SAC meetings first began, we didn’t know each other and there was a bit of tension in the room. We were curious about each other and how the council would function. One student asked a member of the Chancellor’s staff: “Are you sure we’ll fairly represent all the students? Because it seems that we’re the ‘nerds’ of our schools.”
Well, the rest of the reps didn’t agree with this assumption. One student said he was a dropout who only recently returned to his school, and wasn’t chosen because of a 90 average. He said he could identify with both dropouts and those who stayed in school. He wanted to make the system better so that fewer kids would drop out in the future.
After a few more reps spoke, it was clear that we weren’t a bunch of nerds. Some of us were honor roll students, but some weren’t. Some of us were Black, some White, some Hispanic. We were Native American, Jamaican, and Mexican. I’m Haitian. We had a great balance between males and females. Some of us came from “safe” schools, others from schools with bad reputations. We came to the table with a lot to offer because of our different backgrounds and experiences. Although we didn’t know each other, we all shared the desire to improve the schools for ourselves and our fellow students.
To create a better understanding among us, we participated in a Leadership Weekend in Pawling, N.Y. We went through a series of exercises to learn to communicate effectively. By the end of the weekend we were laughing and talking and loosening up, and we even built a fire and roasted marshmallows. We weren’t strangers anymore.
Chancellor, You May Speak
Our meetings were supposed to last two hours, but they often went on longer. After each borough council made a 15-minute presentation to the Chancellor and his staff, an open debate followed that sometimes got heated-not because of disagreements, but because we felt very strongly about the topics being discussed. We’d run out of time and have to move on to a different topic. We were frustrated by this at times.
When we did disagree, we didn’t allow the conflict to drag on. We understood where each of us was coming from when a proposal was introduced. And there were moments of humor in the midst of all the seriousness.
One time I was chairing the meeting and it was my job to “recognize” anyone who wanted to make a comment. We were discussing budget cuts and one student was telling the Chancellor (who, by the way, came to almost every one of our meetings) how unfair it was that after-school activities were in jeopardy. I then recognized another student. I didn’t see Chancellor Fernandez signaling to me that he wanted to respond to the previous comment. A member of the Chancellor’s staff told me the Chancellor’s hand was up (it seemed that everyone noticed except me). I turned to him and he said to me, “Mary, I’d like to answer that if I may.” Instead of just letting him go on, I replied, “Yes, Chancellor, you may speak.”
As soon as I said those words I was as embarrassed as I could be. Thank God he had a sense of humor, because he just said, “Thank you, Mary.” The way he said it made everyone in the room-including me-laugh out loud. He didn’t have to be nice about it, but he was, and to me that showed real class.
Student/Teacher Relations
The Chancellor would sometimes bring along members of his staff who deal directly with the topics we brought up so we would better understand Board of Education policy. Once the head of security sat in and listened to our worries about lack of security in the schools. He explained the policies regarding security officers, acknowledging that there were limits in what the guards could do and that mistakes were sometimes made.
Another topic on our agenda was teacher/student relations. We felt that communication between teachers and students had to improve greatly. Some of us suggested that teachers get involved with students in after-school programs so that both groups could get to know each other as people in a non-academic atmosphere. Some of us recommended evaluation forms where students could inform teachers anonymously about the course, how well it was taught, and what, if any, improvements could be made. Some student reps did not agree that a form was necessary, but we all agreed that something had to be done to improve student/teacher relations.
We Were Taken Seriously
When our SAC meetings first began, we doubted we would be taken seriously. Those doubts were quickly erased, because the Chancellor and his staff treated us seriously. They showed concern for our feelings and ideas, and responded to us honestly. They didn’t try to make empty promises or put down our suggestions. If a proposal we made was going to take time, they told us so. If they could estimate how much time, they did; if they couldn’t, they got back to us. For example, the Bronx reps proposed that there should be a multi-cultural curriculum implemented in the schools. The Chancellor told us that such a curriculum was already being devised and that he’d welcome our input. Sure enough, at the next SAC meeting we were all given a copy of the planned curriculum so we could make comments.
One of our big accomplishments was getting a student rep on the Board of Education in an advisory capacity. Our feeling was that the Board works for students and should hear their concerns face-to-face. Chancellor Fernandez and BOE member Carol Gresser sponsored our resolution and it was unanimously approved by the Board on May 22. It showed us that if we work for changes, they can happen.
Although I regret leaving the Council as a graduating senior, I’m happy to give another student the same opportunity and encouragement I’ve received. The Student Advisory Council has shown me that you only fail when you stop trying. As long as you try to make a difference, as long as you voice your opinions, you’re a success.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.