“Until the mid-1960s, [America had] an explicit, long-term commitment to creating character. It was the work ethic, it was honesty, right and wrong, it was not harming others, it was being vigilant in the defense of liberty. It was very clear, and we taught it,”
-Rep. Newt Gingrich, speaking the day after the Republicans won control of the U.S. Congress.
Everybody loves to beat up on the evil ’60s. If you listen to Newt Gingrich and his friends, you’d think life in America was just dandy before a bunch of “pot-smoking, counter-culture” hippies took over the country.
Of course, I guess “not harming others” and “being vigilant in the defense of liberty” meant that sheriffs could turn attack dogs on civil rights protesters in the South. And that Black people couldn’t vote, or drink from a public water fountain, or eat at a Woolworth’s lunch counter…Because that’s exactly what life in much of America was like up until the ’60s.
Separate But Equal
In fact, the U.S. Supreme Court, in its 1896 Plessy v. Ferguson decision, legitimized the Jim Crow system of two “separate but equal” societies in the South-one for Whites, the other for Blacks. This system of racial segregation governed all aspects of life: Blacks had to use different bathrooms and water fountains; attend separate schools; ride in the back of public buses; and they couldn’t register to vote.
The modern civil rights movement began in the early 1950s, when the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) launched an aggressive legal and legislative campaign to end racial segregation. It would be a long and difficult struggle because racial inequality was written into the U.S. Constitution and remained virtually unchallenged until the 1940s. Most White Americans accepted stereotypes of Blacks as lazy, ignorant and simply inferior.
A Major Victory
The NAACP’s main strategy was to challenge segregation laws in the federal courts. The group launched a series of lawsuits which culminated in 1954 in a historic Supreme Court decision. In Brown v. Board of Education, the court ruled that “in the field of public education the doctrine of ‘separate but equal’ has no place. Separate educational facilities are inherently unequal.”
In effect, the Supreme Court decided that segregation was unconstitutional. At first, it seemed as if this one court case would destroy the Southern apartheid system. But a violent White backlash proved that Blacks would have to struggle long and hard for their rights.
Violent Backlash
In 1956, a storm of racist violence swept across the South as civil rights activists and parents tried to integrate all-White schools. Black students faced rock-throwing mobs and pickets screaming, “n-ger” on their way to school. They were also harassed by White teachers and often beaten by their White classmates. Then in 1957, Governor Orval Faubus used the National Guard to prevent nine Black students from entering Central High School in Little Rock, Arkansas.
This wave of White violence continued throughout the ’50s and ’60s. White supremacists bombed dozens of Black churches and schools; they assassinated dozens of civil rights leaders; and they beat or killed hundreds of protesters. The level of White repression was especially shocking because African-Americans were making simple demands for basic rights and dignity (such as access to an education and the right to vote).
By the late 1950s, the struggle shifted from the courts to direct action. Civil rights leaders adopted nonviolent protest as their cornerstone strategy because it provided a way to deal with the legacy of White violence in the South-and throughout American history.
Since Blacks comprise a minority of the U.S. population, most civil rights leaders felt that they couldn’t afford to take a more militant approach (such as a revolt). Black churches, meanwhile, became an important organizing base and helped develop a moral commitment to nonviolence.
The Soul of the Movement
In 1956, the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. led a yearlong bus boycott in Montgomery, Alabama that shut down the city. The boycott was purely nonviolent and based on Christian ethics. “The heart and soul of the movement-noncooperation with evil, coupled with love and forgiveness-exemplified the Southern Blacks’ faith in their church and in their leaders’ gospel of avoiding armed conflict,” writes Harvard Sitkoff in The Struggle for Black Equality, a history of the civil rights movement.
According to Sitkoff, one leaflet told boycott participants: “If cursed, do not curse back. If pushed, do not push back. If struck, do not strike back, but evidence love and good will at all times.”
After winning the bus boycott in December 1956, King emerged as the leading advocate of nonviolent protest and activity. King saw nonviolence as a means to win the moral struggle against racial inequality. But other civil rights organizations, such as the Congress for Racial Equality and the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee, viewed nonviolence merely as an effective tactic.
In the early 1960s, thousands of Blacks and Northern Whites-many of them students-took part in nonviolent protests across the South. They held demonstrations in segregated cities; staged sit-ins at “Whites-only” lunch counters; and organized voter registration drives. These activities exposed civil rights to brutal White repression. As a result, a new generation of leaders like Robert Williams and Stokely Carmichael argued that African-Americans should arm themselves to combat White violence.
But even those who advocated self-defense for Blacks in the mid-60s did not turn the movement towards violence. Blacks didn’t bomb White churches, nor did they assassinate White supremacists. The self-defense strategy was intended to combat the terrorist activities of the Ku Klux Klan, White Citizens Councils and local sheriffs. The violence that was associated with the civil rights struggle did not stem from the protest movement (or the protesters), but rather from the institutions of power (the land owners, police and other Southern authorities).
Successes and Failures
Ultimately, the movement was successful in defeating segregation and in passing federal laws to protect the rights of African-Americans. The movement helped millions of Blacks gain access to education, better jobs, housing and representation in local governments, among other things. By the late ’60s, Blacks in the South could register to vote; attend integrated schools; hold public office; ride in the front of public buses; and shop at any department store.
But the civil rights struggle didn’t result in significant changes for many poor and working-class Blacks because it failed to address issues of economic inequality. Poor Blacks in rural parts of the South and in the inner cities couldn’t take advantage of their new rights because for them it was a daily struggle simply to survive.
Moreover, many activists had hoped that the defeat of segregation would also put an end to racism. They thought that the process of integration (in schools, neighborhoods, and the workplace) would force Whites to reject the stereotypes they had held for so long. But racism-and segregation-still poison American society.
Too Much Equality?
This brings us back to Newt Gingrich (the new speaker of the House of Representatives) and the current backlash against civil rights. More Black students attend predominately minority schools today than in 1954, when the Supreme Court ruled that segregated schools were unequal. School, housing and job segregation still exist because many Whites are lashing out against the hard-won victories of the 1960s. Their targets include affirmative action, school busing programs and civil rights legislation.
Unfortunately, some Whites still can’t accept the fact that an African-American can get a job because she’s qualified and intelligent (insisting instead that she’s stealing a White person’s job through affirmative action). According to a recent Times-Mirror public opinion poll, 51 percent of Whites believe that “equal rights have been pushed too far in this country.”
Perhaps that’s why there has even been a resurgence of interest in the long-discredited “scientific” claims of White superiority. For example, two social scientists, Charles Murray and Richard Herrnstein, recently wrote a book (The Bell Curve) claiming that Whites are naturally more intelligent than Blacks. The book became a best seller.
But let’s not forget that slavery was once assumed to be a permanent fact of American life. It was abolished. Nearly 100 years later, segregation was defeated. Maybe what we need is another social struggle to guarantee the civil rights of all oppressed groups: African-Americans, Latinos, Asians, immigrants, gays and lesbians. As Frederick Douglass once said, “Without struggle, there is no progress.”
The Struggle for Civil Rights: It’s Not Over Yet
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.