Each year, hundreds of thousands of high school students take one of the longest and most terrifying exams of their lives, the Scholastic Aptitude Test, otherwise known as the SAT. The exam is three hours long and is divided into six sections: two verbal, two math, one test of standard written English and an experimental section that doesn’t count toward your final score.
Many students view the SAT as the most stressful part of the college application process.
Kerri Flowers, 19, a graduate from Harry S. Truman HS, described the test in one word:
“Unfair…The test to me was hard. I feel it measures how well you guess,” she added.
“A three hour test that solely measures one’s ability to remember information should not determine one’s life,” argued Omar Freilla, 17, of Bronx Science HS.
Antoine Bryant, 17, of Hunter College HS agreed: “What it really measures is how well you can answer questions in a small amount of time because if you weren’t pressured and had more time, you could do a lot better.” But Antoine conceded that there should be some standard for college admissions. “It’s a fair way to tell how a kid is doing compared to other kids across the country.”
Whites Are Scoring Higher
Many educators also feel the test has biases-based on race, gender, culture, and geographical region.
The difference in combined SAT scores between White Americans and minority groups is significant. In a 1989 College Board study, the average SAT score for a White American was 937, while Blacks had a national average of 737. Other groups like Hispanics and Native Americans had scores that were significantly lower as well.
“In terms of minorities, in many cases, non-Whites suffer through weaker education and some of the questions are oriented from a cultural experience that suburban, White students generally have,” stated Blair Horner, testing reform director at the New York Public Interest Group (NYPIRG).
Gillian Perrone, a verbal instructor at Princeton Review, a popular SAT preparation course, agreed. She said that money was another factor in the bias. “If you have the money, you’ll have the exposure, you’ll know what they’re talking about. It’s not just White people or ‘money people,’ it’s a specific group of ‘monied White people.’ “
Biases Against Women
And women don’t get a fair shake on the SAT. The College Board reported that in 1989, the national scores for women were approximately sixty points lower than men. Since 1972, women have scored lower on the verbal and math sections of the SAT compared with men. But in classwork and Regents exams, women do just as well, if not better than men. “We’ve determined that something in the construction of the test is biased,” noted Horner.
As a result of this gap many women lose out on New York State Regents scholarships which are determined by their SAT scores.
Perrone argued that there is also a regional bias on the test. She cited one question on the analogy section that she felt was unfair-students had to know the relationship between subways and tokens. “How many people from Iowa know that you need a token to get on the subway?”
Perrone explained how preparation courses like Princeton Review work: “All that Princeton Review is doing is letting you into the mind of the person who wrote the test…if you know the person, then you can guess intelligently and get the right answer.”
Intelligent Guessing
The fact that the SAT is coachable indicates that the test isn’t just measuring what students have learned in high school, as the College Board claims. The SAT is also measuring test-taking skills.
Many people also feel that prep courses like the Princeton Review add to the unfairness of the exam because some of these courses cost hundreds of dollars. Omar said it wasn’t fair for poor kids because good prep courses are very expensive.
Kerri agreed: “I feel there should be an alternative. It [the prep course] should be given [free] in school if the kids cannot afford it.”
The College Board, the company that produces the SAT, claims that score differences are not an indication of any bias. But Horner disagreed, “The illusion of being all-knowing is more important to them than the product they produce. Just like any bureaucracy, they refuse to admit mistakes…
“Data that we’ve looked at that the state has collected shows that the SAT is virtually worthless in terms of predicting [college] grades, yet colleges still require it. They place too much emphasis on it,” stated Horner.
“Everything else should be emphasized. The things you do outside of school, extra-curriculars, grades should be weighed more and I guess your essay,” added Omar.
Perrone agreed, “There are students who do poorly [on the SAT], and go on to be great students. Like me, I did well on the SAT, but messed up in college. If someone accepted me on the basis of my SAT’s, they would be making a big mistake.”
Changes Slow In Coming
Until now, the College Board has refused to change the format of the test, but it has just approved changes to the SAT that will be implemented beginning in 1994. Some of these changes include: optional essays, some math questions without multiple-choice answers, the removal of the antonym (word opposite) section, and the option of using a calculator. Until 1994 however, students will still have to deal with the present test.
The College Board maintains that the changes to the format of the SAT were not made in response to criticism that the test was unfair to minority groups and women, but claimed the test was changed to increase its reliability. Critics of the SAT like Fairtest, and the National Center for Fair and Open Testing say the College Board revisions ignore the test’s real flaws. So although the packaging is new, it’s the same old test, they charge.
For those of you who are going to take the SAT in the future, here are some words of advice from Perrone: “Relax, two years from now, you’ll never remember the SAT anyway.”
Antoine, a two-time SAT taker acknowledged, “Despite all of our complaints, the SAT still counts, and it’s going to count for years, so just study hard so you can do the best you can.”
SIDEBAR: Some Questions Favor Males & the Wealthy
The following are actual SAT questions from past exams which show how the SAT discriminates against students (largely women and minorities) who may not be familiar with the activities of males and upper-middle class Americans.
1.DIVIDENDS: STOCKHOLDERS (A) investments: corporations(B) purchases: customers(C) royalties: authors(D) taxes: workers(E) mortgages: homeowners
This question is biased toward wealthier students. It also favored boys over girls by 15%.
2. MERCENARY: SOLDIER (A) censor: author(B) hack: writer(C) agent: performer(D) fraud: artist(E) critic: subject
This question favored boys by 16%
3. RUNNER: MARATHON (A) envoy: embassy(B) martyr: massacre(C) oarsman: regatta(D) referee: tournament(E) mortgage: homeowner
53% of Whites answered this question correctly, compared to 22% of African Americans. Source: Fairtest, National Center For Fair and Open Testing
Answers 1: C, 2: B, 3: C
